TFC Power Rankings: Can Toronto Climb from 12th?

Toronto FC · 2026-09-18 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Jessica: Antoine Griezmann is on fire, scoring in five straight games to help Orlando City dismantle us 3-0, but hold on—just days before that nightmare, we actually beat the league leaders. Nashville SC? Gone. 2-1. How do you reconcile a team that can knock down the best in the world with one that gets turned inside out by Dallas and Orlando?

Mark: That’s the question hanging over every TFC fan this week. We are sitting at 6-11-8, 12th in MLS, and frankly, the gap between our highs and lows is widening, not narrowing. It’s a tale of two completely different teams depending on which Wednesday night you’re watching.

Jessica: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, your daily source for everything MLS. I’m Jessica, and I’m joined by Mark. Today is our Power Rankings edition. We’re looking at where Toronto FC stands right now in the grand scheme of things, what’s working, what’s broken, and if that upset win over Nashville was a fluke or a forecast.

Mark: Exactly. We’ve spent the last three days digging into the defensive lapses against FC Dallas and the midfield chemistry issues between Jonathan Osorio and Djordje Mihailovic. But today, we zoom out. We look at the record, the standing, and the reality of the Eastern Conference playoff picture as it sits today.

Jessica: Here is what we are tackling today. First, we break down exactly where TFC ranks in its division and why that 12th-place standing is so precarious. Second, we analyze the biggest strength—the sudden offensive spark—and the biggest question mark, which is obviously consistency. And third, we give you a realistic season outlook and try to project how many more wins are actually in the tank.

Mark: Let’s get right into it. Because if you haven’t been paying attention, the landscape has shifted. Chicago is sliding, Nashville is cementing the top spot, and Miami is bouncing back thanks to Messi. Where does Toronto fit in this chaos?

Jessica: So, let’s start with the hard numbers. 6 wins, 11 losses, 8 draws. That is a .429 winning percentage. In a league that just set records for incoming and outgoing transfers in 2026, meaning everyone is getting stronger, TFC is essentially stagnant. You’re 12th in MLS overall. What does that tell you about the roster's ceiling right now?

Mark: It tells me we’re in a holding pattern. When you look at the power rankings, teams like Nashville and Orlando are climbing because they have clear identities. Orlando has Griezmann, who has eight goal contributions in eight games since joining the Lions. That’s an identity. TFC doesn’t have a consistent identity yet. We’re 12th because we lack the tactical cohesion to punish weaker teams consistently.

Jessica: But wait, we have to talk about the Nashville game. Emilio Aristizábal scored in stoppage time to give us a 2-1 victory over the frontrunners. Dániel Sallói tied it in the 72nd. That feels like a 15th-place team playing with house money. Is that result legitimate, or is it masking the deeper issues?

Mark: It’s legitimate effort, but it’s not sustainable strategy. You beat the best team in the league when you play with nothing to lose. But then you go play Orlando, and Antoine Griezmann scores again—his fifth straight game—and we get blown out 3-0. Rookie Harvey Sarajian even got his first goal and assist. That shows the quality gap. We can punch up once, but we don’t have the depth to stay there.

Jessica: And speaking of punching down, or rather, failing to punch anyone effectively, let’s look at the FC Dallas game. We lost 3-2 away. Petar Musa had four shots for Dallas. Osaze Urhoghide completed 49 passes. Michael Collodi made three saves. On our side, Djordje Mihailovic had two shots, and Jonathan Osorio had 57 accurate passes. That pass count for Osorio looks good on paper, but did it translate to danger?

Mark: Not really. This goes back to what we discussed yesterday. The midfield chemistry. Osorio is a veteran leader, he’s putting up those numbers, but the link-up play isn’t clicking. Mihailovic is creative, but he’s isolated. When you compare our build-up play to something like NYCFC, where Nicolás Fernández scored his 14th goal and Matt Freese kept a clean sheet in a 1-1 tie, you see a more structured approach. We’re relying on individual moments rather than systemic pressure.

Jessica: So, if we’re 12th, and the gap between us and the playoff teams is growing, what is the path forward? Are we looking at a finish outside the top ten? Last episode, Mark, you predicted we’d finish 11th in the Eastern Conference. Does that still feel possible given this 6-11-8 record?

Mark: I’m sticking to it, but it’s going to be tight. The Eastern Conference is weird this year. With Chicago sliding and other teams inconsistent, there’s room to climb. But we need to close out games. We drew 1-1 with NYCFC. That’s a point we should have taken, or better yet, won. If we can secure those draws against mid-tier teams, we inch up. But beating the bottom feeders is non-negotiable.

Jessica: Alright, let’s pivot. Segment Two. Strengths and Weaknesses. We’ve talked about the weaknesses extensively—the defense, the midfield disconnect. But what is actually working for Toronto FC right now? Besides the occasional miracle against Nashville?

Mark: Resilience. That’s the only word that fits. Getting beaten 3-0 by a team with Griezmann on fire, and then bouncing back to beat Nashville? That’s mental toughness. Also, Josh Sargent. He’s scoring goals. Simple as that. When he’s involved, we have a focal point in attack. It’s not pretty, but it works.

Jessica: Sargent is definitely a bright spot. But let’s talk about the elephant in the room. Antoine Griezmann. He’s tearing up the league for Orlando. Eight goals in ten matches. How much does seeing a rival like that add fuel to the fire, or is it just frustration for our players?

Mark: It’s frustration. Watching Griezmann score in five straight games while we struggle to find the back of the net against average sides is tough. It highlights the disparity in quality. We don’t have that kind of clinical finishing depth. Our strengths are currently too narrow. We rely too heavily on specific individuals rather than a balanced attack.

Jessica: So, the biggest question mark heading into the final stretch: Can the midfield duo of Osorio and Mihailovic finally gel? Or are we destined to keep having those possession-heavy, low-xG performances like we saw against Dallas?

Mark: They need to gel. Fast. Without that connection, we’re vulnerable on the counter. Teams like Dallas exploit that space. Urhoghide had 49 passes, sure, but he had space to make them because we weren’t pressing high enough or coordinating our transition defense. If Osorio and Mihailovic can’t synchronize their movement, we’ll keep conceding cheap goals.

Jessica: That is a lot of pressure on two players. But let’s move to Segment Three. Season Outlook. We have some games left. The league has seen record transfer activity in 2026, so rosters are shifting. What is your realistic projection for the rest of the season? How many more wins do you see in the tank?

Mark: I think we win two more games. That’s it. Maybe three if the stars align perfectly. But realistically, two. The schedule is tough, and the defensive issues are structural, not just bad luck. We need to tighten up the back line before we can expect consistent victories.

Jessica: Two more wins. That keeps us hovering around that 11th place spot we talked about earlier. It’s not a playoff push, but it’s a respectable finish if we can stabilize. Now, before we wrap up this deep dive into the rankings, I want to take a quick moment with you, our listeners.

Jessica: If today’s breakdown of TFC’s struggles and that miraculous Nashville win felt worth your time, please consider supporting the show. Your contributions keep these daily episodes free and running. Just click the link in the episode description to help us out.

Mark: We appreciate it. Really. It allows us to dig this deep into the stats and bring you the analysis you need. Thank you for listening.

Jessica: To recap: TFC sits at 6-11-8, 12th in MLS. We have resilience and Sargent’s goals, but we lack midfield cohesion and defensive stability. We predict two more wins, aiming for 11th in the East. Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Go TFC!