Crew Mailbag: Open Cup Heartbreak, Amundsen’s Rise & The Midfield Void

Columbus Crew · 2026-11-17 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Nicole: You are not ready for this one. We just lost the U.S. Open Cup final on penalties to St. Louis City SC, and Roman Bürki was stretchered off with a head injury in that same match. But somehow, despite sitting 13th in MLS with a 14-5-15 record, we are still talking about Malte Amundsen scoring his first career multi-goal brace against Toronto. What is going on? Let’s get into it.

Kevin: It’s a chaotic season, Nicole. We’ve seen four wins in five games, including a dominant 2-0 shutout of Cincinnati where Gonzalo Tapia and Taha Habroune were instrumental, but then we go lose a trophy final and drop points at Portland. The narrative is all over the map.

Nicole: That is exactly why we’re here today. It’s mailbag time. I’ve got your questions coming in hot. First up, we’re looking at the big picture: how do you reconcile a team that beats Cincinnati 2-0 and Toronto 4-1 with a standing that puts them outside the playoff picture entirely?

Kevin: Inconsistency in the defensive line. When Rudy Camacho is controlling the build-up with 74 accurate passes like he did against Portland, the structure holds. But when that breaks down, we’re vulnerable. We’ll answer your questions on this identity crisis, the roster battles for next season, and a fun hypothetical about what happens if Nashville really does break records.

Nicole: We are live from the Beatline Podcast Network. I’m Nicole, and I’m joined by Kevin. Welcome to the Crew Mailbag. Let’s dive straight into Segment One.

Nicole: First question comes from Sarah in Columbus. She asks: 'How can the Crew be 13th in the league when they just beat Cincinnati and Toronto so convincingly? Is the playoff spot actually out of reach?' Kevin, walk us through this paradox.

Kevin: It’s the classic Crew problem this year. You look at the recent form—four wins in five games—and it looks promising. But you have to look at the full 34-game sample. A 14-5-15 record means you dropped way too many points in the middle of the season. Being 13th puts you just outside the final playoff spot, which is usually held by teams with more consistency.

Nicole: Right, and that gap to ninth place is critical. In the last game against Portland, we saw Felipe Mora take three shots for Timbers while Wessam Abou Ali also had three for us. Offense is there, but the results aren't sticking.

Kevin: Exactly. And let’s not forget the Open Cup final loss. Even though we dominated possession in some spells, losing on penalties to St. Louis City SC hurts morale. Then you have the injury to their goalkeeper, Roman Bürki, stretchered off after a collision. That adds a layer of chaos to our own narrative—we’re dealing with high stakes and high drama, but the table doesn’t lie.

Nicole: So, Sarah, the short answer is: the offense is clicking now, but the defense isn't reliable enough to keep you in the top nine. Did we say before that a creative midfielder could change this?

Kevin: We did. And without one, finishing eighth or ninth is a stretch. If we stay at 13th, the structural issues in midfield remain unresolved. We need someone who can unlock those low blocks, not just rely on transitions.

Nicole: Next question is from @CrewFan88. He asks: 'What happened to Cole Bassett? He had 68 accurate passes against Portland. Is he starting every game now?' This is a huge debate in the comments.

Kevin: Bassett is crucial for the build-up play. Against Portland, his 68 accurate passes were vital in keeping the ball. But against Toronto, Malte Amundsen scored twice and Gonzalo Tapia added a goal. The coach has to decide: do you stick with Bassett’s control, or go with the attacking firepower of Amundsen and Tapia?

Nicole: I think it’s about balance. Against Cincinnati, Taha Habroune scored his third consecutive game. So we have multiple attackers stepping up. But Bassett’s passing range is unique. If he’s not starting, who is providing that creativity?

Kevin: That’s the void we keep talking about. We have players like Habroune and Tapia contributing, but we lack a pure number ten. Bassett is a box-to-box engine, but he’s not always the primary creator. If the Crew want to challenge Nashville for the Supporters' Shield, as ESPN’s power rankings suggest they might be able to, we need more than just hard work.

