Blue Jackets Mailbag: Werenski's Future, Sillinger Deal, and Center Battles

Columbus Blue Jackets · 2026-09-17 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Brooke: The offseason drama is over, but the real questions are just starting. Is Zach Werenski staying? Did we just lock in our starting goalie? And who actually makes the lineup from this massive group of centers? We’re answering it all today.

Tony: It’s a lot to unpack. We’ve got contract extensions, roster battles, and a team that’s sitting pretty at first in the Metropolitan Division even before puck drop. Let’s get into the mailbag.

Brooke: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Brooke, your lead host, and alongside me as always is Tony, the man with the tactical tape. Good morning, Columbus!

Tony: Morning everyone. It’s good to be back. The preseason is looming, and there is a lot of noise to cut through.

Brooke: Here is what we are tackling today. First, we’re diving deep into the Zach Werenski situation and what his public comments really mean for the franchise's long-term plans. Second, we’re looking at the new contracts for Cole Sillinger and Jet Greaves, and how they change the defensive and forward core. And third, we have to talk about the center ice logjam—seven centers fighting for spots, and who wins?

Tony: Exactly. And if you enjoyed yesterday’s breakdown on the defensive pairings, you’re going to love today’s answers because we’re getting specific about line matchups and zone entries.

Brooke: Before we jump into the first question, a quick note. If today’s episode helped you feel more confident about the Jackets' outlook or taught you something new about these new contracts, please consider supporting the show. It keeps us free and daily. Just head to the link in the episode description. Now, let’s get to the questions.

Brooke: Our first question comes from Sarah from Westerville. She writes: 'Zach Werenski says he believes fans are still on his side after a turbulent offseason. Does this mean he’s fully committed to staying in Columbus, or is he just managing expectations?' Tony, walk us through this.

Tony: Well, Sarah, you have to look at the context. Werenski reiterated recently that his future is tied to contending. He has two seasons left on his current deal, but he clearly wants to remain with the Blue Jackets long term. When a player of his caliber says he expects a positive reception, it usually signals he’s done with the speculation. He’s ready to work.

Brooke: So, is he staying? The headlines say he believes fans are on his side, which implies he’s planning to be here for the next game against Detroit and beyond. But does the front office have any leverage now?

Tony: I think the dynamic has shifted in Columbus's favor. By extending Cole Sillinger and Jet Greaves, the team is signaling stability. Werenski sees a team that is building around its core, not tearing it down. He’s likely feeling good about the direction under General Manager Jarmo Kekalainen.

Brooke: That makes sense. It’s about culture. You don’t want to leave a place where the organization is actively investing in young talent like Sillinger and Greaves. Next question, this one from @BuckeyeBlues. He asks: 'With the NHL producing games for the Blue Jackets centrally, how does that affect our identity on the ice? Does centralized production change how we play?'

Tony: Interesting question. Honestly, centralized production by the league doesn’t change the hockey. It changes the broadcast quality. But it does signal that the NHL views Columbus as a key market for the coming season. Being grouped with Carolina, Minnesota, and St. Louis suggests the league sees us as a competitive entity worth highlighting.

Brooke: So it’s more of a marketing win than a tactical one? Because tactically, I still see Ivan Provorov and Zach Werenski driving the power play.

Tony: Exactly. The on-ice product is driven by the coaching staff and the players. Centralized production just means more eyes on those plays. It raises the stakes for visibility. If you want national attention, you have to produce highlights. And with Valeri Nichushkin and Kirill Marchenko on the wing, we should have plenty of those.

Brooke: Right. Nichushkin brings that physicality and scoring touch. Okay, last question for this segment from Mike in Dublin. 'Jet Greaves signed a three-year, $15 million deal. Is he the clear starter, or do we expect a goaltending competition?'

Tony: When you sign a goalie to a three-year, $15 million contract through the 2028-29 season, that is a statement. That is not a backup deal. That is a number-one commitment. Greaves is the guy. Unless he gets injured or completely breaks down, he’s starting every game against the Red Wings and the Sabres.

Brooke: That provides a huge amount of stability. Knowing you have your netminder locked up for three years allows the defensemen to play with more confidence. They know someone is there.

Tony: Precisely. It frees up cap space later and removes the uncertainty. We talked about this yesterday—the goal is to build a contender, and locking in your goalie early is a hallmark of successful franchises.

Brooke: Great insights. Stick with us—we’re moving into the heart of the roster battle. Who makes the cut among those centers? Don’t go anywhere.

Brooke: We are back. This is Segment Two, and we are talking roster construction. Our next question is from Lisa in Gahanna. She asks: 'There are seven centers listed on the roster: Coyle, Del Bel Belluz, Johnson, Keskinen, Lundestrom, McCue, Monahan, Pinelli, Sillinger, and Owen Sillinger. Wait, that’s more than seven. How many actually make the playoff roster?'

