Crew's Playoff Push: Open Cup Heartbreak and the Race for 9th

Columbus Crew · 2026-11-15 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Nicole: Malte Amundsen is finally finding his rhythm, but can Columbus survive the grind of a playoff race where every point is measured in millimeters? We’re looking at the Open Cup final loss to St. Louis, the win over Toronto, and what it all means for that elusive ninth seed.

Kevin: It’s a tight race, Nicole. The margin between eighth and thirteenth is razor-thin right now. We’ve got the data, we’ve got the context, and we’re ready to break down exactly how the Crew gets there.

Nicole: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Nicole, and alongside me as always is our lead analyst, Kevin. Today is Sunday, November 15th, 2026. If you are new here, you have found your daily home for MLS coverage that actually respects your time and your intelligence.

Kevin: That’s right. We don’t do fluff. We do facts, tactical breakdowns, and honest assessments of where teams stand heading into the most critical stretch of the season.

Nicole: Before we dive into today’s deep dive on the Columbus Crew, we want to take a quick second to talk about this show itself. You know, many listeners ask us why we keep the content this high-quality and accessible every single day. The answer is simple: it’s because of you.

Kevin: Exactly. We believe soccer analysis should be free for everyone. No ads interrupting your commute, no paywalls locking away the good stuff. That model only works if listeners like you chip in to help keep the servers running and the writers paid. It’s a genuine ask from two people who love this game.

Nicole: If you enjoy what we do, please consider supporting us through the link in the episode description. Even a small contribution helps us keep the Beatline free, ad-free, and daily for the next decade. Thank you for keeping this network alive.

Kevin: With that out of the way, let’s get into it. Today we’re talking Columbus Crew. They sit 13th in MLS with a record of 14-5-15. It’s a weird number, right? On paper, they look competitive. In reality, they’re stuck in the middle of the pack.

Nicole: And that’s what we’re unpacking today. We’ve got three big things coming up. First, we’ll look at the division rivals and the league-wide headlines that are shifting around them. Second, we’ll analyze how those results stack up against Columbus’s recent form, especially after that heartbreaking Open Cup final loss to St. Louis. And third, we’ll discuss what outside results mean for their path to the playoffs. Kevin, you mentioned the Open Cup final earlier—let’s start there.

Kevin: Right. The Open Cup final was a massive moment. St. Louis City won their first-ever trophy by defeating Columbus on penalties. It’s a bittersweet end to a strong cup run, but it leaves the Crew with some momentum going back into the league play. Let’s talk about that momentum.

Nicole: So, Kevin, let’s set the scene. The MLS Power Rankings are shifting fast. We see Miami finding its feet, Nashville still leading the way, and Inter Miami moving up after ending a winless drought. Where does Columbus fit into this chaotic landscape?

Kevin: Well, Nicole, if you look at the broader picture, the top tier is solidifying. Nashville is the team to beat, but St. Louis, Philly, and Miami are closing the gap. For Columbus, sitting 13th, the danger isn’t just falling further back—it’s getting swept up in the mid-table chaos while the top six pull away.

Nicole: But wait, didn’t we see the New England Revolution jump eight places in the rankings recently? That suggests the playoff spots are wide open for teams like ours.

Kevin: They did. And that’s the opportunity. The Revs jumping up shows that form is volatile right now. But Columbus has a different problem. They’re not rising; they’re stagnant. Thirteenth place is a graveyard for playoff hopes unless something changes drastically.

Nicole: Stagnant is one word for it. Another word might be inconsistent. We saw them lose to Portland 3-2 in that last game on February 22nd. Felipe Mora had three shots for Portland, and Cole Bassett completed 68 passes. Columbus couldn’t contain the buildup.

Kevin: That’s the issue. Against Portland, Wessam Abou Ali tried to carry the attack with three shots, but without midfield control, it’s lonely up top. Rudy Camacho had 74 accurate passes, which is good, but when the defensive line gets stretched, those passes don’t matter if you can’t transition quickly.

Nicole: So, the league is heating up. Miami is back to winning ways, Nashville is chasing history, and Columbus is watching from the sidelines of the top tier. How do we reconcile that with their recent offensive wins?

Kevin: You reconcile it by looking at the specific opponents. They beat Toronto 4-1, with Malte Amundsen scoring twice in his first career multi-goal game. Then they beat Cincinnati 2-0, with Gonzalo Tapia adding a goal and an assist, and Taha Habroune scoring his third consecutive game.

Nicole: Those are huge wins. Beating Cincinnati closed the gap on the ninth and final playoff spot. That must have given the locker room a massive boost.

Kevin: It should have. But here’s the nuance: beating Cincinnati and Toronto is great, but losing to St. Louis on penalties and dropping points to Portland keeps them at 13th. The gap between sixth and ninth is smaller than the gap between ninth and thirteenth. That’s the structural problem.

Nicole: So, the headline isn’t just “Columbus is struggling.” It’s “Columbus is punching above their weight in weak games but getting exposed in tough ones.” Is that fair?

Kevin: Fair and accurate. They have the firepower to beat anyone on a good day, but the consistency isn’t there yet. And that’s what we need to dissect in the next segment.

