Columbus Crew Power Rankings: The 13th Place Paradox

Columbus Crew · 2026-11-19 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Nicole: You are scoring points for watching this, but Columbus is sitting in 13th place. Let that sink in. A team with Malte Amundsen on fire and a recent Open Cup final appearance is stuck outside the playoff picture. How does that happen? And can they fix it before the window closes forever?

Kevin: It’s a paradox, Nicole. You have offensive output that suggests top-tier form, but a defensive record and a standing that says otherwise. We’re breaking down exactly where the Crew stand in the MLS power rankings today.

Nicole: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, the daily home of soccer analysis you can trust. I’m Nicole, and I’m joined by my favorite tactical mind in the game, Kevin.

Kevin: Good morning, good evening, wherever you are listening. It’s great to be back. Today we’re doing a deep dive into the Columbus Crew’s current position.

Nicole: Here is what we are tackling today. First, we look at where the Crew actually rank in their division and why that 13th-place spot is so misleading. Second, we break down the biggest strength—Malte Amundsen—and the biggest question mark, which is obviously the defense. And third, we give you a realistic season outlook and win projection. Let’s get right into it.

Nicole: Kevin, let’s start with the hard numbers. The Crew are 14-5-15. That puts them 13th in MLS. When you see headlines about Nashville winning the Supporters' Shield or Miami finding its feet, where do you see Columbus fitting in?

Kevin: They are in a strange limbo. If you only looked at the wins, you’d think they were top eight. But that 15-draw record tells you something about inconsistency. They beat Cincinnati 2-0 recently, Gonzalo Tapia had a goal and an assist, Taha Habroune scored his third straight game. That looks like a playoff team.

Nicole: But then you look at the losses. They lost to St. Louis in the Open Cup final on penalties. They lost to Portland 3-2 away. Those are the games that kill you in the standings.

Kevin: Exactly. In a tight league, those dropped points or narrow losses add up. Being 13th means they are outside the playoff spots, likely fighting for that ninth and final spot. It’s precarious. One bad week and they fall further behind.

Nicole: And the headlines reflect this tension. ESPN’s power rankings mention Nashville as the team to beat, Inter Miami moving up, and St. Louis City SC hot on their heels. Where does Columbus fit in that narrative?

Kevin: They are the underachievers in the eyes of the media. People expect more from a club with this history. When they beat Toronto 4-1 with Malte Amundsen scoring two goals—that was his first career multi-goal game—it felt like a statement. But one statement game doesn’t erase the 13th-place reality.

Nicole: So, in terms of division context, are they contenders or pretenders right now?

Kevin: Pretenders who could become contenders if the defense stabilizes. Right now, the gap between them and the teams above is too wide to ignore. They need a creative midfielder to bridge that gap, which we talked about yesterday.

Nicole: That’s a key point. Without that creative spark, staying 13th feels inevitable. Stick with us; next we talk about the offense that’s keeping them alive.

Nicole: Let’s talk strengths. Malte Amundsen is having a breakout year. He scored twice against Toronto, and he’s clearly the focal point. Is he carrying the attack single-handedly?

Kevin: He’s not alone, but he’s the engine. Look at the stats from the Portland game. Wessam Abou Ali had three total shots. That’s significant. It shows the attack isn’t just relying on one man, though Amundsen is definitely the primary threat.

Nicole: And the support system? Gonzalo Tapia has been crucial. He had a goal and an assist against Cincinnati. Brooks Lennon also chipped in against Toronto.

Kevin: Right. So the strength is clear: when the ball gets to these guys, they finish. The transition play is effective. But the weakness is glaring. The defense.

Nicole: Patrick Schulte made three saves against Portland. James Pantemis, the Portland keeper, only made two. So Columbus created chances, but they conceded three. That’s the issue.

Kevin: It’s the defensive line. They leave space. Against St. Louis, Roman Bürki got stretchered off after a collision, which was scary, but even without that injury, the structure wasn’t there. They concede easy chances because the midfield doesn’t protect them enough.

Nicole: Rudy Camacho had 74 accurate passes against Portland. That’s solid build-up play from the back, but if the press breaks, they are exposed.

Kevin: Exactly. They have the technical ability to pass, but they lack the physical dominance in midfield to win second balls consistently. That’s why they need that creative midfielder we’ve been discussing. Someone who can control the tempo and stop counters.

Nicole: So, strength is individual brilliance in attack. Weakness is collective vulnerability in defense. Clear as day.

Kevin: Clear as day. And until that balance is struck, every win feels fragile.

Nicole: We’ll be right back after we break down what this means for their future.

Nicole: Okay, season outlook. Realistic projections. Can they make the playoffs? Or is 13th the floor and maybe the ceiling?

Kevin: If nothing changes, 13th is the floor. But I think they can climb. They’ve won four of their last five games. Momentum is building. Amundsen is confident.

Nicole: But momentum doesn’t win titles. Structure does. Do you think they can secure that ninth spot?

Kevin: Only if they sign that creative midfielder. Without him, the gaps in midfield remain. With him, they can control games better and reduce those defensive errors.

Nicole: So, prediction time. What’s your win projection for the rest of the stretch?

Kevin: I think they win six of their next ten games. That puts them around eighth or ninth. It’s tight, but possible.

Nicole: I agree. If Amundsen keeps scoring and the defense stops leaking goals, they sneak in. But it requires immediate action from the front office.

Kevin: Agreed. History-making Nashville might be unstoppable, but Columbus has the talent to upset the odds if they fix their mid-field issues.

Nicole: Thanks for sticking with us. Next up, we wrap it all up.

Nicole: To recap: Columbus is 13th, riding high on Malte Amundsen’s goals but hampered by defensive leaks. They need a creative midfielder to climb into the playoffs.

Kevin: Precisely. The talent is there, but the structure needs work. If they address that, they can challenge for the top spots.

Nicole: Before we go, if today’s breakdown helped you understand the Crew’s situation better, please consider supporting us. Your contribution keeps this show free and daily. Just check out the link in the episode description.

Kevin: We appreciate every bit of support. It makes this possible.

Nicole: Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. For Kevin, I’m Nicole. Go Crew!