Melissa: Max Scherzer just punched his ticket to history books with his 225th career win, striking out seven on short rest in the season finale. But while the headlines celebrate the legend, the real story is what this means for a Blue Jays team sitting second in the AL East with a 79-83 record.
Ryan: It’s a fascinating pivot point. We’re looking at a roster that has plenty of talent but needs some serious structural changes if they want to climb that standings table next year. Let’s get into it.
Melissa: Welcome back to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Melissa, and I’m joined by Ryan. If you’re new here, you’ve found America’s number one daily sports podcast network. Today, we’re breaking down the Blue Jays’ end-of-season wrap-up, the massive implications of Scherzer’s final start, and how division rivals are shaping up for 2027.
Ryan: Right. And as Ava mentioned in the intro, we’ve got three big things coming up. First, we’re looking at the division rivalries and what the AL East landscape looks like now that October is over. Second, we’re diving deep into how Toronto stacks up against those teams based on their current roster construction. And third, we’ll talk about what outside results—like the World Series matchups and league-wide trends—mean for the Jays' path forward.
Melissa: Before we get there, let’s address the elephant in the room: Max Scherzer. Sunday wasn’t just another game. It was a statement. At 42 years old, pitching on three days’ rest, he struck out seven over seven-plus innings. That is not something you see every day. That is elite-level stuff.
Ryan: And he got the win, too. His 225th. Against the Reds, no less. Brandon Valenzuela and Charles McAdoo homered, the Blue Jays won 5-1, and Scherzer looked like he was twenty years younger. It was a perfect send-off for a guy who has carried this rotation for years.
Melissa: Okay, let’s shift gears to the division. The Blue Jays finished second in the AL East. That’s huge for a team that many expected to struggle more. But who are they fighting against? And what’s happening around them?
Ryan: Well, the headlines tell us the AL East is still a dogfight. We know the Yankees have achieved the most wins in ALCS history, which tells you something about the pedigree in that division. They’re always tough. Always dangerous.
Melissa: Right. And then there’s the broader context. This year’s Fall Classic will crown a first-time winner. Here’s where it stands among the best matchups of this century. So, the competition at the top is getting sharper, faster.
Ryan: Exactly. And for Toronto, being second in the AL East with a 79-83 record means they’re close. Really close. But also, there’s some weird noise coming out of Ohio. An Ohio bettor was banned for alleged threats toward Blue Jays manager John Schneider during the 2025 World Series.
Melissa: That is disturbing. Gaming regulators stepped in, but it highlights the pressure these managers and players are under. John Schneider has done a great job keeping this team together through ups and downs, and hearing about threats directed at him is just... it’s not right.
Ryan: It’s a dark side of modern baseball, especially with the gambling integration. But it doesn’t change the fact that Toronto is sitting pretty in second place. The question is, can they hold onto that spot when the Yankees and others are adding firepower?
Melissa: Let’s talk about the ABS system. Robot umpires flipped 54% of challenged calls in the first season. Catchers were far more successful than batters. How does that impact the Jays’ infield-heavy lineup?
Ryan: This is critical. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Alejandro Kirk rely on plate discipline. If catchers are winning challenges more often, pitchers are getting away with more strikes. It forces hitters to be more aggressive earlier in counts. For a team with guys like Andres Gimenez and Ernie Clement, who value contact, it might actually help. Less chasing, more hitting.
Melissa: So the robot helps the contact hitters? Interesting take. I’d argue it hurts everyone because the margin for error shrinks. But Ryan makes a good point about aggression.
Ryan: It’s all about launch angle and OBP. If you can’t draw walks because the zone is tighter, you have to hit the ball harder. Guerrero and Kirk are built for that. They’re power hitters. They don’t need walks as much as they need barrels.
Melissa: Fair enough. But let’s not forget the injury concerns or the depth issues. We talked about the crowded infield last week. Who’s standing out right now?
Ryan: Kazuma Okamoto at third base has been solid. Myles Straw in center field brings defense. And Davis Schneider in left? He’s emerging as a consistent threat. But the infield is still crowded. Josh Smith, Luis Urias, Ernie Clement... it’s a lot of bodies.
Melissa: And that’s why we said last week that a trade is coming. We predicted the Blue Jays would trade a second baseman by November to bolster the bullpen. Do you still think that’s the move?
Ryan: Absolutely. You can’t keep four second basemen on the roster if you want to compete. You need arms. Look at the bullpen names: Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas, Braydon Fisher, Mason Fluharty, Devereaux Harrison, John Klein, Chase Lee, Brendon Little, Spencer Miles, Jose Rodriguez, Tyler Rogers, Paul Sewald, Ricky Tiedemann, Louis Varland. That’s a lot of arms, but not enough quality ones.
Melissa: So you’re saying the front office needs to cut one of those infielders to bring in a closer or a setup man?
Ryan: Not necessarily a closer. A reliable middle reliever. Someone who can eat innings. Because right now, the rotation is set with Scherzer, Arrighetti, Bieber, Cease, Taillon, Soriano, Van Eyk, Yesavage. That’s eight starters. Too many. But the bullpen needs stability.
Melissa: Okay, so we’re leaning into the trade narrative. But let’s talk about Scherzer again. He just had his best game in years. What does this mean for his 2027 role?
