Stars Fade as Wave Rises: The NWSL Reality Check

Chicago Stars FC · 2026-10-26 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Nicole: San Diego is on a five-game winning streak. Angel City is climbing the power rankings with ruthless efficiency. And Chicago? They just got handed another zero at home, sitting sixteen in the standings with a record that reads like a cautionary tale.

Kevin: It’s not just the losses, Nicole. It’s the structural gap. When you look at the build-up play against teams like San Diego or even Houston, the press isn’t just tight—it’s suffocating. We’re seeing tactical mismatches that no amount of individual talent can fix in the final weeks.

Nicole: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network. I’m Nicole, and this is your daily deep dive into the NWSL. Joining me as always is our lead analyst, Kevin. Kevin, we’ve been talking about Maitane all week, but today we’re zooming out. The league is moving, and Chicago is watching from the bottom of the table.

Kevin: Exactly. And honestly, it’s hard to argue with the data right now. We predicted before the season ended that Chicago would finish with zero to two additional wins. Looking at the last few fixtures, including that heavy defeat to Angel City, that prediction feels almost generous.

Nicole: So here is what we are tackling today. First, we break down the division rivals and the league-wide storylines—like the World Cup host bids and international call-ups—that are reshaping the landscape around Chicago. Second, we’ll do a cold, hard comparison of how the Stars stack up against those top-tier teams tactically. And finally, we’ll discuss what these outside results mean for Vlatko Andonovski’s rebuild.

Kevin: And we will revisit that Maitane situation one last time, because if he isn’t released by tomorrow, the front office loses all credibility. Let’s get into it.

Nicole: Alright, Segment One. Let’s talk about the world around us. Because while Chicago is struggling, the NWSL is absolutely exploding with news. The headlines this week have been massive. San Diego Wave stays at number one in the ESPN Power Rankings after their fifth straight win. That is dominance.

Kevin: Right. And Angel City keeps rising. They aren’t just winning; they are controlling games. Look at that match against Chicago. Maiara Niehues had five total shots. Gisele Thompson completed forty-three accurate passes. That is controlled possession. That is what happens when a team has cohesion and a clear tactical identity.

Nicole: Meanwhile, in Chicago, the narrative is shifting toward legacy and future infrastructure. Did you see this? Chicago and Portland have officially entered the bidding process to host games for the 2031 Women's World Cup. Sources confirmed this to ESPN.

Kevin: That is huge for the city, Nicole. But it’s interesting timing. You have a team currently fighting for survival in the standings, yet the organization is looking ten years ahead. It shows ambition, sure, but it also highlights the disconnect between long-term vision and short-term performance.

Nicole: And then there’s the international angle. Michelle Alozie fired Nigeria past Comoros in the CAF qualifiers for the 2028 LA Olympics. She scored. Cruz Azul’s Uchenna Kanu also found the net. Nigeria won 2-0. Alozie is shining on the global stage, yet her club side is sitting sixteenth in the NWSL.

Kevin: It’s a classic case of individual brilliance not translating to team success. Alozie is a world-class winger. But if the midfield isn’t providing the width or the support she needs in build-up play, she’s isolated. We saw that against Houston on October 24th. The highlights showed flashes, but the structure was missing.

Nicole: There’s also the bizarre situation with the Zambia players. Due to Ebola travel restrictions following a match in Uganda, several Zambian internationals are facing a twenty-one-day quarantine. This means they will miss several weeks of NWSL action.

Kevin: This directly impacts Chicago. Remember, the Stars recently signed Racheal Kundananji from Bay FC for seven hundred thousand dollars in intraleague transfer funds. That was the first major move since Andonovski became chief soccer officer. If Kundananji is part of that affected group, or if the roster disruption affects team chemistry, it’s a blow.

Nicole: A seven-hundred-thousand-dollar investment that might be sidelined due to health protocols. That is frustrating management. And we haven’t even touched on the USWNT big board questions for the 2027 World Cup. With eight months away, coaches are asking tough questions about roster fit.

Kevin: Which puts pressure on players like Grosso and Alozie. Julia Grosso had thirty-one accurate passes against Angel City. She’s trying to control the tempo, but without a clinical finisher upfront, those passes don’t result in points. The USWNT staff is watching closely. If Chicago doesn’t click, those stars might find themselves benched for national duty.

Nicole: Let’s pivot to Segment Two. How does Chicago actually stack up against these rivals? We keep hearing about the 'gap.' Is it real? Or is it just perception?

Kevin: It’s very real. Let’s look at the Angel City game on March 15th. A 4-0 loss. Not a close game. Not a lucky goal. A complete dismantling. Angel City had more shots, more possession, and better defensive transitions. Chicago’s defensive line was exposed repeatedly.

