Columbus Crew: Open Cup Heartbreak and the Playoff Push

Columbus Crew · 2026-11-10 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Nicole: The penalty kick. The silence. And then, a trophy slipping away from St. Louis City SC’s hands—wait, no, that’s not right. It was Columbus Crew who stood tall in regulation, only to see their first-ever major trophy opportunity vanish on the spot from twelve yards out. That is the story we are breaking down today.

Kevin: It’s a bitter pill for the Crew. You fight through the regular season, you beat Cincinnati, you beat Toronto, you reach the U.S. Open Cup final against St. Louis, and then... penalties. It’s a specific kind of pain that haunts a locker room for months.

Nicole: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we live for the beautiful game. I’m Nicole, and I’m joined by my analyst partner Kevin. Today, we’re looking at the Columbus Crew’s strange position in 2026. We’ve got three big things coming up: First, we’re diving into that heartbreaking Open Cup final loss to St. Louis City SC and what it means for the club's identity. Second, we’re checking in on how those recent wins against Toronto and Cincinnati have shifted the MLS power rankings. And third, we’re talking about the lingering midfield questions that Kevin and I have been obsessing over for days now.

Kevin: That’s right. And if you’ve been listening since Thursday, you know exactly which midfield question I’m talking about. The lack of a creative number ten. But before we get back to that tactical rabbit hole, let’s look at the landscape around us.

Nicole: Let’s start with the headlines, because the league is heating up as we approach Decision Day. ESPN’s MLS Power Rankings are dropping, and there’s some movement that directly impacts Columbus. Miami finds its feet again, Nashville is still No. 1, but here’s the kicker: the New England Revolution jumped eight places. Eight places! They’re jumping right up toward the playoff picture.

Kevin: Eight places is massive momentum. When teams like New England jump that high, it usually means they’ve found consistency in transition. For Columbus, sitting at 13th in MLS with a 14-5-15 record, every team moving up makes the path to the ninth spot—the final playoff berth—steeper. It’s a crowded table.

Nicole: And speaking of crowded tables, let’s talk about St. Louis. St. Louis City SC won the first trophy in their club’s history by beating Columbus in that Open Cup final. It was a historic night for them, but for us? It was a miss. Remember, Roman Bürki was stretchered off after a collision in that final. A serious injury for their keeper, but it didn’t save Columbus from the penalty shootout defeat.

Kevin: Right. And it’s ironic because just weeks before that, Columbus looked unstoppable. They beat Cincinnati 2-0, with Gonzalo Tapia contributing a goal and an assist, and Taha Habroune scoring his third consecutive game. That was their fourth win in five games. Then, they went to Toronto and Malte Amundsen scored twice—his first career multi-goal game in MLS—with Brooks Lennon and Tapia adding more. Five wins in six games heading into the final, and then... silence on the scoreboard in extra time.

Nicole: Amundsen is having a moment. But Kevin, this brings us back to our running theme. In the Open Cup final, did you feel the midfield creativity was missing when the game opened up?

Kevin: Absolutely. It was there. Without that creative midfielder to unlock the defense in tight spaces, Columbus relied too heavily on individual brilliance and set pieces. Against St. Louis, who had a solid defensive structure, that wasn’t enough. You need someone to drag defenders out of position so players like Amundsen or Tapia can exploit the half-spaces. That’s the gap we’ve been talking about.

Nicole: So while St. Louis celebrates their first trophy, Columbus has to reflect on a season that felt like two different movies. One where they were winning four in a row, and another where they choked on penalties. How does that affect their standing in the league right now?

Kevin: Well, statistically, they’re 13th. 14-5-15. It’s confusing, right? Because the form guide says they’re good. The recent results say they’re good. But the points total puts them outside the playoff spots. Let’s stack them up against those rivals moving up. New England is climbing. Inter Miami is finding its feet with Messi leading the charge. Nashville is still the team to beat.

Nicole: And Columbus? They’re stuck in that middle tier. Not bad enough to tank, but not good enough to secure the top seeds. Let’s look at their last real test before the playoffs loom: that trip to Portland Timbers. February 22nd. They lost 3-2. Felipe Mora led Portland with three shots, Cole Bassett moved the ball well with 68 accurate passes. For Columbus, Wessam Abou Ali had three shots, Rudy Camacho controlled the midfield with 74 accurate passes.

Kevin: Camacho was excellent in that game. 74 accurate passes shows he was trying to build from the back, but without the creative spark behind him, those builds often stalled. Abou Ali getting three shots is great for a forward, but it highlights the isolation. He’s isolated. That’s the issue. Compare that to the Toronto game where Amundsen was supported by Lennon and Tapia. The synergy was there. In Portland, it felt disjointed.

