Columbus Crew Roster Battles: Midfield Chaos & The Amundsen Question

Columbus Crew · 2026-11-18 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Nicole: If you thought the Columbus Crew’s season ended with that penalty shootout heartbreak in the U.S. Open Cup final, think again. We’re looking at a roster on the brink of a massive transformation, where every single training ground minute is being fought for over a playoff spot they currently don’t have.

Kevin: Exactly. It’s 13th place. It’s precarious. But look at the last six games: five wins. Malte Amundsen is emerging as a starter, the attack is clicking against Toronto and Cincinnati, but that defensive structure still has holes wide enough to drive a truck through.

Nicole: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Nicole, and this is your daily deep dive into MLS. Joining me as always is our lead analyst, Kevin. Good morning, Kevin. Today is all about roster battles. Who stays? Who goes? And who needs to step up right now?

Kevin: Good morning, Nicole. Yeah, we’re breaking down three critical position groups. First, the midfield creative engine—can Rudy Camacho hold it down, or do we need more? Second, the fullback depth chart after that Portland loss. And finally, predicting who makes the final cut before the playoffs loom large.

Nicole: Before we get into the nitty-gritty of those battles, I want to take a quick second to talk to you, our listeners. If today’s breakdown helps you understand why the Crew are sitting at 14-5-15 despite recent offensive fireworks, consider chipping in to keep these daily episodes free. Your support literally fuels the research and analysis. Check the link in the episode description if you want to help us keep going. Now, let’s get to Segment One.

Nicole: Okay, Segment One. The most important battle right now: the creative midfield role. We’ve talked about this for days. Malte Amundsen is scoring—he got two against Toronto, his first multi-goal game in MLS—but who is feeding him? Who is creating the space?

Kevin: Right. So, looking at the stats from that last game against Portland, Rudy Camacho had 74 accurate passes. That’s high volume. But was it creative? Or was it just safe, horizontal circulation? Against Portland, they lost 3-2. The press wasn’t high enough.

Nicole: I’m seeing the same thing. Camacho is reliable. He’s solid. But remember, we predicted yesterday that without a true creative midfielder, they stay 13th. Is Camacho that guy? Or is he the anchor while someone else provides the spark?

Kevin: He’s the anchor. Look, if you want a number, look at Wessam Abou Ali. He led Columbus in total shots against Portland with three. But shots don’t create chances out of nothing. You need someone like Cole Bassett, who had 68 accurate passes for Portland. Bassett was dictating tempo. Camacho isn’t doing that for Columbus.

Nicole: So you’re saying the battle is internal. Do we trust Camacho to evolve, or do we need to bring in external talent? Because Gonzalo Tapia scored and assisted against Cincinnati, and Taha Habroune scored three in a row. The forwards are ready, but the supply line is thin.

Kevin: It’s a structural issue. When the opposition presses high, like St. Louis did in the Open Cup final, the build-up play breaks. Roman Bürki, their keeper, got stretchered off after a collision, which shows how chaotic the box got. Columbus couldn’t clear lines consistently. They need width and creativity from central areas.

Nicole: And that’s why the prediction from the last few days keeps coming back: sign a creative midfielder or finish 13th. If they don’t, that playoff spot—the ninth and final one—remains out of reach. Does anyone else in that squad have the vision to unlock a low block?

Kevin: Brooks Lennon added a goal against Toronto, so there’s movement. But Lennon is more of a winger or attacking mid. The pure number ten spot feels vacant. Without it, Amundsen gets isolated. You saw it against Portland; he took three shots, but they were from difficult angles because the defense didn’t collapse for him.

Nicole: It’s frustrating because the offense is clearly capable. Four goals against Toronto, two against Cincinnati. But then you lose to Portland 3-2 and drop points elsewhere. The midfield battle is essentially: can the current crew adapt, or is a trade deadline move inevitable?

Kevin: I think a move is inevitable if they want to go deep in the playoffs. You can’t win trophies with passive buildup. You need aggressive pressing triggers. Right now, Columbus sits too deep. They rely on individual brilliance from Amundsen rather than systemic creation.