Tony: Lisa, you caught me. There are ten centers listed. That is a lot of bodies. But realistically, you need three to four top-six centers and maybe a fourth liner. The big names are Kent Johnson, Cole Sillinger, and Charlie Coyle. Sean Monahan brings experience. The rest will be fighting for bottom-six roles or ETOE spots.

Brooke: Cole Sillinger just signed that three-year, $13.875 million extension. Does that secure his spot as a top-six fixture?

Tony: Absolutely. That arbitration avoidance deal shows the team believes in him. He’s going to be a mainstay. He’s young, he’s fast, and he fits the modern center mold. He’s not cutting anyone else out of the top six necessarily, but he’s definitely ahead of the pack in terms of organizational investment.

Brooke: What about Kent Johnson? He’s been developing for a few years now. Is he the other cornerstone alongside Sillinger?

Tony: Yes. Johnson has the skill set to be a primary scorer. If he can maintain consistency in the neutral zone and finish off chances, he’s a top-two center. The key for both Sillinger and Johnson is their defensive responsibility. They need to backcheck effectively.

Brooke: And then you have veterans like Charlie Coyle and Sean Monahan. Do they push for top-six time?

Tony: Coyle is a grinder. He’ll win faceoffs and kill penalties. Monahan provides stability. But the team is clearly betting on youth. I’d expect Sillinger and Johnson to start the season in the top six, with Coyle and Monahan providing depth and leadership on lines two and three.

Brooke: Okay, so that leaves Oiva Keskinen, Max McCue, Luca Del Bel Belluz, Isac Lundestrom, Luca Pinelli, and Owen Sillinger. Who has the best shot at making the final 23-man roster?

Tony: Owen Sillinger has the name recognition and the hockey IQ. Lundestrom is a reliable two-way player. Keskinen brings speed. I think it comes down to training camp performance. Whoever shows the best forecheck and zone entry skills will make the cut.

Brooke: It’s going to be a tight competition. One wrong shift and you’re sent to the AHL. Speaking of shifts, let’s talk defense. Question from @JacketFan2026: 'Ivan Provorov and Zach Werenski are the top pair, but who is the third pair? Dante Fabbro? Damon Severson? Or is it someone else?'

Tony: This is a crucial matchup. With Provorov and Werenski logging heavy minutes, you need a shutdown third pair. Carson Soucy and Erik Gudbranson bring size. But Dante Fabbro has offensive upside. I’d expect Fabbro to play significant minutes, especially on the power play if Werenski is resting.

Brooke: So it’s not just about size; it’s about balancing the pairings. You need guys who can move the puck out of the zone quickly.

Tony: Exactly. If you get trapped in your own end, you’re dead. Fabbro and maybe Colton White can help alleviate that pressure. They need to execute clean zone exits.

Brooke: Alright, we’ve got one more segment. This is the fun part. A hypothetical scenario and some lightning rounds. Stay tuned.

Brooke: Segment Three! Let’s do a hypothetical. What if Valeri Nichushkin and Conor Garland form a line together? How does that change the Blue Jackets’ offense?

Tony: That would be scary. Nichushkin is a power forward, and Garland is a skilled playmaker. If they can connect, you’re looking at a lethal combination. They could exploit mismatches against slower defenders. It adds a layer of unpredictability to the top six.

Brooke: I love that image. Nichushkin crashing the net while Garland sets up the play. Okay, lightning round. Quick takes. First topic: Kirill Marchenko scoring on opening night against the Buffalo Sabres. My prediction: Yes.

Tony: I agree. Marchenko has been working on his shot all summer. Against Buffalo, who might be shaky defensively, I see him cashing in. It’s a high-probability outcome.

Brooke: Second topic: Will the Blue Jackets finish first in the Metropolitan Division? Last year we said Wild Card, but things have changed.

Tony: With the extensions and the stability, I’m shifting my pick. I think they finish first. Carolina is tough, but Columbus looks healthier and deeper now.

Brooke: Third topic: Boston Buckberger. Will he crack the NHL roster this year?

Tony: Unlikely. He’s too raw. He needs more development in the minors. I’d expect him to start in the AHL.

Brooke: Final topic: The next game against Detroit. Who wins?

Tony: Columbus. Home ice advantage, fresh legs, and Greaves in net. It’s a solid pick for the opener.

Brooke: That’s our show for today! We covered Werenski’s future, the Sillinger and Greaves deals, the center logjam, and our predictions for opening night. Huge thanks to Sarah, Mike, Lisa, and @BuckeyeBlues for your questions.

Tony: If you liked the analysis, please subscribe, rate, and review the show. It helps us reach more Blue Jackets fans across Ohio and beyond.

Brooke: Don’t forget to check out the link in the description if you want to support the network directly. Your contributions keep this show free and daily. See you tomorrow for another episode!

Tony: Go Jackets!