Megan: Macklin Celebrini is twenty years old. He’s the youngest captain in franchise history. And he’s staring down a center group so crowded it might break the depth chart before the puck even drops on October second.
Steve: That’s right, Megan. We’re looking at nine centers on this roster. Nine. That is not a typo. It’s a logistical puzzle for the coaching staff that will define the first month of the season.
Megan: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we live for the hockey grind. I’m Megan, and this is your daily Sharks deep dive. Steve, how are we doing?
Steve: I’m good, Meg. Still buzzing from that Vegas win last week. Four-two away from home. The defensive structure held up, and yeah, Mason Marchment had his two-point night again.
Megan: We are officially in the thick of training camp battles. Today, we’re breaking down the three biggest roster spots up for grabs. First, who starts at center behind Captain Macklin Celebrini? Second, the left wing competition with Tyler Toffoli and others. And third, the goalie triangle involving Yaroslav Askarov, Kyle Keyser, and Alex Nedeljkovic. But first, a quick note.
Steve: Before we get into the nitty-gritty of line matchups and zone entries, if you love what we do here—digging through the API data, tracking the injuries, keeping this feed free every single day—we’d be honored if you considered supporting us. A small contribution helps cover the daily research, the editing, and keeps the lights on for this show. You can find the link in the episode description.
Megan: Thanks, Steve. Let’s jump straight into Segment One. The Center Ice Battle. Macklin Celebrini is locked in as the number one center. He’s got Logan Couture’s guidance, sure, but who plays next to him? Who takes the top-six minutes?
Steve: It’s fascinating because we have nine names listed as Centers. Alex Barre-Boulet, Ty Dellandrea, Barclay Goodrow, Cam Lund, Michael Misa, Zack Ostapchuk, Will Smith, Tyler Toffoli, and Alexander Wennberg. Plus Celebrini. That’s ten centers. Or maybe Toffoli plays wing? No, brief says C. So ten centers.
Megan: Ten centers! Okay, let’s narrow it down. From a tactical standpoint, who fits best alongside Celebrini? We need someone who can handle pressure in the neutral zone and protect the puck.
Steve: Barclay Goodrow is the obvious choice for a physical presence, but I think Alexander Wennberg is the smarter fit for a two-way game. Wennberg has experience, he reads the ice well, and he doesn’t need the puck to make an impact. He can kill penalties and forecheck hard.
Megan: Goodrow brings the grit, though. Remember, we talked about how the Sharks need to establish identity after that Vegas loss last year. Goodrow is pure energy. But Wennberg stabilizes the bottom six, which we predicted yesterday would be key given the injury list.
Steve: Exactly. And don’t forget Ty Dellandrea. He’s been getting looks in preseason. If he can translate that speed to the NHL level, he’s a dangerous option on the second line. But defensively? Wennberg is safer.
Megan: What about the younger guys? Will Smith and Cam Lund. They’re talented, but are they ready for top-six minutes against teams like Florida or Vegas?
Steve: Not yet. Not against elite competition. You want them in the middle-six, grinding out lines three and four. Your core needs to be Celebrini, then either Wennberg or Goodrow depending on the opponent. Then Dellandrea or Lund for speed.
Megan: So, the hierarchy: Celebrini, Wennberg/Goodrow, Dellandrea/Lund. What about Tyler Toffoli? Is he really a center?
Steve: If the roster lists him as C, he’ll take some faceoffs. But offensively, he’s a sniper. You want him shooting more than winning dots. Unless Goodrow gets injured, Toffoli is likely shifting to wing or playing on a power-play unit centered by someone else.
Megan: Alright, moving on. Segment Two: Left Wing and Right Wing Battles. We have Mason Marchment, Quentin Musty, Kiefer Sherwood, Ivar Stenberg on the left. And Adam Gaudette, Patrick Giles, Collin Graf, Brett Leason on the right.
Steve: This is where the depth gets real interesting. Mason Marchment is clearly the leader there. Big body, net-front presence. He scored twice against Vegas. He’s your number one left winger.