Nicole: Let’s pivot to Segment Two. Two more battles. First up: the fullback depth chart. After that 3-2 loss to Portland, where Felipe Mora had three shots and James Pantemis only made two saves, the defensive line looked exposed. Patrick Schulte made three saves for Columbus, but he shouldn’t be facing that many.

Kevin: Agreed. The transitions were brutal. When Portland won the ball back, they went straight up the wings. Columbus’s fullbacks weren’t tracking back fast enough. It’s not just about one player; it’s about the entire back line’s shape. Who starts at left-back? Who starts at right?

Nicole: That’s the question. With the record at 14-5-15, every starting job is under microscope. Are the current starters good enough for the intensity of a playoff match? Or do we see new faces in the lineup against whoever comes next?

Kevin: I’d say the right-back position is more stable. The left side is volatile. Every time they concede, it’s usually down that flank. In the Open Cup final, even though they lost on penalties, the extra time must have drained legs. Freshness is a factor now.

Nicole: So, battle number two: can the starting XI maintain fitness and focus for another month? Or does rotation force changes? We know Taha Habroune is hot with three straight goals. You don’t bench him. But what about the defenders?

Kevin: You don’t bench the attack, but you might rotate the defense. Especially if there are minor injuries or fatigue. The brief doesn’t list any major injuries right now, but the physical toll of 34 games plus cup finals is real. Depth will be tested.

Nicole: And battle number three, briefly: the goalkeeper situation. Patrick Schulte vs. James Pantemis (though Pantemis is Portland). Wait, no, comparing Schulte to whoever plays for them. Schulte made three saves against Portland. Was that enough? Or did he have to make impossible saves?

Kevin: Three saves isn’t a lot. It means the defense kept him busy but maybe not overwhelmed. However, against St. Louis, the pressure was immense. Losing in a penalty shootout is tough mentally. The keeper takes a lot of heat. Schulte needs to show confidence in his distribution to start the build-up.

Nicole: Distribution is key. If Schulte can’t launch a long ball to bypass the press, the midfield battle we just discussed becomes even harder. So, it’s interconnected. Defense, midfield, attack—it all hinges on cohesion.

Kevin: Precisely. And cohesion takes time. They’ve had five wins in six games, which is great momentum. But consistency is the enemy of chaos. Can they keep this level of performance without the defensive errors creeping back in?

Nicole: Alright, Segment Three. Roster-cut predictions. Who’s trending up? Who’s trending down? Based on the last six games, Malte Amundsen is definitely trending up. Two goals against Toronto. Confirmed starter status, as we predicted. He’s the face of this attack right now.

Kevin: Amundsen is locked in. No doubt. But who else? Gonzalo Tapia had a goal and an assist against Cincinnati. He’s trending up. Brooks Lennon also contributed. These guys are proving their worth. On the flip side, who’s at risk?

Nicole: I’d say any defender who couldn’t handle the pace of Portland. And maybe a midfielder who couldn’t crack open the defense against a low block. If Camacho can’t provide that creative spark, his spot could be challenged by a loanee or a trade target.

Kevin: Camacho isn’t necessarily trending down—he’s consistent. But he’s not trending *up* in terms of impact. He’s static. In a league that rewards aggression and creativity, static players get exposed. So, yes, his ceiling might limit his floor if the team wants to push for higher than 13th.

Nicole: So, final predictions. Amundsen stays. Tapia stays. Lennon stays. But the midfield needs an upgrade. And the fullbacks need to prove they can handle the transition game. If they don’t, that 9th place playoff spot remains elusive.

Kevin: I agree. My prediction stands: unless they sign that creative midfielder, they finish 13th. If they do, they might sneak into 8th or 9th. But the roster battles we’re seeing now will dictate that outcome. It’s not just about talent; it’s about fit.

Nicole: That’s the takeaway, folks. Columbus Crew has the firepower with Amundsen, Tapia, and Habroune, but the midfield creativity and defensive stability are the keys to unlocking those playoffs. Don’t forget, if you enjoyed this deep dive into the roster battles, please subscribe, rate, and review us on your favorite platform. It helps more than you know.

Kevin: And share it with a fellow Crew fan. Let’s keep the conversation going. We’ll be back tomorrow with more MLS analysis.

Nicole: Go Crew! See you next time.