CF Montréal Mailbag: Surviving Messi, Ríos' Streak & The Sánchez Question

CF Montréal · 2026-09-17 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Laura: Four goals. Seven total goals. A club-record 7-1 dismantling by Inter Miami. If you’re still shaking your head from that performance, you are not alone. But here is the thing about CF Montréal this season: they keep showing up, they keep digging, and today we are answering your questions on how they survive the chaos.

Greg: It’s a brutal landscape in MLS right now. You have Nashville cementing the top spot, Orlando jumping into the playoff picture with Antoine Griezmann, and Miami bouncing back after their own slump. Meanwhile, Montreal sits at 5-6-14, 15th in the league, trying to find any rhythm in what has been a chaotic campaign.

Greg: That’s right. We’ve got three segments planned. First, we tackle the biggest current topic: the tactical fallout of those heavy losses and where the team stands heading into the final stretch. Second, we look at the roster battles, specifically debating Alexis Sánchez versus Prince Owusu's consistency. And finally, we do a fun hypothetical scenario plus a lightning round of quick takes.

Laura: So grab your scarf, pour a poutine, or just brace yourself for some hard truths. Let’s get into Segment One: The Big Picture. First question comes from Sarah from Rochester. She asks: 'Greg, after getting blown out by San Diego FC 5-0 and then seeing Messi score four against us, is there any positive takeaway from these results? Or is the defense completely broken?'

Greg: Sarah brings up a fair point. When you look at the San Diego game, it wasn’t just the scoreline; it was the dominance. Anders Dreyer had five total shots, Manu Duah completed 98 accurate passes, and Duran Ferree only had to make two saves because Montreal rarely threatened. It was a masterclass in possession and width by San Diego.

Laura: And then add in the Miami result. Messi scoring four goals in a single match is historically significant, but for Montreal, it feels like another layer of frustration. Is it just bad luck facing the best teams in the world?

Greg: Not entirely. While Messi is an anomaly, the defensive structure issues are real. In the Miami game, Thomas Gillier had two saves, which tells you they weren't under sustained pressure for long stretches—meaning they couldn't even get the ball back. Brayan Vera managed one shot for Montreal. That’s a lack of creativity in the final third, yes, but also a failure to transition quickly enough to create chances before the defense resets.

Laura: One shot. That’s the headline number for Brayan Vera in that loss. Does that suggest he’s being isolated too much, or is the midfield failing to supply him?

Greg: Efraín Morales had 28 accurate passes in that game. That’s decent distribution, but if those passes aren't reaching the striker in dangerous areas, it’s a breakdown in verticality. The issue is the press. When opponents like Miami or San Diego bypass the first line of pressure, Montreal doesn’t have the numerical superiority to recover. It leaves Vera hanging.

Laura: Okay, let’s pivot to another listener question. This one is from @HabsFan88 who asks: 'Daniel Ríos scored in the draw against LA Galaxy. Greg, in previous episodes, you predicted he would be the next goal scorer. Has his form changed? Can he carry this attack when the stars aren't around?'

Greg: I stand by that prediction, and honestly, it’s been vindicated. Against the Galaxy, Daniel Ríos was the spark. He scored in a 2-2 tie where Montreal had to fight back. That resilience is key. Unlike the Miami or San Diego games, where the team looked disjointed, Ríos showed movement off the ball that created space.

Laura: He also scored against DC United in that 1-1 draw, right? Where Tai Baribo had a five-game scoring streak for the opposition.

Greg: Exactly. So Ríos has been involved in multiple key moments recently. The challenge is consistency. One game he’s influential, the next he disappears behind a high defensive line. But compared to the rest of the squad, he’s providing a focal point. If Montreal wants to climb out of 15th place, Ríos needs more service.

Laura: We’ll see if that holds up. Next question from Marcus in Denver: 'With Alexis Sánchez arriving, does he take playing time away from Prince Owusu? Owusu has been consistent, but Sánchez is a legend. Who starts?'

Greg: This is the big debate. On paper, Sánchez is the bigger name. But tactically, Owusu offers a different profile. He provides width and steady buildup play. Sánchez is more of a connector in tight spaces. If the team struggles to retain possession against high presses, Owusu’s ability to hold the ball might be more valuable than Sánchez’s flair.

Laura: But Sánchez changes the dynamic of the final third. He draws defenders. Doesn’t that create the space Owusu needs?

Greg: Theoretically, yes. But practically, it depends on the manager’s setup. If they play a compact block, Sánchez thrives. If they need to stretch the field, Owusu is safer. Given Montreal’s current record, safety might be the priority until they can generate their own chances more reliably.

Laura: Let’s hear from @MontrealMike who asks: 'What about the goalkeeper situation? Thomas Gillier had two saves against San Diego. Is he ready for the long haul, or should we be looking elsewhere?'

Greg: Two saves isn’t a lot, but it’s also not a reflection of Gillier’s ability—it’s a reflection of the team’s inability to keep the ball. In the DC United game, Sean Johnson made six saves for the opposition, meaning the game was end-to-end. Gillier hasn’t faced that kind of volume recently, so his sample size is small.

Laura: So we don’t have enough data to judge him harshly yet. What about the overall standing? We’re 15th. Last week we talked about finishing around 14th. Are we still on track for that, or is the gap too wide?

Greg: 14th is still achievable if the bottom-feeders slip up. Teams like Chicago are sliding, which helps. But Montreal needs to win games they should win. The draw with the Galaxy was a good sign. The loss to San Diego was expected given the quality difference. It’s about closing the gap on the teams just above you.

Laura: Stick with us, because in Segment Three, we’re going to ask the ultimate hypothetical: If Montreal could pick ONE player from any MLS team to join them for the final month, who gets the call? And we’ll wrap up with a lightning round of quick takes.

Laura: Alright, let’s dive into Segment Three. First, the hypothetical. If you could bring in one player to fix Montreal’s current issues, who is it? I’m going to say someone who can control the tempo. Maybe a midfielder like Manu Duah from San Diego, since he had 98 passes in that game.

Greg: I’d go for a striker who can finish. Brayan Vera needs a partner who creates half-chances. Someone like Tai Baribo, who was on a five-game streak against DC United. Just having that kind of clinical instinct in the box would change everything.

Laura: Baribo vs. Duah. Classic choice between end product and possession. Now, lightning round. Quick takes on the headlines. Nashville is top of the power rankings. Messi is doing Messi things. And Montreal is... well, fighting for every point.

Greg: Nashville looks untouchable right now. They blew out Miami. But MLS is volatile. Montreal just needs to stay organized. If they can replicate the discipline shown against the Galaxy, they can steal points.

Laura: Before we go, I want to thank you all for sending in such great questions. To keep this show free and daily, please consider supporting us. It takes a lot of work to put this together every single day, and a handful of supporters makes that possible. Check out the link in the episode description.

Greg: Your support keeps the analysis sharp and the stories fresh. Thank you for listening.

Laura: Thanks, Greg. Thanks, fans. Keep wearing the badge. Allez les Habs!