Werenski's Future, Greaves' Deal & The Seven-Center Battle: Blue Jackets Mailbag

Columbus Blue Jackets · 2026-09-16 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Brooke: Is the heart of this team staying? Zach Werenski says he believes the fans are still behind him, but after a turbulent offseason that had everyone holding their breath, is that enough to keep Columbus’s captain locked in for the long haul? And while we’re asking big questions, Jet Greaves just signed a massive three-year deal. Is he ready to be the guy?

Tony: It’s a pivotal moment for the Blue Jackets. We’ve got a roster full of new faces and old questions. From Cole Sillinger avoiding arbitration to the seven-center competition heating up, there is a lot to unpack. This is your daily dose of hockey truth.

Brooke: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Brooke, and this is The Daily Jacket. Joining me as always is Tony. Tony, good morning.

Tony: Good morning, Brooke. It’s going to be a busy one today. We’re diving into the mailbag, answering your burning questions about the upcoming season.

Brooke: Here is what we are covering: First, we tackle the Zach Werenski situation head-on. Does his public confidence match the front office's actions? Second, we break down the seven-center battle—Kent Johnson, Cole Sillinger, Sean Monahan, who starts on opening night? And third, we look at the defensive corps with Ivan Provorov, Dante Fabbro, and the new additions like Valeri Nichushkin up front.

Tony: And finally, we’ll talk about Jet Greaves’ contract and whether that goaltending tandem can hold up when the pressure mounts in the Metropolitan Division.

Brooke: Before we get into the emails, quick favor. If you love hearing us break down these complex roster moves and trade implications, please consider supporting the show. Your contributions directly fund the daily research, the editing, and keep the feed running so we can bring you this analysis every single day. Just check the link in the episode description.

Tony: We appreciate it. It helps us stay independent and keep the content free for all of you. Now, let’s open the mailbag.

Brooke: First question comes from Sarah in Cleveland. She writes: 'Zach Werenski said he believes the fans are still on his side. He also reiterated that his future is tied to contending. With two years left on his current deal, do you think he stays past that?' Tony, start us off.

Tony: It’s a fascinating dynamic, Sarah. Werenski is being very transparent. He knows the expectations. The Blue Jackets are currently first in the Metropolitan Division, which is wild considering where they were a few years ago. But being first now doesn’t mean they’re a Cup contender yet. He wants to win deep. If this team isn’t pushing for the Conference Final, he’s going to test the market in two years.

Brooke: But does he leave? He’s been here his whole career. The fanbase loves him. The headlines say he expects a positive reception even after the turbulence. Do you think the organization will go all-in to keep him?

Tony: I think they have to. Look at the contract extensions we’ve seen recently. Cole Sillinger just avoided arbitration with a three-year, $13.875 million deal. That’s significant. It shows the front office is trying to lock up core young talent. If they want Werenski back, they need to build around him. They can’t just rely on his loyalty. They need to prove they’re contenders.

Brooke: What about the next email? @HockeyFan88 asks: 'With Jet Greaves signing a three-year, $15 million deal, is he the clear starter? Or is this a platoon system?' This is huge news. $15 million over three years is not a backup contract.

Tony: No, it’s absolutely not a backup contract. In today’s NHL, that kind of money signals intent. Greaves is likely the number one goalie heading into camp. The question is, who is the backup? The brief doesn’t list other goalies beyond Greaves, but typically, you don’t put a $5 million-a-year goalie behind someone unless you’re very confident in them. This feels like Greaves is the man. If he struggles early, though, that cap hit becomes tricky.

Brooke: Right. And remember, the Blue Jackets are playing the Detroit Red Wings on September 21st. That’s the home opener. If Greaves starts there, he needs to be sharp. The forecheck against Detroit can be brutal. Can he handle the pace?

Tony: He has to be. But look at the defensive support. They brought in Dante Fabbro and Damon Severson. Fabbro is an offensive defenseman, Severson is steady. If they can kill penalties and limit high-danger chances, Greaves gets easier looks. The key is neutral-zone play. If they trap effectively, Greaves wins games. If they get stretched, he’s exposed.

Brooke: Let’s move to the roster battles. Marcus in Cincinnati asks: 'Seven centers. Kent Johnson, Cole Sillinger, Sean Monahan, Charlie Coyle, Isac Lundestrom, Max McCue, Owen Sillinger. Who makes the final four?' This is the biggest debate in Columbus right now.

Tony: Seven centers is a luxury problem, but it’s also a headache. Let’s look at the veterans. Charlie Coyle and Sean Monahan are established NHLers. They’re likely top-six fixtures. Coyle brings physicality, Monahan brings playmaking. Then you have Kent Johnson and Cole Sillinger. These are the guys the future is built on. Kent is dynamic, Cole is a two-way force. Those four seem like locks.

Brooke: So what happens to the others? Isac Lundestrom, Max McCue, Owen Sillinger? Are they depth or do they get sent down?

