Gina: Ross Colton is staring down the barrel of his career. Or maybe it’s Jonathan Marchessault. Or maybe, just maybe, it’s a rookie named Mavrik Bourque who hasn’t even laced up in an NHL game yet but is already eating the air out of the locker room. We are breaking down exactly who is winning the battles for spots on this Nashville roster right now.
Wes: It’s not just about feelings, Gina. It’s about ice time. And with the Minnesota Wild coming to town on October 2nd, those decisions aren't hypothetical anymore. They’re immediate. If you missed our look at the neutral zone vulnerabilities last week, you know we left some questions hanging. Today, we answer them with names and numbers.
Gina: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Gina, your lead host. This is 'The Beatline,' America’s number one daily sports podcast. I’m joined by the man who knows more about line matchups than any human should, Wes. Wes, welcome back.
Wes: Hey Gina. Great to be here. Look, after that 0-6 shutout loss to Carolina, there’s a lot of noise out there. But inside the building? It’s quiet. Focused. And very competitive. That’s what we’re talking about today.
Gina: That’s right. Three things coming up. First, we dive into the most critical battle of training camp: the center depth chart. Who gets the second-line spot? Second, we look at the defense corps and whether Roman Josi is truly untouchable or if someone is closing the gap. And third, the goalie situation. Juuse Saros is the guy, but Justus Annunen is knocking hard on the door. Let’s get into it.
Gina: Okay, let’s start with the big one. Centers. We have Steven Stamkos leading the charge, obviously. He’s the captain. He’s the engine. But behind him? It’s a mess on paper if you don’t know the team well. Ryan O’Reilly is there for stability. But then you’ve got Alexander Kerfoot, Ross Colton, Jack Drury, Adam Edstrom, and Mavrik Bourque. Where does the competition actually lie?
Wes: Right. So, if we’re looking at the top six, it’s pretty clear. Stamkos on the first line. O’Reilly anchoring the second. That leaves the third line spot as the primary battleground. And honestly, Gina, I think Ross Colton has the edge right now.
Gina: Colton? Really? I mean, he’s gritty. He works hard. But Mavrik Bourque... the kid has skill. He’s young, he’s fast. Isn’t he the future?
Wes: He’s the future, sure. But the present needs two-way reliability. Colton can forecheck. He can kill penalties. He understands structure. Bourque is raw. He’s going to need time. I think Kerfoot might actually steal that third-line role because of his versatility, but Colton is the most complete player in that group outside of Stamkos and O’Reilly.
Gina: I hear you. Structure over flash. But what about Jack Drury? He’s got that playmaking vision. If the Preds want to fix that offensive stagnation we talked about against Carolina, maybe they need more creativity from the middle.
Wes: Drury is a special teams asset. Don’t get me wrong. But in five-on-five, against a team like the Wild, you need physicality. You need to win board battles. Drury struggles with that size mismatch. I think he makes the team, but as a fourth-line grinder or a power-play specialist, not a starter.
Gina: So, Stamkos, O’Reilly, Colton/Kerfoot, Drury/Edsworth. What about Adam Edstrom? The Swede is huge. Literally.
Wes: Edstrom is a project. He’s got size, but his skating isn’t NHL-ready yet. He’ll likely start on the taxi squad or go to the AHL. He’s not battling for a regular spot right now. It’s between Kerfoot and Colton for that third-line gig, and honestly, I’d bet on Kerfoot because of his experience. He knows how to play in tight games.
Gina: Okay, so Kerfoot wins the day. But wait—what about Filip Forsberg? He’s listed as a Left Wing, but doesn’t he sometimes slide into the center when needed? Or is that strictly a wing role now?
Wes: No, Forsberg is a winger. Always has been. His shot is too good to waste on faceoffs. He’s playing left wing next to Stamkos or O’Reilly. He’s not touching the dot unless it’s an emergency. So, the center battle is real. And I think it comes down to who can handle the pressure of the third line without making mistakes.
Gina: Fair point. So, Colton or Kerfoot. Got it. Now, let’s move to the blue line. Roman Josi is the king. Everyone knows that. But who’s fighting for the other spots? We have Nicolas Hague, Brady Skjei, Nick Perbix, Ilya Lyubushkin, and newcomers like William Trudeau and Ryan Ufko.
Wes: Josi is the anchor. He’s going to play 25 minutes a night. No debate. The battle is for the remaining four spots. And I think Nicolas Hague is solidifying his role. He’s big, he’s mobile enough. He pairs well with Josi sometimes when they need to slow the game down.
Gina: And Skjei? He’s been here a while. Is he losing his spot?
Wes: Skjei is safe. He’s a veteran presence. But he’s not starting every game. I think we see a rotation between Hague, Skjei, and maybe Nick Perbix. Perbix has that speed. If the Preds want to escape the neutral zone trap like they did against Carolina, they need speed on the back end. Perbix provides that.
Gina: Speed vs. Size. That’s the theme. What about Ilya Lyubushkin? He’s tough. He’s physical.
Wes: Lyubushkin is a penalty-kill specialist. He’s not going to log heavy minutes at even strength. He’s there to shutdown the top lines of opposing teams. So, he makes the team, but he’s not a everyday starter. Same with William Trudeau—he’s a defensive defenseman. Good for specific matchups.
Gina: So, the core is Josi, Hague, Skjei, Perbix. Then Lyubushkin and Trudeau as depth. What about Adam Wilsby? He was in the mix before.
Wes: Wilsby is interesting. He’s versatile. He can play both sides. But with the current roster construction, I think he’s competing for a spot against Ryan Ufko. Ufko is younger, faster. Wilsby is older, smarter. It’s a toss-up. But I lean towards Ufko because of the speed factor.
Gina: Speed wins again. Okay, so we’ve got centers and defense. Let’s talk wings. Filip Forsberg is locked in. What about the right side? Jonathan Marchessault is there. Matthew Wood. Nils Hoglander. Reid Schaefer.
Wes: Marchessault is the leader on that wing. He’s experienced. He knows how to score. But Hoglander? The kid is a terror. He presses the puck. He creates chaos. I think he earns a spot over Wood because of his energy. Wood is good, but Hoglander brings that intangible grit.
Gina: Chaos is good. Especially after that 0-6 loss. We needed some chaos. Okay, Wes, this has been intense. Before we break for the ad, let me ask you this: if you had to pick ONE player from this entire roster to carry the load against the Wild, who is it?
Wes: Steven Stamkos. Hands down. When the pressure is on, you go to the best shooter in the world. He’s the heartbeat of this team.
Gina: Stamkos. Agreed. Stick with us, folks. We’re taking a quick break, but when we come back, we’re diving into the goalie controversy and predicting who’s getting cut before opening night. Don’t go anywhere.
Gina: We are back. Welcome to the Beatline. If you enjoyed our deep dive into the Predators' roster battles, please consider supporting the show. It helps keep us free and daily. Check the link in the episode description.
Wes: Exactly. Your support means the world. Now, let’s wrap up. Who’s trending up? Mavrik Bourque. Who’s trending down? Jack Drury, maybe. He needs to step up his physical game.
Gina: Solid takes. Thanks for listening, Nashville. Go Preds!