Nicole: So @CrewFan88, Bassett is likely still key, but maybe not as the sole creative hub. We need depth there. Alright, moving on to Segment Two. Marcus in Denver asks: 'With Patrick Schulte making 3 saves against Portland, is he the long-term number one? Or is James Pantemis still ahead of him?'

Kevin: Schulte showed composure. Three saves against a team that shot well is solid. But remember, Pantemis was the starter in the Open Cup final. He faced high-pressure moments against St. Louis. Schulte’s performance against Portland was good, but it was against a team that ultimately won 3-2.

Nicole: And let’s be real, losing 3-2 to Portland stings. You give up three goals, and even if Schulte makes three saves, the defensive line gave up space. Pantemis has experience in finals. Does Schulte have that yet?

Kevin: Experience matters. But Schulte is young. If he keeps clean sheets against Cincinnati and Toronto, he earns the spot. However, the issue isn’t just the keeper; it’s the defense behind him. If the defensive line doesn’t improve, no amount of saves will fix the 13th-place standing.

Nicole: So Marcus, Schulte is in the mix, but unless the defense tightens up, it’s a tough job. Next question from Lisa in Westerville: 'Malte Amundsen scored two goals against Toronto. His first multi-goal game! Is he locked in as the starter for March?'

Kevin: We predicted this weeks ago. Amundsen is emerging. Scoring twice against Toronto, with Brooks Lennon adding another, shows he’s ready. The tactical setup favors his movement in the box. If he continues this form, yes, he’s the starter.

Nicole: Absolutely. And don’t forget Gonzalo Tapia’s goal and assist against Cincinnati. The attack is diverse. But again, Kevin, does this mean we don’t need that creative midfielder anymore?

Kevin: No. Amundsen and Tapia are finishers. We still need someone to create chances consistently. Without a true playmaker, we risk stagnating against teams that park the bus. Amundsen is great, but he’s not a deep-lying organizer.

Nicole: So Lisa, Amundsen is confirmed, but the midfield still needs help. Let’s move to Segment Three. We’ve got a fun hypothetical from @TimbersTie. 'If Nashville breaks the points record and wins the Supporters' Shield, can anyone stop them? Where does Crew fit in?'

Kevin: Nashville is the team to beat right now. Their points haul is historic. But history says upsets happen. If the Crew can find that creative spark, we could challenge the top teams. Right now, we’re fighting for ninth. But the potential is there.

Nicole: I love that optimism. But let’s be realistic. We’re 13th. To catch Nashville, we’d need a miracle run. Still, beating Toronto and Cincinnati proves we can compete. The question is: can we do it every week?

Kevin: Consistency is the key. If we can replicate the Cincinnati performance—two clean goals, strong defense, Tapia and Habroune shining—then yes, we can climb. But one bad day, like the Open Cup final, knocks you back.

Nicole: Alright, lightning round. Quick takes. First: Who was the MVP of the recent win streak? Amundsen or Tapia?

Kevin: Tapia. Two goals and an assist against Cincinnati. Plus a goal against Toronto. He’s been consistent.

Nicole: Agreed. Second: Will the Crew make the playoffs this year? Yes or No?

Kevin: No. Unless something drastic changes in the transfer market, 13th is where we finish.

Nicole: Harsh, but fair. Third: Best moment of the season so far?

Kevin: Amundsen’s brace against Toronto. Pure class.

Nicole: Okay, before we wrap up, I want to talk about what it takes to bring you this content every single day. We analyze every pass, every lineup, every heartbreak. It’s a lot of work, but doing it for free for you guys is worth it. If you want to help us keep the show daily and ad-free, please check out the link in the episode description. Your support keeps the beatline rolling.

Kevin: Thanks for listening, everyone. We’ll see you next time.

Nicole: Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Go Crew!