Commanders Fall to Lions 17-13: O-Line Concerns, QB Battle Heats Up

Washington Commanders · 2026-08-23 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Victoria: The Commanders lost again in the preseason, but the real story is what happened to the offensive line. We break down the loss, the QB battle, and what it means for Baltimore.

Dan: And we've got some big takeaways from the defense that might surprise you.

Victoria: Welcome back to the Beatline Podcast Network. I'm Victoria, and as always, Dan is here with me. Commanders Nation, we are live after a tough 17-13 loss to the Lions yesterday. We've got a lot to unpack, so let's dive in.

Dan: That's right. We talked all week about the kicker battle and the backup QB situation, but the big takeaway from this one? The offensive line is a real concern.

Victoria: We'll break down the offense, the defense, and look ahead to the Ravens. Stick with us.

Victoria: Let's start with the score. The Lions beat us 17-13. Dan, the offense struggled to get into the end zone. What did you see from Athan Kaliakmanis?

Dan: Athan actually looked sharp. He went 11-for-14 for 162 yards. That's a really efficient day, and he hit Nick Nash for a big 62-yard gain. But he didn't get the touchdown, and that's the bottom line.

Victoria: We predicted Athan would throw for over 150 yards and a touchdown. He got the yards, but no score. So we were half right. But the bigger issue was the run game. Kaytron Allen had just 30 yards on 10 carries. That's not going to cut it.

Dan: Exactly. And the offensive line is a big reason. They couldn't open holes. And it's not just the run blocking. Pass protection was shaky too. We saw Nick Allegretti and others on the injury report, and it's showing on the field.

Victoria: The headlines are all about the O-line. It's a concern through two preseason games. How concerned are you, Dan?

Dan: I'm concerned, but it's still preseason. The starting five hasn't played together. Laremy Tunsil and Sam Cosmi will anchor that unit. But the depth is a problem. We saw that against the Lions.

Victoria: Let's talk about the scoring plays. We had a fumble recovery for a touchdown by Joshua Josephs, and then Dobbs broke a 50-yard run. But our offense settled for field goals. Drew Stevens hit a 27-yarder and a 32-yarder. Dan, we predicted he'd hit one from 50-plus. He didn't.

Dan: No, but he was perfect on his attempts. That's something. The kicker battle is still open, but Stevens did what he needed to do. The long ball will come.

Victoria: We also saw a 1-yard rushing touchdown from Trayveon Williams. That's a positive. But overall, the offense felt disjointed. We had 13 points, and we needed more.

Dan: Right. And let's not forget the turnovers. Dobbs had two turnovers for the Lions, but he also had that 50-yard run. So it was a mixed bag. For us, we didn't turn it over, which is good. But we didn't force any either.

Victoria: We'll get to the defense in a second. But first, the quarterback battle. Athan outplayed Sam Hartman in this one. Is he pulling ahead?

Dan: I think so. Athan's numbers were better, and he looked more comfortable in the pocket. Hartman didn't see much time, but Athan is making a case for the backup job behind Jayden Daniels.

Victoria: And we can't forget about Marcus Mariota. He's still in the mix. But Athan's performance yesterday was impressive.

Dan: Absolutely. It's going to be a tough call for the coaching staff, but that's a good problem to have.

Victoria: Alright, let's stick with us. After the break, we'll talk defense and special teams, including Maurice Hurst's big night.

Victoria: Welcome back. Let's talk about the defense. Dan, Maurice Hurst II had two sacks. That's a big stat line.

Dan: Hurst was disruptive all game. Two sacks is huge, especially for a guy trying to earn a roster spot. He's making a strong case.

Victoria: And Ale Kaho led the team with six tackles. That's a solid outing. The defense gave up 17 points, but they forced some stops.

Dan: Right. And we predicted the defense would get at least four sacks. We only got two from Hurst. So we missed that one. But the pass rush showed signs of life.

Victoria: Special teams had a big play too. Joshua Josephs recovered a fumble in the end zone for a touchdown. That was a huge momentum swing.

Dan: That was a great hustle play. Special teams can win you games, and that was a prime example. It kept us in the game.

Victoria: Now, the injury report. We've got a lot of names listed as questionable. Nick Allegretti, K'Lavon Chaisson, Tim Settle, and others. How concerning is that?

Dan: It's concerning, especially on the O-line. But it's preseason. They're being cautious. The bigger issue is Jer'Zhan Newton's torn pec. That's a significant loss for the defensive line.

Victoria: That's right. Newton had surgery. That's a tough break. But it opens the door for other guys to step up.

Dan: Exactly. And we saw some of that yesterday. The defense held up okay, but they'll need more consistency.

Victoria: Let's talk about the receivers. Nick Nash had 62 yards on just two catches. That's a big play threat. And we've got guys like Terry McLaurin, Stefon Diggs, and Dyami Brown. The competition is fierce.

Dan: Nash is making a name for himself. He's a deep threat, and that's valuable. But the roster is stacked. It's going to be tough cuts.

Victoria: And Jacory Croskey-Merritt spoke about his offensive strategy. He's another back in the mix. The running back room is crowded.

Dan: Yeah, with Kaytron Allen, Jeremy McNichols, and others, it's a battle. But Allen got the most carries yesterday, so he might have the edge.

Victoria: Alright, Dan. Let's look ahead to the next game. We face the Baltimore Ravens on Friday. What are you watching for?

Dan: First, the offensive line. They need to show improvement. The Ravens have a good defensive front, and that will be a test.

Victoria: And the quarterback battle continues. Athan vs. Hartman vs. Mariota. Who takes the lead?

Dan: Athan has the momentum. But Mariota's experience could be a factor. It's going to be interesting.

Victoria: We also need to see more from the run game. Kaytron Allen needs to find some holes.

Dan: And the defense needs to build on the pass rush. Hurst's performance was encouraging, but we need more from the edge.

Victoria: Dan, any bold predictions for the Ravens game?

Dan: I think Athan throws for another 150-plus yards and a touchdown. And I think the defense gets at least three sacks.

Victoria: I like that. I'll go with the O-line having a bounce-back game and the Commanders getting their first win of the preseason. We'll see.

Dan: That would be a nice confidence booster before the regular season.

Victoria: Alright, that's our show. We covered the loss to the Lions, the O-line concerns, the defensive standouts, and a look ahead to Baltimore.

Dan: Make sure to subscribe, rate, and review the podcast. Share it with your fellow Commanders fans.

Victoria: And remember, we're all in this together. Hail to the Commanders! We'll catch you next time.