Nicole: Let’s zoom in on that offense. Malte Amundsen is clearly emerging. Two goals against Toronto, and he’s been a constant threat. Do you think he’s the guy to anchor their attack for the rest of the season?

Kevin: He’s certainly the focal point. As we discussed in previous episodes, we predicted he’d be a confirmed starter by March, and that looks likely to hold true. But relying solely on him is risky. He needs service.

Nicole: Which brings us back to that creative midfielder we’ve talked about before. The lack of a playmaker behind Amundsen seems to be the Achilles' heel.

Kevin: Exactly. When you look at the Cincinnati game, Gonzalo Tapia stepped up with a goal and an assist. That’s crucial. But in the Portland game, the midfield was disjointed. James Pantemis made only two saves for Portland, but Patrick Schulte had to make three for Columbus. That tells you about the pressure.

Nicole: Three saves for Schulte sounds manageable, but in a high-pressure match, that’s too much exposure. It suggests the defensive line is getting caught high or the press isn’t working effectively.

Kevin: Right. The press is sporadic. When it works, they dominate possession. When it doesn’t, they’re vulnerable to transitions. That’s why the Open Cup final loss hurts so much. It wasn’t just the penalty shootouts; it was the inability to close out the game under pressure.

Nicole: Roman Bürki was stretchered off after a collision in that final. A harsh end to the night for St. Louis, but also a reminder of how physical these matches get. Did that incident distract Columbus mentally?

Kevin: Probably. It’s hard not to be shaken when a key opponent goes down badly. But Columbus still lost on penalties. That’s a mental lapse in the shootout phase. Patrick Schulte’s performance was decent, but in a final, you need more than decent—you need clutch.

Nicole: So, stacking up against rivals: Cincinnati was a statement win. Toronto was a confidence builder. Portland was a wake-up call. Where does that leave them relative to the teams fighting for eighth?

Kevin: It leaves them with potential but unproven resilience. They can score, yes. Amundsen, Tapia, Lennon—all contributing. But defensively, they’re leaky. Conceding three to Portland and losing a final to St. Louis shows they aren’t ready for the postseason intensity yet.

Nicole: We said earlier that if they sign a creative midfielder, they could finish 8th or 9th. Otherwise, they stay 13th. Do you feel confident in that assessment now?

Kevin: I do. Without that extra layer of creativity, the offense becomes predictable. Teams will sit back, absorb the pressure, and hit on the counter. That’s what happened against Portland. They need someone to unlock those defenses consistently.

Nicole: So, the roster battle continues. It’s not just about who starts; it’s about who fits. Amundsen is the striker, but who is the engine in the middle?

Kevin: Until that question is answered, they’re flying blind. The current squad has talent, but it lacks cohesion in the final third. That’s the gap between 13th and 9th.

Nicole: Sticky situation. But let’s pivot to the bigger picture. What do the outside results mean for Columbus? With Miami and Nashville climbing, is the window closing?

Nicole: This is the critical part. Decision Day is looming. The power rankings show Miami finding its feet and Nashville chasing history. If those teams keep winning, the playoff spots become incredibly crowded.

Kevin: And Columbus is already behind. Being 13th means they have less room for error. Every draw is a step backward. They need to win, not just compete.

Nicole: But they have momentum. Five wins in the last six games, including the Toronto victory. Can that momentum carry them through the final stretch?

Kevin: Momentum is fleeting if you don’t fix the structural issues. The midfield vulnerability is real. If they face a team with a strong press, like Philadelphia or even St. Louis again, they could get exposed.

Nicole: So, the prediction holds: if they don’t address the midfield, they remain 13th. If they do, they sneak into 9th. But what about the playoff exit we discussed previously? We thought they’d lose in the quarterfinals.

Kevin: That still stands. Unresolved midfield structural issues lead to quarterfinal exits. It’s not a lack of heart; it’s a lack of tactical depth. They can beat anyone once, but over a series, the weaknesses show.

Nicole: Harsh words, Kevin. But realistic. The fans deserve honesty. If Columbus wants to go deeper, they need to evolve. The Amundsen era is starting, but it needs support.

Kevin: Agreed. The foundation is there. The players are willing. But the system needs to be sharper. That’s the difference between a wild-card team and a contender.

Nicole: And that’s the story of the Columbus Crew right now. Talented, hungry, but incomplete. Heading into Decision Day, they’re fighting for survival, not glory. Or are they?

Kevin: They’re fighting for relevance. One win, one slip, and the dream is over. It’s a high-stakes environment, and they need to rise to it.

Nicole: So, to recap: Columbus Crew sits 13th, 14-5-15, with a mix of offensive hope and defensive worry. They beat Toronto and Cincinnati, lost to Portland and St. Louis, and now face a brutal run-in to the playoffs.

Kevin: The key remains the same: fix the midfield, support Amundsen, and hope the other results go their way. It’s a tall order, but not impossible.

Nicole: If you enjoyed this breakdown, please subscribe, rate, and review the Beatline Podcast Network wherever you listen. Share this with a fellow Crew fan who needs to hear this reality check.

Kevin: Stay tuned for our next episode. We’ll be watching the power rankings closely and seeing if Columbus can defy the odds.

Nicole: Thanks for listening, Crew Nation. Keep the faith, keep the pressure on, and we’ll see you next time. Go Crew!