Crew Roster Battles: Amundsen's Rise and the Midfield Void

Columbus Crew · 2026-11-13 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Nicole: Malte Amundsen just scored his first career multi-goal brace against Toronto, but is he enough to drag the Crew out of 13th place? Today we’re tearing down the roster, line by line, battle by battle.

Nicole: This is the Beatline Podcast Network, America’s number one daily sports podcast. I’m Nicole, and I’m joined by Kevin. Kevin, it’s November 13th, 2026, and we are looking at a Columbus Crew that sits 14-5-15 in the standings, right on the fringe of the playoff hunt.

Kevin: It’s a tight race, Nicole. We’ve talked about this for three days now. The structural issues are real, but the offensive spark is there. Today, we’re focusing specifically on the roster battles that will define whether they secure that ninth spot or get pushed out by teams like New England.

Nicole: Here is what we are tackling today. First, the big question: Is Malte Amundsen locked in as the starter moving forward? Second, we’re looking at the defensive depth chart after that gritty Open Cup final loss to St. Louis City SC. And third, who is trending up and who might be on the chopping block before the offseason?

Kevin: Exactly. We predicted yesterday that if they don’t sign a creative midfielder, they stay 13th. But if they do, they jump to eighth. So the roster construction starts with understanding who is already here and who needs to step up.

Nicole: Let’s get into it. Segment One: The most important position battle right now. We have to talk about Malte Amundsen.

Kevin: Right. After that 4-1 win over Toronto FC, where Amundsen netted two goals—his first multi-goal game in MLS—it’s hard to ignore him. He also had help from Gonzalo Tapia and Brooks Lennon, but Amundsen was the catalyst.

Nicole: But Kevin, we’ve been saying for weeks that the Crew need more than just a striker. They need a creative midfielder to support the attack. Does Amundsen fill that void, or is he just a finisher?

Kevin: He’s a finisher, Nicole. A very good one, but not the playmaker. That’s why the battle isn’t really about him starting; it’s about whether the current midfield can handle the load without him having to drop deep to create. If the midfield stays stagnant, Amundsen becomes isolated.

Nicole: So the battle is between the existing midfield structure and the need for an upgrade? Because last week, against Cincinnati, Taha Habroune scored his third consecutive game, and Tapia had a goal and an assist. The offense was clicking.

Kevin: It was clicking because Cincinnati couldn’t keep up with the transitions. But look at the Portland game. We lost 3-2 away to the Timbers. Felipe Mora had three shots for Portland, while Wessam Abou Ali had three for us. It was a shootout, but defensively, we got exposed.

Nicole: And Patrick Schulte made three saves in that game. He was busy. That tells me the team wasn’t controlling the ball as much as we’d like in the final stretch.

Kevin: Exactly. Schulte had to be involved. The battle here is whether the coaching staff trusts the current midfield unit to build up play consistently, or if they need to bring in someone new to link Habroune, Tapia, and Amundsen together.

Nicole: We mentioned in our prior predictions that Amundsen would be a confirmed starter by March. With this form, does that prediction hold water?

Kevin: It absolutely holds. You don’t bench a guy scoring braces against Toronto and contributing to wins against Cincinnati. But the real battle is behind him. Who gets the minutes in front of the defense when Rudy Camacho is playing center back?

Nicole: Camacho had 74 accurate passes in the Portland game. That’s solid build-up play from the back. But does he have the creativity to unlock a low block?

Kevin: Camacho is reliable, but he’s not a creator. That’s why Cole Bassett had 68 accurate passes for Portland. They found a way to move the ball. If Columbus doesn’t add a creative mid, they’re going to struggle against teams that park the bus.

Nicole: So the battle is clear: Can the current midfield sustain the pressure, or is an acquisition inevitable? Let’s move to Segment Two. We’re looking at two more battles. First, the defense after the Open Cup final.