Ryan: He’s 42. He pitched on short rest. He struck out seven. He got the win. This isn’t a full-time starter role anymore. It’s a veteran anchor. Maybe five starts a month. High-leverage spots. But his presence alone stabilizes the whole staff.
Melissa: We touched on this in the mailbag yesterday. Fans are asking if he’ll stay past 2026. Given this performance, do you think he comes back?
Ryan: I think he wants to. And I think Toronto wants him. But contracts are tricky. If they pay him like a frontline starter, he’ll decline. If they pay him like a luxury veteran, he’ll thrive. It’s about managing expectations.
Melissa: Alright, we’re going to take a quick break here. Stick with us. We’re coming back to talk about how the Jays stack up against their rivals, and whether Spencer Arrighetti is ready to step up as the surprise breakout star we predicted.
Melissa: Welcome back. We’re talking division rivals. The Blue Jays are second in the AL East. But how do they actually stack up against the Yankees, the Red Sox, the Rays, and the Orioles?
Ryan: It’s tight. The Yankees have the most ALCS wins, which means they have experience. Experience matters in October. But Toronto has youth. Spencer Arrighetti, Shane Bieber, Dylan Cease. That’s a young core.
Melissa: And Max Scherzer. Don’t forget Scherzer. He’s the glue. But if he leaves, who fills that void?
Ryan: Spencer Arrighetti. We predicted he’d be the surprise breakout star for the Blue Jays in 2027. And I still stand by that. He’s got the stuff. He’s got the confidence. After seeing Scherzer’s finish, Arrighetti knows what it takes to pitch deep into games.
Melissa: But Arrighetti hasn’t shown consistency yet. Can he handle the workload?
Ryan: He can. He’s young. He’s learning from the best. And if the Blue Jays trade a second baseman for bullpen help, Arrighetti gets more run because the pen won’t collapse late in games.
Melissa: So the trade isn’t just about saving money. It’s about enabling the starters to succeed?
Ryan: Exactly. Pitching wins championships. Not just starting pitching. Bullpen depth. If you lose leads in the seventh inning, it doesn’t matter how good your starter was. You need reliability.
Melissa: Let’s look at the offense. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is a monster. Alejandro Kirk is behind the plate. But who else?
Ryan: Davis Schneider. Myles Straw. Andres Gimenez. They’re all contributors. But the infield is crowded. Josh Smith, Luis Urias, Ernie Clement... it’s a mess. Someone has to go.
Melissa: Who goes? Who stays?
Ryan: Smith has upside. Urias has experience. Clement has speed. But you can’t keep all three. I’d say Urias is the most expendable. He’s older. He’s not as dynamic. Trade him for a reliever.
Melissa: Okay, so we’re predicting a trade. Again. We said it yesterday. We said it two days ago. Is it happening?
Ryan: It’s inevitable. The front office knows it. The fans know it. The only question is when. November is the deadline. We’re already there.
Melissa: So, if you’re a Blue Jays fan, expect news soon. Big moves ahead.
Ryan: Big moves. Or big trades. Same thing.
Melissa: Alright, before we move on to our next segment, I want to take a moment to talk about you. Our listeners. We put out a fresh show every single day, covering every team, every angle, every nuance. It takes a lot of work, a lot of research, and a lot of passion. And honestly, it’s a handful of supporters like you that make it possible. When you chip in, even just a few dollars, it keeps this show free and daily for everyone. So if you love what we do, please consider supporting us at the link in the episode description. It means the world to us.
Melissa: Thanks for that. Now, let’s talk about the bigger picture. What outside results mean for the Blue Jays’ path. The World Series is wrapping up. A first-time winner is crowned. Where does this rank among the best matchups since 2000?
Ryan: It’s high up there. Great TV. Great stakes. But for Toronto, it’s about watching. Learning. Seeing what works in October.
Melissa: And the Silver Linings for MLB’s non-playoff teams. Your favorite team won’t be playing in October—but that doesn’t mean the season was a total loss. Right?
Ryan: Right. Toronto finished 79-83. Second in the AL East. That’s progress. From last year to this year. There’s growth. There’s potential.
Melissa: So, predictions time. We said the Blue Jays would finish between 85 and 88 wins in 2027. Do you still think that’s realistic?
Ryan: I do. If they make the bullpen trade, if Scherzer stays in a limited role, if Arrighetti breaks out... yeah. 85 to 88 is very achievable.
Melissa: What about Scherzer’s future? Will he retire after 2026?
Ryan: Maybe. Maybe not. He’s 42. But he’s pitching well. If he feels good, he’ll play. If he doesn’t, he’ll hang ‘em up. Either way, he’s a legend.
Melissa: One last thing. The robot umpires. 54% of challenged calls flipped. Catchers winning more. How does that change the game for 2027?
Ryan: It changes everything. Batters have to adjust. Pitchers have to adjust. Coaches have to adjust. It’s a new era. And Toronto has to adapt faster than anyone.
Melissa: Adapt or die. That’s the lesson.
Ryan: Exactly. The game is evolving. And the Jays need to evolve with it.
Melissa: Alright, that’s it for today’s episode. We covered Scherzer’s historic night, the division rivalry landscape, and the need for bullpen trades. Make sure to subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen. And share this with a fellow Blue Jays fan!
Ryan: Thanks for listening. Keep your eyes on November. Big moves are coming.
Melissa: From the Beatline Podcast Network, I’m Melissa. I’m Ryan. Go Jays!