Blue Jays Mailbag: Scherzer's Last Dance, Infield Chaos & The 2027 Breakout

Toronto Blue Jays · 2026-10-29 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Melissa: The lights are off at the Rogers Centre, the confetti is swept up, and the 2026 season is officially in the history books. But for Blue Jays fans, the story doesn't end with a 79-83 record. It starts with a question that’s been burning all October: Can Max Scherzer actually do it one last time? We’re talking about the 42-year-old ace who just struck out seven on short rest in the season finale to secure his 225th career victory. Is this the twilight of a legend, or the spark for a 2027 resurgence? Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, I’m Melissa Harris.

Ryan: And I’m Ryan O’Connor. Today is a mailbag episode, which means we’re digging into your questions about the roster, the standings, and the absolute chaos in the infield. We’re looking at the AL East picture, where Toronto sits second, and trying to figure out what moves John Schneider needs to make before November hits. We’ve got Spencer Arrighetti, Vladimir Guerrero Jr., and a bullpen that needs serious help. Let’s get into it.

Melissa: Here is what we are tackling today. First, we’re answering your questions about Max Scherzer’s role heading into 2027 and whether he can still anchor the rotation. Second, we’re dissecting the crowded infield—Ernie Clement, Josh Smith, Andres Gimenez—and figuring out who stays and who goes. And third, we’ve got a fun hypothetical about the new ABS system and how it might change player development for guys like Shane Bieber. Let’s start with Segment One: The Pitching Staff and the Veteran Anchor.

Melissa: Our first question comes from @JaysFanatic99, who asks: 'Max Scherzer just threw 7+ innings on three days' rest against the Reds. He’s 42 years old. Do the Blue Jays keep him as a starter, or move him to the bullpen to save his arm?' Ryan, you’ve been tracking his velocity all year. What does the data say?

Ryan: It’s a fascinating tactical dilemma. On paper, moving a guy with Scherzer’s stuff to the bullpen seems like a no-brainer for longevity. You can throw harder, more frequently, without the wear and tear of five days of recovery. But look at what he just did. Seven strikeouts, 225th win, holding the line against Cincinnati. If you put him in the relief corps, you’re risking a high-leverage spot with a guy whose mechanics are starting to show age. My take? Keep him in the rotation, but limit his innings. He’s not going to pitch 200 frames again. He’s an anchor, not a workhorse.

Melissa: So you’re saying trust the veteran instinct over the traditional model? That feels risky for a team that finished 79-83.

Ryan: It’s calculated risk. Look at the rest of the staff. You’ve got Spencer Arrighetti coming up, Dylan Cease, Jameson Taillon. If Scherzer can eat 150 innings while staying healthy, that’s huge. But if he starts feeling tight in June, the bullpen switch is always there. Guys like Paul Sewald and Brendan Cellucci are ready to absorb some load. But right now? He’s getting the ball every fifth day.

Melissa: Okay, next question. This one is from Sarah in Mississauga. She writes: 'Spencer Arrighetti was projected to break out in 2027. With Scherzer potentially sticking around, does Arrighetti lose his spot? Or is there room for both?' We talked about this yesterday, Ryan. The breakout star narrative.

Ryan: Arrighetti isn’t going anywhere. He’s young, he’s got the stuff, and frankly, the Blue Jays need depth. You don’t bench a promising young arm because you have a Hall of Fame veteran. Think of it as a platoon situation, but by health. If Scherzer gets hit, Arrighetti steps in. If Scherzer is dominant, Arrighetti pushes for a Cy Young conversation alongside him. The roster has room for both. In fact, having Scherzer mentor Arrighetti could be the key to unlocking that potential we predicted last week.

Melissa: I love that. Mentorship meets competition. Now, let’s talk about the other side of the mound. Luis Urias asked via Twitter: 'With the ABS system overturning 54% of challenged calls, how does this affect the catcher’s game plan for Alejandro Kirk? Is he calling fewer pitches now?' Great point. The automated strike zone changes everything.

Ryan: It absolutely changes the game. Catchers used to be able to manipulate the zone, to frame pitches on the edge that weren’t quite strikes. Now? The robot doesn’t care about framing. It cares about geometry. For Alejandro Kirk, this means he needs to be even more precise in his pitch selection. No more hoping for a borderline call. He has to attack the heart of the plate or swing and miss. It puts more pressure on the pitchers to execute, but it also levels the playing field for hitters who have good plate discipline.

Melissa: So, precision over manipulation. Got it. One more quick one from Marcus in Hamilton: 'Shane Bieber is on the roster. Does he factor into the 2027 rotation plans, or is he a trade chip?' Bieber has been quiet this season, but his name keeps coming up.

Ryan: Bieber is a wild card. If he’s healthy and clicking, he’s a top-five starter. If he’s struggling with command, he’s a massive trade asset. Given the Blue Jays’ need for bullpen help, trading a high-ceiling starter like Bieber for a closer like Chad Dallas or Trey Yesavage could be the move. But I think they’ll try to make it work internally first. You don’t trade a talent like that unless you have to.

Melissa: Alright, we’re taking a quick breath here. Before we dive into the infield mess, I want to ask you something directly. Ryan, you know why we’re here. We’re independent, daily, and we do this because we love the game. But research, editing, and keeping this feed running costs money. Every coffee, every small contribution helps us keep the lights on and the stories coming. If you value these deep dives into the Blue Jays’ future, please consider chipping in through the link in the episode description. It keeps us free for everyone. Thank you for listening.