Tony: Lundestrom is a strong candidate for the fourth line because he can defend and face tough matchups. Max McCue might be the odd man out if they want more size. Owen Sillinger is young, maybe he starts in AHL to develop. But don’t be surprised if Lundestrom plays significant minutes. He’s a grinder. He fits the style we talked about yesterday—hard-nosed hockey.

Brooke: And what about Kirill Marchenko? He’s listed as a RW, but does he ever play center? No, he’s pure wing. But with the center crunch, do you see him shifting?

Tony: No, Marchenko stays on the wing. He’s too skilled to waste on center duty unless there’s an injury crisis. He’s your top-line winger. Pair him with someone like Conor Garland or Valeri Nichushkin, and you have serious firepower. Nichushkin adds that size and speed combo that really bothers defenses.

Brooke: Okay, let’s talk defense. Jennifer in Dayton asks: 'Ivan Provorov and Zach Werenski are the top pair, obviously. But who is the third pair? Dante Fabbro, Colton White, Erik Gudbranson? There are so many names.' How do you structure the blue line?

Tony: This is where the coaching staff earns their paycheck. You have Provorov-Werenski as the elite pair. Then you need a shutdown pair and an energy pair. Erik Gudbranson is your classic shutdown defender. Big, physical, limits damage. He pairs well with someone like Carson Soucy or Brendan Smith for heavy minutes. Then Dante Fabbro and Colton White likely form the third pair. Fabbro moves the puck, White provides stability.

Brooke: What about Boston Buckberger? He’s a younger guy. Does he have a shot at the NHL roster?

Tony: Buckberger is intriguing. He’s got size and mobility. But with guys like Fabbro and White already there, he might need to start in the AHL to get consistent ice time. You don’t rush kids into the NHL unless they’re special. Buckberger is promising, but he’s not a guaranteed roster spot yet. He’s competing hard, though.

Brooke: Another email from @JacketFan23: 'The headline says the NHL will produce games for the Blue Jackets, Hurricanes, Wild, and Blues. What does that mean for us? Does it change how we watch the games?' Interesting league-wide shift.

Tony: It means centralized production. Instead of local teams handling everything, the league is taking over the broadcast package for these teams. It could mean better graphics, more consistent camera angles, and potentially higher quality feeds. For fans, it might feel a bit more polished, but less locally tailored. Some people miss the local flavor. But from a technical standpoint, it’s a step up.

Brooke: Do you think it affects the game itself? Like, does the league interfere with tactics? No, it’s just the broadcast. But it shows the league is investing in Columbus. They see us as a growing market.

Tony: Exactly. They’re betting on us. With the standings showing us first in the Met, the league wants to showcase that story. It validates the work the front office has done. It’s not just about TV; it’s about prestige.

Brooke: Let’s talk about the power play. With players like Kent Johnson, Danton Heinen, and Jordan Dumais, who takes the points?

Tony: Johnson is the primary playmaker. He sees the ice better than anyone. Heinen is dangerous from the circle. Dumais has a quick release. I’d expect Johnson to quarterback the unit. He’s smart, he’s fast. He’ll find the seam passes. If the power play clicks, it’s going to be lethal. The penalty kill needs to be good, though, to balance it out.

Brooke: Alright, fun time. Ryan in Toledo asks: 'If you could only keep one player from the entire roster for the rest of your life, who is it?' No stats, no salary cap. Just who do you pick?

Tony: That’s a tough one. Zach Werenski. He’s the soul of the team. He’s been through the ups and downs. He represents everything we want in a leader. Plus, he’s great at passing out pucks.

Brooke: I’m going with Kent Johnson. He’s young, he’s exciting, he’s got that skill. Watching him skate is a joy. I’d keep him forever.

Tony: Fair choice. Johnson is electric. Okay, lightning round. First question: Who wins the Metropolitan Division?

Brooke: The Blue Jackets. Obviously. We’re first in the standings for a reason. Our depth is unmatched.

Tony: I’ll give it to Carolina. They’re the defending champions. They’re consistent. But Columbus is right there. It’s going to be a dogfight.

Brooke: Second question: Will Kirill Marchenko score on opening night against Buffalo?

Tony: Yes. He’s hungry. He’s proven himself. Expect a goal from him. It’s coming.

Brooke: Final question: What is the most underrated player on the roster?

Tony: Isac Lundestrom. People focus on the scorers, but Lundestrom shuts down lines. He’s the glue. Without him, the middle six falls apart.

Brooke: Great answers, Tony. We’ve covered Werenski’s future, Greaves’ contract, the center battle, and the defensive pairings. The Blue Jackets are poised for a huge season.

Tony: They are. If they stay healthy and the power play clicks, they’re in the hunt. Keep listening, keep believing.

Brooke: Thanks for tuning in to The Daily Jacket. Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Share this episode with a friend who needs some Blue Jackets hype.

Tony: See you next time. Go Jackets.

Brooke: Go Jackets!