Megan: And then who’s fighting for the other spots? Kiefer Sherwood has that edge. Quentin Musty is a grinder. Ivar Stenberg is young and fast.
Steve: Sherwood vs. Musty is the battle for the fourth line. Sherwood brings the aggression, which fits the new coach’s style. Musty is reliable, but Sherwood wins the tough battles along the boards.
Megan: On the right side, Collin Graf is trending up. We predicted he’d score key goals, and he’s been delivering. Who’s competing with him?
Steve: Brett Leason and Adam Gaudette. Leason has size, but Graf has the finish. In my opinion, Graf holds the job unless he goes cold. Gaudette is versatile, can play both wings, but Graf feels like the permanent fixture on line two or three.
Megan: What about the defense corps? Darnell Nurse, Jacob Trouba, Dmitry Orlov. That’s a heavy hit list.
Steve: Nurse and Trouba are your shutdown pair. Orlov is the veteran leader. But look at the younger guys: Sam Dickinson, Mattias Havelid, Michael Fisher. They’re fighting for those last two spots. The team is standing first in the Pacific, but that’s preseason stats. Regular season defense requires consistency.
Megan: Right. And with the injury list being significant, these younger guys might get their shot sooner than later. If Trouba or Nurse misses time, who steps in?
Steve: Michael Kesselring. He’s steady. He won’t make mistakes. In a tight game against Florida, you want reliability over flash. Kesselring pairs well with Dickinson if they need to go young.
Megan: Okay, Segment Three. The Goalie Situation. This is the big one. Yaroslav Askarov, Kyle Keyser, Alex Nedeljkovic. Three goalies. Who starts against Florida?
Steve: Askarov is the future. He’s young, he’s hungry, and he has the tools. But does he have the stamina for a full season? Keyser is the experienced backup. Nedeljkovic is the vet.
Megan: I think Askarov gets the nod early. Why? Because the Sharks are building around Macklin Celebrini. You want your goalie built around the same youth movement. Askarov provides that continuity.
Steve: But watch the first period. If Askarov gives up a soft goal, Keyser might slide in. Keyser is calm under pressure. He’s seen more NHL action than Askarov. If the Sharks are struggling, they’ll turn to Keyser.
Megan: So, Askarov starts, Keyser backs him up. Nedeljkovic is the insurance policy. What happens if Askarov struggles? Do they call up someone from San Jose’s system?
Steve: Unlikely. The AHL affiliate isn’t throwing up anyone who can immediately replace Askarov. If Askarov struggles, it’s either Keyser or a buy-in move. But for now, Askarov is the man.
Megan: Let’s recap the roster cuts. Who’s likely headed back to the minors? I’m thinking Zack Ostapchuk and Michael Misa. Too many centers, not enough room.
Steve: Agreed. Ostapchuk and Misa are depth pieces. When the lineup is set, they’re the first ones cut. Also, maybe Patrick Giles on the right wing. Graf and Leason seem ahead of him.
Megan: And who’s trending up? Collin Graf, obviously. We said he’d score, and he’s earning it. Also, Ty Dellandrea. If he locks down that second-line center role, he’s a breakout star.
Steve: Dellandrea is the sleeper. Everyone is watching Celebrini, but Dellandrea is the engine that could make the second unit deadly. If he wins that job, expect him to see 14-15 minutes a night.
Megan: So there you have it. Ten centers, a goalie race, and a left wing battle that will keep fans guessing until the first puck drop. Macklin Celebrini is ready to lead, but the depth chart is stacked.
Steve: The Sharks are sitting first in the Pacific, but Florida is coming to town. This roster battle isn’t just about pride; it’s about survival. Every shift counts now.
Megan: Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network. If you enjoyed this breakdown, please subscribe, rate, and review wherever you get your podcasts. Share this with a fellow Shark fan!
Steve: Keep your sticks on the ice, and let’s hope Askarov stays hot. Go Sharks!
Megan: I’m Megan, joined by Steve. See you tomorrow for more daily Sharks coverage!