Melissa: Welcome back to Segment Two: The Infield Chaos. We’ve got four guys fighting for two spots. Ernie Clement, Josh Smith, Andres Gimenez, and Charles McAdoo. This is a crowded house. David from Etobicoke asks: 'Who is the most expendable second baseman? And can we trade one for bullpen help?' We predicted this would happen. Who’s going?

Ryan: This is the million-dollar question. Josh Smith has the highest upside, but he’s inconsistent. Ernie Clement is reliable but maybe not a everyday guy. Andres Gimenez is a defensive wizard, but his bat has stalled. If I’m John Schneider, I’m looking at trading Josh Smith. His trade value is highest right now. You package him with a minor league arm to get a proven reliever. Maybe someone like Mason Fluharty or Devereaux Harrison. You clear the path for Clement or McAdoo to compete for the job.

Melissa: Trading the guy with the most upside? That feels bold. But you’re right, the bullpen is leaking runs. We saw it all season. If you can stabilize the late innings, it translates to wins. How do you handle the fallout if Smith’s bat takes off next year?

Ryan: You take the chance. You’re 79-83. You need to fix the losses, not the wins. The bullpen is the weakness. Fixing it gives you a better shot at those 85-88 wins we projected. If Smith blossoms, you traded him too early. But if you keep him and the bullpen continues to struggle, you’re stuck at .500 forever. It’s a gamble, but a necessary one.

Melissa: Okay, so Smith is the likely trade candidate. What about the others? Jessica in Scarborough asks: 'If Josh Smith is gone, who starts at second base? Is it Ernie Clement or Charles McAdoo?'

Ryan: I’d lean toward Ernie Clement. He’s the veteran presence. He knows the system. He’s consistent. McAdoo has power, but he’s raw. In a competitive AL East, consistency matters. You want a guy who won’t beat himself. Clement fits that bill. But keep McAdoo in the mix for platoon situations. Left-handed pitching? Bring McAdoo in. Righties? Clement holds the fort.

Melissa: Solid plan. Now, what about shortstop? Andres Gimenez is underperforming. Kevin in London asks: 'Is Andres Gimenez still the everyday shortstop, or should they bring up someone else? The defense is great, but the offense is dead.' Your thoughts on Gimenez?

Ryan: Gimenez is a tough one. Defensively, he’s elite. But offensively? He’s a liability. In modern baseball, you can’t hide a weak bat, especially in the middle infield. If they trade Smith, they might look to move Gimenez too. But the market for shortstops is thin. They might have to stick with him and hope for a late-season surge. Or, they promote a prospect from the minors. But for now? He’s the starter until he proves otherwise.

Melissa: So, stay the course on Gimenez, but keep a close eye on his OPS. One more from Tyler in Burlington: 'Vladimir Guerrero Jr. had a down year. Is he done? Or will he bounce back in 2027?'

Ryan: Vladimir is Vladimir. He’s going to bounce back. He’s a generational talent. A down year is part of the cycle. Look at his launch angle, his contact rate. He’s still hitting the ball hard. It’s just not falling in for hits this year. Next year? He’s back to being the MVP candidate we all expected. Don’t panic. Just wait.

Melissa: Thank goodness for that. Okay, Segment Three: Fun Hypotheticals and Lightning Round. First up, a hypothetical from @BaseballNerdTO: 'If the Blue Jays could design their own stadium rules for 2027, what’s the first thing you change? Bigger bases? Shorter fences?'

Ryan: Smaller fences. Definitely smaller fences. The game has become too pitcher-dominated. We need more offense. Make the outfield a little friendlier. Let guys like Davis Schneider and Brett Bateman drive the ball. It would make the games more exciting for the fans.

Melissa: I’m with you. More home runs, less napping. Okay, lightning round. Rapid fire. Who is the surprise breakout star for 2027? Not Arrighetti. Someone else.

Ryan: Jameson Taillon. He’s been overlooked. If he finds his slider again, he’s a dark horse Cy Young contender.

Melissa: Bold pick. Who is the biggest disappointment? Give me a name.

Ryan: Kazuma Okamoto. He hasn’t found his footing. If he doesn’t click, he’s gone.

Melissa: Ouch. Okay, final question from Lisa in North York: 'What is the one thing the Blue Jays MUST do in the offseason to reach the playoffs?'

Ryan: Stabilize the bullpen. That’s it. Fix the late innings. Everything else is secondary. If you stop bleeding runs, you win games.

Melissa: Ryan, that is a strong finish. Stabilize the bullpen, trade for pitching, and watch Scherzer write his final chapter. We’ve covered a lot today. From Scherzer’s 225th win to the infield shuffle, the Blue Jays have a lot of work to do before Spring Training. But there’s hope. There’s talent. And there’s us, breaking it all down.

Ryan: Exactly. The foundation is there. Now it’s just about building the right structure around it. Thanks for listening, Jays Nation.

Melissa: Before we go, if you enjoyed this mailbag, please subscribe, rate, and review the show on your favorite platform. It helps more fans find us. And share this episode with a fellow Blue Jays fan who needs to hear about Scherzer’s last dance. Go Jays! We’ll see you tomorrow.