Nicole: We just lost the U.S. Open Cup final on penalties to St. Louis City SC, and Roman Bürki was stretchered off with a head injury. But wait—the Crew just beat Toronto 4-1, Gonzalo Tapia is scoring, and Malte Amundsen is finally breaking out. Is this team built for next year or broken forever?
Kevin: It’s complicated, Nicole. We’re sitting 13th in MLS with a 14-5-15 record. That’s not playoff material right now. But if we look at the last six games, five wins? That’s a different story. Let’s unpack it.
Nicole: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Nicole, and this is your daily Columbus Crew deep dive. Joining me as always is our tactical analyst, Kevin. Kevin, you ready to tackle the mailbag?
Kevin: Born ready, Nicole. We’ve got three segments today. First, we’re answering your questions about that heartbreaking Open Cup loss and the immediate fallout. Then, we’re digging into the roster battles—specifically that midfield void we talked about yesterday. And finally, a lightning round on what’s coming in the offseason.
Nicole: Perfect roadmap. We’re going live with your emails and tweets. Let’s start with Segment One: The Aftermath. Sarah from Rochester wants to know why we even played in the Open Cup when we were struggling so hard in the league standings.
Kevin: Great question, Sarah. Honestly? It’s about squad depth. You can’t rest an entire starting XI for two months. But tactically, it exposed our transition weaknesses. Against St. Louis, we didn’t have the creative spark to break their press in the final third. That’s why we keep saying we need a number ten.
Nicole: Right. And @ColumbusClutch asks: "Did Patrick Schulte play well?" He had three saves against Portland earlier, but how did he look in the final?
Kevin: Schulte was solid until the penalty shootout. In open play, his positioning was good. But those penalties? That’s mental fortitude. St. Louis won their first-ever trophy because they stayed colder under pressure. We flinched. That’s the difference between 13th place and a championship.
Nicole: Ouch. Okay, Marcus in Denver has a tough one: "If we’re 13th, why are people talking about us making noise next season?"
Kevin: Because of the trajectory, Marcus. Look at the last six games. Five wins. We beat Cincinnati 2-0, with Gonzalo Tapia adding a goal and an assist. We crushed Toronto 4-1. Malte Amundsen scored twice—his first multi-goal game in MLS. Brooks Lennon and Tapia chipped in too. The offense is waking up.
Nicole: Exactly. And Rudy Camacho was linking up beautifully with 74 accurate passes against Portland. The pieces are there, Kevin. But the defense... let’s talk about that structural issue we mentioned yesterday.
Kevin: The defensive line is too high without enough support in midfield. When we lose possession, we get countered. That’s why New England jumped eight spots in the power rankings—they’re structurally sound. We’re not. Until we fix that build-up play, we’ll stay stuck around 9th to 13th.
Nicole: Okay, sticking with that theme. Segment Two: Roster Battles. Emily from Westerville asks: "Is Malte Amundsen the future starter?" Remember, we predicted back in November that he’d be a starter by March next season.
Kevin: I stand by that prediction, Emily. His performance against Toronto was undeniable. Two goals, control of the attack. He’s not just a finisher; he’s creating space for Tapia and Lennon. If he stays healthy, he’s your primary striker. No doubt.
Nicole: But here’s the rub, Kevin. @SoccerDadCLT says: "Who is supporting him?" We keep hearing about the lack of a creative midfielder. Who fills that role right now?
Kevin: Currently? It’s a group effort. Gonzalo Tapia drops deep, Brooks Lennon provides width. But it’s inconsistent. Against Portland, Felipe Mora had three shots for them, while Wessam Abou Ali had three for us. Abou Ali is working hard, but we need someone who can unlock that final pass consistently. Cole Bassett had 68 accurate passes for Portland—that level of control is what we’re missing.
Nicole: So, does that mean we need to buy in the offseason? Or can Taha Habroune step up? He’s scored in three consecutive games against Cincinnati.
Kevin: Habroune is hot right now, don’t get me wrong. But relying on a winger to create central chances is risky. I think we see an acquisition. A dedicated playmaker. Without one, we risk staying 13th. With one, we could jump to 8th or 9th, maybe even crack the playoffs properly.
Nicole: Let’s hope the front office listens. Because if they don’t, those playoff predictions from the last few days might come true in the worst way. Speaking of which, Segment Three: Hypotheticals and Lightning Round. James from Austin asks: "If the Crew signed Messi tomorrow, where would they finish?"
Kevin: James, if Messi comes, they win the league. Period. Miami is already climbing the power rankings with him. Adding him to a team that just beat Toronto 4-1? That’s unstoppable. But realistically, we’re looking at someone more attainable.
Nicole: Okay, lightning round. Quick takes. Gonzalo Tapia or Wessam Abou Ali for Player of the Year honors in this rebuild phase?
Kevin: Tapia. Goals AND assists. Versatility. He’s the engine right now.
Nicole: Agreed. Next: Best moment of the season so far? Not counting the Open Cup final loss.
Kevin: The Cincinnati win. Closing the gap on 9th. That felt like momentum. Then the Toronto thrashing. Those are the peaks.
Nicole: Last question for Kevin: What’s the one thing that needs to change immediately for next season?
Kevin: A creative midfielder. Stop the turnover chain. Build-up play must improve. Otherwise, we’re just running in place.
Nicole: Well said, Kevin. So, to recap: We lost the Open Cup, but we’re winning games, Amundsen is emerging, and the offseason plan hinges on one key signing.
Kevin: Exactly. If they get that midfielder, watch out. If not, 13th place again. The ball is in the board's court now.
Nicole: Before we go, listeners—if these daily breakdowns help you navigate your commute or morning routine, consider supporting the show. A small tip keeps this free content flowing every single day. Just use the link in the episode description.
Kevin: Thank you for listening. Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you get your podcasts. Share this with a fellow Crew fan.
Nicole: Keep the faith, Crew Nation. We’ll see you tomorrow.