Kevin: The Open Cup final loss to St. Louis City SC was painful. Roman Bürki was stretchered off after a collision. St. Louis won on penalties. It was their first trophy, and it hurt us deeply.

Nicole: That injury to Bürki was scary. But looking at the roster, who steps up if Schulte isn’t available? Or if we need more depth in the back line?

Kevin: This is where the depth chart gets thin. Camacho is your anchor. But behind him, we need bodies that can handle the physicality of MLS. The battle is between experience and youth in the center-back spots.

Nicole: And what about the fullback positions? In the Portland game, did we see width being utilized effectively?

Kevin: Not really. Portland controlled the wide areas. Felipe Mora was dangerous. We need our fullbacks to push higher and provide outlets for Camacho’s long balls. If they sit too deep, the midfield gets clogged.

Nicole: So the second battle is fullback energy versus defensive caution. And the third battle? It’s about the bench. Who provides the spark off the bench?

Kevin: Brooks Lennon gave us something against Toronto. But we need consistent production from the substitutes. When Amundsen comes on, or when Tapia rotates, the intensity has to stay high.

Nicole: Because right now, the momentum is there. Five wins in the last six games. But consistency is key for that ninth-place spot.

Kevin: Consistency requires depth. If the starters get tired or injured, the second string has to be ready. That’s the battle. Are we prepared for a 30-game grind?

Nicole: Let’s wrap this segment with a thought on Miami. They’re finding their feet in the Power Rankings. Are they a threat to push us out of the playoffs?

Kevin: Absolutely. Messi’s Inter Miami is moving up. They’re hot. If they keep winning, they’ll squeeze out anyone not playing well. We can’t afford slumps.

Nicole: Stick with us. We’re taking a quick break, but when we come back, we’re making our roster-cut predictions. Who’s trending up, and who’s heading for the door? Don’t go anywhere.

Nicole: Welcome back. Segment Three: Roster-cut predictions and trends. Let’s start with who is trending up. Malte Amundsen is obvious. But who else?

Kevin: Gonzalo Tapia. Goal and assist against Cincinnati. He’s becoming a focal point. If he keeps this up, he’s untouchable.

Nicole: Tapia is essential. What about Taha Habroune? Three goals in a row. Is he safe?

Kevin: Habroune is dangerous in transition. But he needs support. If the midfield doesn’t feed him, his numbers drop. He’s trending up, but it’s fragile.

Nicole: Now, who is trending down? Or who might be cut?

Kevin: If we don’t add a creative midfielder, the current midfielders who can’t create are in trouble. They become liabilities against top teams.

Nicole: So it’s not necessarily a specific name, but a type of player? The non-creators?

Kevin: Exactly. The system demands creativity. Without it, you’re playing 10-man football mentally. Those players get exposed.

Nicole: And what about the goalkeepers? Schulte vs. someone else?

Kevin: Schulte showed promise against Portland. Three saves in a tough loss. He’s earning trust. Unless there’s an emergency, he’s the guy.

Nicole: So the cuts will likely come from the midfield or fullback spots to make room for new talent.

Kevin: Yes. We need fresh legs and fresh ideas. The current squad has heart, but it lacks the creative spark to dominate consistently.

Nicole: Final thought: Will the Crew make the playoffs? Based on these battles, what’s your call?

Kevin: If they sign that creative mid, yes. Eighth or ninth place. If not, we stick with our prediction: quarterfinal exit due to structural issues.

Nicole: There you have it. The Crew are at a crossroads. Amundsen is rising, but the midfield needs help. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network.

Nicole: Before we go, we need your help. This breakdown of the roster battles and tactical nuances is exactly why we love this game, and keeping it free means we need your support. Please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description to help us keep bringing you daily, high-quality soccer analysis.

Kevin: Your support allows us to dig deeper into these stats and predictions every single day. It truly makes a difference.

Nicole: Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Let’s get the Crew into those playoffs. Go Crew!