Crew Mailbag: Open Cup Heartbreak, Amundsen's Rise & The Creative Void

Columbus Crew · 2026-11-16 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Nicole: We are back. If you think the Columbus Crew’s season ended with that penalty shootout loss to St. Louis in the Open Cup final, you haven’t been paying attention to what’s happening in the locker room. We’re talking about Malte Amundsen breaking out, a defense that needs answers, and whether this team can actually climb out of 13th place.

Kevin: It’s a fascinating crossroads for Columbus. They’ve got firepower in Abou Ali and Tapia, but that midfield structural issue we’ve been warning about all week? It’s still there. Today, we’re opening the mailbag to answer your toughest questions on roster battles, the recent win streak, and where things go from here.

Nicole: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, I’m Nicole. I’m joined by our lead analyst Kevin. Kevin, let’s get right into it because our inbox is exploding. First up, Marcus in Denver asks: 'With Malte Amundsen scoring twice against Toronto, is he officially the starter for next season?'

Kevin: Well, Marcus, if you listened to us three days ago, you know I predicted exactly this. Amundsen wasn’t just playing; he was dominating. Two goals, his first multi-goal game in MLS. That’s not a fluke performance. When you look at the build-up play, he’s providing that crucial verticality the Crew has been missing.

Nicole: Right, and remember, Gonzalo Tapia and Brooks Lennon also chipped in in that 4-1 win. But Kevin, the bigger question is sustainability. Can Amundsen carry that load every single week, or do we need more help?

Kevin: He can start, absolutely. But relying solely on individual brilliance isn’t a strategy. That brings me to Sarah from Rochester, who asked: 'The Crew beat Cincinnati 2-0 recently, but they’re still 13th. Is the playoff spot actually reachable, or is this just a dead rubber season?'

Nicole: Ouch. 13th place. It’s hard to swallow when you’ve won four of your last five games. Let’s bring in the facts. The record is 14-5-15. They are sitting right outside the playoff picture, chasing that ninth spot. Taha Habroune has scored in three consecutive games, and Tapia had a goal and an assist against Cincinnati.

Kevin: But Nicole, look at the defensive metrics. Against Portland, they lost 3-2. Felipe Mora had three shots for Portland, but Cole Bassett completed 68 passes. That control in the middle is what separates the top teams from the bottom half. Columbus is scoring, yes, but they are leaking chances at the other end.

Nicole: So, the verdict? Kevin, lay it out for us. Are they going to make the playoffs?

Kevin: Here is the cold truth. Without a creative midfielder to unlock those low blocks, they finish 13th. If they sign one, they jump to 8th or 9th. It’s that binary. And if they don’t fix that midfield structure, my prediction stands: they lose in the quarterfinals if they even make it.

Nicole: Let’s dive deeper into that midfield dilemma. We have @CrewFan88 asking: 'Rudy Camacho had 74 accurate passes against Portland. He’s solid, but is he enough to hold the line together defensively?'

Kevin: Camacho is reliable. Seventy-four accurate passes shows his comfort in possession. But hold the line? That’s a different job. He’s a center-back. The issue is the defensive line’s height and how they handle transitions. When opponents like Portland push high, Camacho is exposed if the midfield doesn’t drop back quickly.

Nicole: So, it’s not just Camacho. It’s the collective shape. What about James Pantemis in goal? He only made two saves against Portland, which seems low for a loss.

Kevin: Exactly. Two saves means the defense was either getting beaten early or Pantemis was dealing with very few clear-cut chances until the late goals. But wait, Patrick Schulte had three saves for Columbus in that same game. Three saves in a 2-3 loss? That suggests Columbus created some decent looks but couldn’t convert, while Portland was more clinical.

Nicole: Wessam Abou Ali did have three total shots for Columbus. He’s trying. But Kevin, let’s talk about the Open Cup final. Roman Bürki was stretchered off after a collision. How does losing a goalkeeper like that impact the mental state of the squad heading into the off-season?

Kevin: It’s heavy. Losing the final on penalties is brutal enough. Then seeing your opponent’s keeper taken to the hospital adds a layer of somber reflection. It’s not just about the trophy; it’s about the physical toll of these high-stakes matches. For Columbus, it highlights the depth issue. Who steps up if Schulte gets injured?

