Brooke: Ten centers. One roster spot left to fight for. And a goaltender who just signed a deal that changes the entire defensive philosophy of this team. If you think the Columbus Blue Jackets are just waiting around for Zach Werenski’s decision, you’re not looking at the depth chart closely enough.
Tony: It’s not just about Werenski anymore, Brooke. We’ve got Jet Greaves locked in for three years and fifteen million dollars, Cole Sillinger upped to thirteen point eight seven five, and now we’re staring down a positional group that has more bodies than headshots. This is where seasons are won or lost before the puck even drops in Detroit on the twenty-first.
Brooke: Welcome to today’s Beatline Podcast Network episode! I’m Brooke, and this is Tony. We are breaking down the most critical roster battles in the NHL right now, starting with the Blue Jackets. Today we’re talking about the center ice chaos, the defensive pairings that might surprise you, and who is trending up as training camp gets real.
Tony: That’s right. We’re going deep into the numbers. We’ll look at why Kent Johnson and Isac Lundestrom are in a dogfight, how Charlie Coyle’s role is shifting, and whether Boston Buckberger can hold off the veterans on the blue line. Let’s get into it.
Brooke: Okay, Tony, let’s start with the big one. The center position. We have ten names listed here. Charlie Coyle, Sean Monahan, Cole Sillinger, Kent Johnson, Isac Lundestrom, Oiva Keskinen, Luca Del Bel Belluz, Max McCue, Luca Pinelli, Owen Sillinger, and Jack Williams. That is eleven actually. How do we even fit them?
Tony: It’s crowded, Brooke. It’s extremely crowded. But if you look at the competitive hierarchy, it really comes down to four guys battling for two spots behind the established top line. You’ve got Cole Sillinger, who just avoided arbitration with that three-year deal. He’s a rock. Then you’ve got Kent Johnson, who we predicted would score on opening night against Buffalo last time. And then Isac Lundestrom and Charlie Coyle.
Brooke: Right. So Sillinger and Johnson seem like locks? What about Coyle? He’s a veteran presence. Does he drop to the third line, or does he push someone else out?
Tony: Coyle is interesting because he’s versatile. He can play wing, but his best value to this team is in the middle. I think he’s pushing for that third-line pivot spot. But here’s the kicker: Lundestrom. He’s been underutilized. If he brings his two-way game and forechecking intensity, he could steal a spot from Coyle or even Sillinger if the coaching staff wants more speed.
Brooke: So we’re looking at Sillinger, Johnson, Lundestrom, and Coyle as the main contenders. What about the younger guys? Oiva Keskinen? Max McCue?
Tony: Keskinen and McCue are likely camping for ECHL call-ups or bottom-six energy. They’re not winning the main roster jobs yet. The competition is really between the established players and the emerging talents like Lundestrom. It’s a battle of experience versus upside.
Brooke: And don’t forget the Sillinger name! Cole and Owen. Two Sillingers on the same team. That’s a unique dynamic. Owen’s still developing, right?
Tony: Owen is talented, but he’s further down the chain. Cole is the one who needs to prove he’s the centerpiece of this rebuild alongside Werenski. The pressure is on Cole to be the steady hand while the others fight for minutes.
Brooke: So, final verdict on centers? Sillinger and Johnson are the top two. Lundestrom is the wildcard. Coyle is the veteran anchor. Everyone else is fighting for scraps.
Brooke: Before we move on to the next segment, I want to take a quick breath. We know you love the Blue Jackets coverage, and we want to keep bringing it to you every single day, completely free, with no ads and no paywall. Your support is what makes this possible. If you can chip in to help us keep the show running smoothly, please check out the link in the episode description. Thank you for being part of our community.
Tony: Let’s talk defense. The Blue Jackets have a massive group here. Ivan Provorov, Zach Werenski, Carson Soucy, Damon Severson, Dante Fabbro, Erik Gudbranson, Boston Buckberger, Caleb MacDonald, and several others. It’s a lot of bodies.
Brooke: Ivan Provorov and Zach Werenski are clearly the top pair. That’s settled. But the second pair is where it gets messy. Who are you seeing as the core there?
Tony: Carson Soucy and Damon Severson. They bring size and physicality. But wait, Jet Greaves’ new contract changes things. With Greaves locking down netminding, the defense needs to be more mobile to support him. Evan Bouchard-style mobility isn’t here, but maybe Boston Buckberger offers that spark.
Brooke: Boston Buckberger? Really? He’s a young defenseman. Do you think he pushes someone like Dante Fabbro or Erik Gudbranson?
Tony: Absolutely. Fabbro and Gudbranson are reliable, but they’re older. Buckberger is hungry. If he wins a spot, it signals a shift toward youth and speed. It’s a bold move, but necessary if we want to compete with Carolina and Detroit.
Brooke: So, Provorov-Werenski, Soucy-Severson, and Buckberger getting the third pair look. What about the fourth line?
Tony: Corson Ceulemans, Jake Christiansen, and maybe Guillaume Richard. It’s a mix of raw talent and organizational depth. They’ll be playing for their lives in camp.
Brooke: And let’s not forget Valeri Nichushkin on the wing. He’s a RW, but his presence affects the whole lineup. How does he fit with all these forwards?
Tony: Nichushkin is an elite scorer. He’s likely playing on the top line with Kirill Marchenko and Conor Garland. His presence forces other teams to double-team, which opens up space for everyone else. He’s the catalyst.
Brooke: Alright, final segment. Roster cuts. Who’s leaving? We have players like James Malatesta, Ryan Lomberg, Mathieu Olivier, and Danton Heinen. One of them has to go.
Tony: Lomberg is tough, but he’s aging. He might be the easiest cut. Malatesta has skill, but he’s inconsistent. Olivier brings grit, but we have Miles Wood for that.
Brooke: So Lomberg is the odds-on favorite to be sent down or released? What about the goalies? Just Greaves and...?
Tony: Greaves is the starter. The backup spot is wide open. Probably a call-up from the AHL. No clear incumbent yet.
Brooke: Who is trending up? Who is trending down?
Tony: Trending up: Kent Johnson and Boston Buckberger. Trending down: Ryan Lomberg and Erik Gudbranson.
Brooke: There you have it. The Blue Jackets are shaping up to be a dangerous team in the Metropolitan Division. We’ve covered the center chaos, the defensive shifts, and the key roster moves. Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and review us on your favorite podcast app. Share this episode with a fellow Blue Jackets fan!
Tony: We’ll see you after the season opener against Detroit. Go Jackets!