Nicole: Disjointed is the perfect word. And Patrick Schulte had to make three saves for Columbus in that Portland game. James Pantemis, Portland’s keeper, only had two. So Columbus created chances, but couldn’t finish consistently enough to overcome the deficit. Now, with the Revs jumping eight spots in the rankings, does Columbus have enough firepower to catch them?

Kevin: If they keep the current roster unchanged? Probably not. We predicted earlier that without a creative midfielder, they’d stay around 13th. If they sign one, maybe they climb to 8th or 9th. It’s that binary outcome. The talent is there—Tapia, Amundsen, Camacho—they’re all MLS-ready. But the system needs that extra layer of creativity to break down organized defenses like St. Louis or New England.

Nicole: So the offseason isn’t just about adding bodies; it’s about adding brains. A playmaker. Someone who can do what Bassett did for Portland but with more verticality. Someone who can turn that 74-pass game into a 74-pass game with three key passes added. That’s the difference between 13th and 8th.

Kevin: Exactly. And it’s not just about offense. Our previous predictions also mentioned defensive structural issues. The lack of a creative midfielder forces the fullbacks higher, leaving gaps in transitions. When you lose possession, you’re exposed. That’s why the penalty shootout loss stings—it’s a symptom of a deeper tactical imbalance.

Nicole: Ouch. Okay, let’s pivot to the bright side. Those wins against Cincinnati and Toronto. Taha Habroune’s three-game scoring streak. Malte Amundsen’s breakout. Are these guys ready to carry the load if the new signing doesn’t come in immediately?

Kevin: They’re ready to try. Habroune’s consistency is valuable. Amundsen’s confidence is peaking. But relying on forwards to create their own opportunities is inefficient. You want your midfielders to create. You want your wingers to cut inside. Right now, Columbus is asking their strikers to be playmakers too. It’s a role reversal that works sometimes, but not against the best teams.

Nicole: So, is it too late for the trade deadline? Or is this strictly an offseason move? Because if they don’t act soon, that 13th place standing might become permanent.

Kevin: I think it’s mostly offseason. The trade market for creative midfielders is thin, and Columbus might not have the assets to pull off a blockbuster right now. But that doesn’t mean they’re done. They have a core group that’s gelling. The Open Cup run proved they can compete with anyone on any given day.

Nicole: And that’s the key phrase: “on any given day.” Soccer is chaotic. But chaos favors the prepared. St. Louis prepared for penalties and won. Columbus prepared for open play and lost in the shootout. What does this mean for their path forward? Does the heartbreak fuel them, or does it weigh them down?

Kevin: It fuels them. Look at the reaction. They’re not hanging their heads. They’re analyzing. They’re talking about the midfield gap. That self-awareness is rare. Most teams would blame the referees or the weather. Columbus is blaming their own tactical setup. That’s a good sign for growth.

Nicole: Growth requires action though. If they sit still, Nashville keeps moving up. Miami keeps finding its feet. New England keeps jumping eight spots. Columbus stays at 13th. Is that acceptable for a club with their ambitions?

Kevin: No. Never. Columbus has history. They’ve won championships. Sitting at 13th is a far cry from their legacy. They need to address the midfield deficiency aggressively. Whether it’s a trade, a free agent signing, or promoting from within, they need that creative spark. Without it, they’re just another mid-table team fighting for a wildcard spot.

Nicole: And if they don’t get it? Then our prediction stands: quarterfinal exit due to unresolved structural issues. But if they do? We’re looking at an 8th or 9th place finish, and a much deeper playoff run.

Kevin: Precisely. The margin for error is razor-thin. Every pass matters. Every decision matters. That’s why we watch. To see if they can solve the puzzle.

Nicole: Before we go, I want to check in on that prediction from a few days ago. Kevin, you said Malte Amundsen would be a starter by March next season. With this performance against Toronto, is that a lock now?

Kevin: It’s a lock. Two goals, plus the support from Lennon and Tapia. He’s not just a starter; he’s a focal point. The coaching staff will ride this wave.

Nicole: Alright, folks, that’s the wrap. Columbus Crew sits at 13th, heartbroken by St. Louis in the Open Cup final, but hungry for a creative midfielder to push them into the playoff hunt. We’ve talked about the midfield gap, the rising rivals like New England, and the bright spots in Amundsen and Habroune.

Kevin: It’s a pivotal moment for the club. The talent is there, but the structure needs work. If they fix the midfield, they’re dangerous. If they don’t, they’re stuck in mediocrity. The choice is clear.

Nicole: We love bringing you this daily deep dive, but keeping the feed running, editing the episodes, and researching the stats takes time and resources. If you enjoy our breakdowns, please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. Your support literally powers the research and editing that keeps this show free and daily for you.

Kevin: It helps us dig deeper, find those hidden stats, and bring you the analysis you deserve. Thank you for being part of the community.

Nicole: Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Share this episode with a fellow Crew fan. Until next time, keep your head up and your boots laced tight. Go Crew!