Nicole: That’s a scary thought. Depth is non-negotiable in MLS. Let’s move to the next batch of questions. Jen in Chicago writes: 'Malte Amundsen is great, but who is the X-factor in attack besides him? Do we trust Gonzalo Tapia to be the consistent producer?'

Kevin: Tapia has been excellent. Goal and assist vs. Cincinnati. He’s intelligent in the box. But an X-factor implies unpredictability. Tapia is steady. You want someone who can change a game in ten seconds. That’s where the creative midfielder comes in again. Until then, Tapia and Amundsen are the engine, but they need a spark plug.

Nicole: And that spark plug is the missing piece. Okay, Segment 1 wraps up with a big tease for the next part. We’re going to talk about the specific roster battles for the winter transfer window. Stick with us.

Nicole: We are back. Segment 2: Roster Battles. Mike from St. Louis—sorry, wrong city—Mike from Cleveland asks: 'If the Crew don’t sign a creative midfielder, do they trade Wessam Abou Ali? He’s having a breakout year.'

Kevin: Trade Abou Ali? Never. Not unless you get a massive return. He’s the future. Three shots against Portland, leading the attack. Trading him would be admitting defeat on the offensive philosophy. No, you keep Abou Ali. You build around him. You find the creator to feed him.

Nicole: Agreed. He’s too valuable. What about Brooks Lennon? He added a goal against Toronto. Is he locked in as the wide starter, or is there competition coming in?

Kevin: Lennon provides width. In a system that relies on fullbacks overlapping, you need wingers who can cut inside or stay wide. Lennon does both. But against a deep block like Cincinnati might have played, you need pace. Lennon has it. I see him starting. Unless... they bring in a specialist who offers something fundamentally different.

Nicole: Taha Habroune is another name dropping goals. Three straight games. Where does he fit? Is he a striker or a second striker?

Kevin: Habroune feels like a second striker or an attacking mid. He’s linking up well. But if Amundsen is the main striker, Habroune plays behind him. That creates a triangle: Amundsen up top, Habroune pulling strings, Tapia drifting in. It’s fluid. It’s dangerous. But again, it needs that central hub.

Nicole: So the hierarchy is clear. Abou Ali, Tapia, Lennon, Habroune are core. The gap is between the lines. Lisa in Atlanta asks: 'What about the backup keeper situation? With Schulte playing well, is Pantemis gone?'

Kevin: Pantemis is young. Two saves against Portland isn’t a bad stat if the defense held firm, but they didn’t. Schulte had three saves. Both keepers showed composure. This is a healthy problem. But in MLS, consistency matters. If Schulte keeps clean sheets, Pantemis becomes the cup option. But don’t write off Pantemis yet.

Nicole: Healthy problem. I like that. So, the main battle isn’t internal, it’s external. Who do they bring in? Let’s head to Segment 3 for some fun stuff and your predictions.

Nicole: Segment 3: Fun Hypotheticals. @CrewLife wants to know: 'If the Crew could clone any player in MLS for one match to save their season, who do they clone?'

Kevin: Easy. Clone the best defensive midfielder in the league. Someone who can break up play, recycle possession, and allow Camacho to focus on defending. Just one game of pure midfield control. Imagine that against Inter Miami or Nashville.

Nicole: I’d clone someone who can score from anywhere. Maybe Messi? Just kidding. But seriously, a creative force like that changes everything. Okay, lightning round. Quick takes. Amundsen starter by March? Yes or no?

Kevin: Yes. Confirmed. He’s earned it.

Nicole: Playoff berth? Yes or no?

Kevin: No. Not without the signing. They finish 13th.

Nicole: Open Cup revenge next year? Yes or no?

Kevin: Maybe. But they need to fix the defense first. You can’t win cups on offense alone.

Nicole: Alright, before we wrap up, we need to talk about something important. This show is free. There are no ads, no paywall, nothing. Just pure soccer analysis from Nicole and Kevin. But keeping this daily, independent, and ad-free costs money. If you love hearing about the Crew, tap the link in the episode description to chip in. It helps us keep the mic open for you.

Nicole: Thank you so much for listening. We covered the Amundsen rise, the midfield void, and the harsh reality of 13th place. If you enjoyed this mailbag, please subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Share it with a fellow Crew fan.

Kevin: Keep your heads up, Crew Nation. The work isn’t done. We’ll see you next time.

Nicole: Beatline out!