Nicole: And Alyssa Naeher? She only made two saves. That sounds low, but it implies the defense wasn’t even getting into positions where saves were necessary. It was a breakdown before the shot was taken.

Kevin: Exactly. The press wasn’t coordinated. When opponents went through the middle, Chicago didn’t have enough bodies to block passing lanes. Compare that to San Diego. Their fifth straight win is built on high-intensity pressing and rapid transitions. Chicago is still playing a slower, disjointed game.

Nicole: We talked about Maitane yesterday. He had two total shots against Angel City. Two. In a four-goal loss. Where is his threat? We predicted earlier that he would be released. Does this performance justify that call now?

Kevin: Absolutely. It’s not just about shots. It’s about movement off the ball. He’s static. Against a team like Seattle Reign, whose highlights from October 19th showed aggressive marking, Maitane couldn’t find space. He’s occupying defenders but not creating chances. For a team trying to claw its way out of the basement, you need dynamic forwards.

Nicole: So if Maitane goes, who replaces him? We have Racheal Kundananji. But she’s new. She’s coming from Bay FC. Can she step in immediately and provide that spark?

Kevin: Kundananji is a proven scorer. But integration takes time. Andonovski brought her in for seven hundred thousand dollars because he needed quality. But quality needs system. If the system is broken, Kundananji becomes just another player staring at a crowded penalty box. The issue isn’t just the striker; it’s the lack of width in the midfield to stretch defenses.

Nicole: Julia Grosso is trying to distribute, but she’s surrounded by traffic. Thirty-one passes against Angel City is good volume, but were they progressive? Or just lateral circulation to kill time?

Kevin: Mostly lateral. Without a forward making runs behind the defensive line, Grosso has no vertical options. So she plays it safe. Safe football doesn’t win matches against top teams. It just delays the inevitable defeat.

Nicole: It’s painful to watch. Especially when you consider the resources being poured into the club. Seven hundred thousand for Kundananji. Now entering the bid for the 2031 World Cup. Yet the on-field product looks like a rebuilding year from five years ago.

Kevin: Rebuilding is fine. Stagnation is not. And right now, Chicago is stagnating while everyone else is sprinting. San Diego is flying. Angel City is clicking. Houston is competitive. Chicago is stuck in neutral.

Nicole: Before we head to our final segment, I want to take a quick moment to talk about something important. Every single day, we dig through stats, analyze tactics, and bring you this content for free. It takes a lot of late nights and early mornings to keep the Beatline running. If you love this show, please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. Your support helps us keep the signal strong and the coffee brewing. Thank you for listening.

Kevin: Thanks, everyone. Really. It means the world to us.

Nicole: Okay, Segment Three. What do these outside results mean for Chicago’s path? We know San Diego is winning. We know Angel City is rising. How does that affect the Stars’ playoff hopes or their standing?

Kevin: It means the window is closing rapidly. Sixteen in the standings. Five wins, two draws, twenty-two losses. That is a historically difficult record. With only a few games left, the mathematical probability of a playoff run is virtually non-existent. The focus now must shift entirely to next season.

Nicole: So, do we accept the prediction? Zero to two additional wins? Is that the ceiling now?

Kevin: I think so. Unless there is a massive tactical overhaul in training between now and the final whistle, they lack the cohesion to beat top teams. Beating a bottom-dweller might be possible, but against anyone with structure, they will struggle. I stand by the prediction: zero to two more wins.

Nicole: And Maitane? The clock is ticking. Do you see him wearing a Stars jersey again next season?

Kevin: No. Andonovski needs to clean house. He brought in Kundananji to upgrade the attack. Keeping Maitane sends the wrong message. It suggests the front office is hesitant to make bold moves. Release him. Clear the salary cap. Build around the players who actually fit the system.

Nicole: Bold words. But maybe necessary ones. As we look ahead, the 2031 World Cup bid is a bright spot. But tonight, the reality is harsh. Chicago is watching from the outside as the league moves on without them.

Kevin: They have to decide if they want to be a spectator sport or a contender. The money is there. The ambition is there. The execution is missing. Fix the execution, and everything else follows.

Nicole: Well, that wraps it up for today’s Beatline. We covered the division rivals, the tactical gaps, and the hard truth about Chicago’s season. If you enjoyed this analysis, please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen. Share this episode with a friend who loves the NWSL.

Kevin: Keep your eyes on the lineup changes. And keep pushing for that release. Go Stars.

Nicole: For Kevin, I’m Nicole. Thanks for tuning in to the Beatline Podcast Network. See you tomorrow.