CF Montreal Mailbag: Alexis Sánchez Impact, Playoff Hopes & Roster Battles

CF Montréal · 2026-09-01 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Laura: Is CF Montréal’s playoff dream officially dead, or is there still a sliver of hope left in the Eastern Conference? We’re talking about it right now.

Greg: It’s a tough pill to swallow when you’re sitting at 5-6-11 and looking at 14th place, but we aren’t giving up on the Blue and Red just yet. Welcome back to the Beatline Podcast Network.

Laura: I’m Laura, and I’m here with Greg. Today is our weekly mailbag episode, so grab your questions because we are diving deep into the current state of CF Montréal. Before we get to the inbox, let’s lay out what we’ve got for you today.

Greg: We have three big segments. First, we’re answering your questions about the team’s current standing and whether they can climb out of this hole. Second, we’re breaking down the roster battles, specifically looking at how Alexis Sánchez fits into the attack alongside Prince Owusu. And third, we’re doing a lightning round of quick takes on the recent results against Inter Miami and San Diego FC.

Laura: Sounds like a packed show. Let’s jump straight into Segment One: The Big Picture. Our first question comes from Sarah in Montreal, who asks: 'Given that we are 14th in MLS with a record of 5-6-11, is it realistic to think we can make the playoffs, or should we be preparing for next season?'

Greg: Sarah, that is the million-dollar question. Mathematically, anything is possible in soccer, but realistically? It’s an uphill battle. You’re eleven points out of a playoff spot with only a few games left, depending on the schedule. The gap between 14th and the top eight is significant.

Laura: Right. And Greg, remember on August 30th we discussed the impact of Alexis Sánchez versus the midfield's defensive struggles. Do you think his arrival has changed the trajectory enough to bridge that gap?

Greg: That’s where it gets tricky. Alexis Sánchez was signed as a Designated Player to elevate the attack, and yes, he brings quality. But look at the recent form. We saw a heavy loss to Inter Miami, where Lionel Messi scored four goals in a club-record 7-1 victory. That wasn’t just a bad day; that was a tactical dismantling.

Laura: Ouch. Seven goals conceded by Messi alone. Does that suggest the issue is purely defensive, or is the attack struggling to keep up?

Greg: It’s both. When you concede seven, you put immense pressure on your attackers. Even with Sánchez, if the midfield isn’t controlling possession, they don’t get the ball. In that match against Miami, the press was non-existent. Nashville SC continues to dominate the league right now, and teams like us are getting blown apart by the top tiers because we can’t sustain the build-up play under high pressure.

Laura: So, to answer Sarah: is it realistic? Probably not for a deep playoff run. But Greg, earlier this week we predicted that CF Montréal would finish around 10th or 11th. With these losses, do we need to adjust that prediction?

Greg: I hate to say it, Laura, but we might have to revise that. If the defensive line doesn’t tighten up, finishing 14th could actually be the ceiling. The gap between us and the teams above is widening every week. We drew with the LA Galaxy when they were down to ten men, which shows we can compete, but we also lost 5-0 to San Diego FC.

Laura: Five-nil. That’s brutal. Okay, moving to our second question from @BlueRedForever in Chicago. He asks: 'How does Alexis Sánchez fit into the starting XI? Is he playing as a striker or dropping deep to link play?'

Greg: Great question. Sánchez is versatile, but given the lack of creativity in the central midfield, he’s likely being used to drop deeper than a traditional number nine. He needs to pull defenders out to create space for others. But look at the stats from the last game against San Diego. Brayan Vera had one shot. Efraín Morales had 28 accurate passes. The ball wasn’t reaching the final third consistently.

Laura: And we know from previous episodes that Prince Owusu is expected to finish with double-digit goals. How does Sánchez’s presence affect Owusu’s role?

Greg: This is the debate of the summer. On August 29th, we talked about the attacking trio. Owusu provides pace and width. Sánchez provides experience and finishing. But if Sánchez is holding the ball too long in tight spaces, Owusu gets isolated. We saw this against DC United, where Tai Baribo scored five games in a row. They found a rhythm. We need that same cohesion with Sánchez involved.

Laura: So, is it better to have two stars sharing the load, or is the chemistry still lacking? Another listener, Marcus in Toronto, asks: 'Will CF Montréal cut fringe players to free up roster spots before the transfer window closes?'

Greg: Marcus, that’s a very astute observation. On August 29th, we predicted exactly that. Clubs often trim the fat before the January window to clear salary cap space or open up roster slots for new signings. Given our current form, it’s highly likely we see some movement on the margins of the squad.

Laura: Interesting. So, who stays and who goes? We mentioned earlier that Alexis Sánchez will score more goals than Prince Owusu from this point until the end of the season. Do you still stand by that prediction?

Greg: I do. Sánchez’s pedigree is undeniable. Even if the team struggles, he creates individual moments. Owusu relies on the system working perfectly. If the system is broken, as it has been against Miami and San Diego, Sánchez can still find pockets of space. Owusu needs the wings to be open. Right now, the opposition is collapsing the box.

Laura: Fair point. One more question from @MontrealFan91: 'What about the goalkeeper situation? Thomas Gillier vs. the backup. Who is the starter for the rest of the season?'

Greg: Gillier started against San Diego and made two saves. It’s not much to go on, but he kept the score from being even worse, theoretically. However, consistency is key. If the defense continues to allow shots like Anders Dreyer did with five shots against us, the keeper is going to have a hard job. We need stability between the posts.

Laura: Okay, we’re running low on time for the deep dives, so let’s move to Segment Three: Lightning Round. I’ll ask a series of rapid-fire questions. First: Was the loss to Inter Miami unavoidable?

Greg: No. Messi is Messi, but seven goals is a collapse. We had chances to stay in the game. Daniel Ríos and Prince Owusu scored against the Galaxy, showing we can score. We just couldn’t stop them.

Laura: Second: Did Alexis Sánchez justify his Designated Player status in his debut stretch?

Greg: He’s brought energy, but goals are the metric. We haven’t seen enough of him in high-leverage games yet to say definitively. But the intent is there.

Laura: Third: Who is the most surprising player from the San Diego game? Not necessarily the best, but the most surprising stat line.

Greg: Manu Duah for San Diego had 98 accurate passes. For us, Efraín Morales had 28. The disparity in possession control was massive. Duah controlled the tempo completely.

Laura: Final hypothetical: If CF Montréal could sign one player to replace their worst performer from the San Diego game, who is it?

Greg: A defensive midfielder. Someone who can break up play and protect the back line. We’re too exposed in transition. A holder like that would give Sánchez and Owusu the ball back faster.

Laura: There you have it, fans. From the Alexis Sánchez debate to the harsh reality of 14th place, we covered it all. Greg, any final thoughts before we wrap?

Greg: Just this: Keep believing, but keep demanding better. The talent is there, but the execution needs to improve. We’ll see you next week.

Laura: Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network. If you enjoyed this mailbag, please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you get your podcasts. Share this episode with a fellow Blue and Red fan.

Greg: Let’s go CF Montréal.