Blue Jays Power Rankings: Scherzer’s Legacy & The Infield Shakeup

Toronto Blue Jays · 2026-10-27 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Melissa: He just turned forty-two, pitched on three days’ rest, and struck out seven over seven-plus innings to secure his two-hundred-and-twenty-fifth career victory. That is not just a win; that is history written in real-time against the Reds.

Ryan: And yet, when you look at the bigger picture of this franchise, Max Scherzer’s brilliance feels like both a celebration and a stark contrast to the rest of the roster. We are looking at a team that finished seventy-nine and eighty-three, sitting second in the AL East, but the story here isn’t just about where they are—it’s about what comes next.

Melissa: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, I’m Melissa. This is your daily deep dive into the game we love.

Ryan: And I’m Ryan. Today is our power rankings episode for the Toronto Blue Jays. We’re breaking down exactly where this team stands in the division hierarchy, analyzing the glaring strengths versus the critical question marks in the bullpen, and giving you a realistic outlook for the twenty-seventeen season.

Melissa: We’ve got some heavy lifting to do. First, we’ll rank them in the AL East and see if that second-place finish was flattered by the standings. Then, we’re talking about the infield logjam and why trading a second baseman might be the key to stabilizing the back end of the rotation. Finally, we’ll give you our win projection for next year. Stick with us.

Melissa: Alright, let’s get right into it. Power rankings. The Blue Jays finished seventy-nine and eighty-three. They are second in the AL East. Now, usually, when I hear seventy-nine wins, I think playoff bubble or wild card chase, but here they are sitting behind the league leaders. Ryan, be honest with me—is this a respectable second place, or were they bailed out by their rivals?

Ryan: It’s a nuanced second place. You have to look at the context of the division. The Blue Jays weren’t quite elite offensively, but they weren’t terrible. The real story here is how they managed to stay relevant despite having a very crowded infield. When you look at the roster construction, having guys like Ernie Clement, Andres Gimenez, Charles McAdoo, Josh Smith, and Luis Urias all competing for time at second base... that’s not a strength, that’s a logistical nightmare.

Melissa: That is such a good point. It’s like they built an infield of second basemen and forgot what to do with the shortstops. But in terms of pure ranking, where do they sit? Are they a top-five team in baseball right now based on this performance?

Ryan: I’d put them around eighth or ninth in the overall league, but definitely top four in the American League East. They beat teams they should beat, and they lost games they probably shouldn’t have, which is classic seventy-nine-win behavior. But the divisional standing matters more because it sets the tone for their identity. They aren’t the Yankees, and they aren’t the Red Sox. They are the grittier, slightly confused, but fundamentally sound Blue Jays.

Melissa: Gritty and confused. I love that. And let’s talk about the manager, John Schneider. He’s been through the wringer this year. There was even some news about an Ohio bettor being banned for making threats toward him during the twenty-fifty World Series—though clearly, that was past tense, it shows the pressure cooker he operates in. Does he deserve credit for keeping this team together?

Ryan: Absolutely. Managing a roster that doesn’t know its own position players is hard. But he got Max Scherzer to perform at an All-Star level in his final act. That’s huge. Scherzer striking out seven on short rest in the season finale wasn’t just a stat line; it was a statement. It showed that even with all the chaos around him, the veteran leadership anchored the team. If you’re ranking teams, you have to reward stability, and Schneider provided that despite the roster oddities.

Melissa: Right. And speaking of Scherzer, can we acknowledge that this was his two-hundred-and-twenty-fifth win? At forty-two years old, pitching on three days' rest? That is legendary stuff. It changes how we view the team’s legacy heading into the offseason.

Ryan: It does. It shifts the narrative from 'what went wrong' to 'look at what we achieved.' Even though they missed the postseason, ending the season with a Scherzer masterclass gives the fanbase something to hold onto. It’s a high note. But as we move into the rankings, we have to ask: is this sustainable without him? Because once Scherzer hangs ’em up, who steps up?

Melissa: That leads perfectly into our next segment. Who *is* stepping up? Because we have Spencer Arrighetti, Shane Bieber, Dylan Cease, Jameson Taillon, Jose Soriano, CJ Van Eyk, and Trey Yesavage in the mix. It’s a deep staff, but also a confusing one. Let’s talk strengths and weaknesses.

Melissa: Okay, Segment Two. Strengths and Question Marks. Ryan, you mentioned the infield logjam earlier. But if we’re talking about the biggest strength of this Blue Jays team, I’m tempted to say the starting pitching depth. We have Scherzer obviously, but we also have Spencer Arrighetti coming off a breakout year, and Shane Bieber still having that ace-level stuff when healthy. Is that the core?

Ryan: That is the core. And I want to circle back to something we predicted on the show a few days ago. Remember, we said Spencer Arrighetti would be the surprise breakout star for twenty-seventeen? Well, looking at how he developed alongside Scherzer and Bieber, I stand by that completely. He’s young, he’s got upside, and he’s learning from the best. That trio—Arrighetti, Bieber, and maybe Cease if he stays healthy—that is a top-five rotation in the American League.

Melissa: I love that prediction. And honestly, it makes sense. Arrighetti has been buzzing in the minors and early calls, but seeing him step into that environment with Scherzer there to guide him? It’s the perfect incubator. So, if the rotation is strong, where are the cracks? Because every team has them.

Ryan: The bullpen. It’s always the bullpen. Look at the list: Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas, Braydon Fisher, Mason Fluharty, Devereaux Harrison, John Klein, Chase Lee, Brendon Little, Spencer Miles, Jose Rodriguez, Tyler Rogers, Paul Sewald, Ricky Tiedemann, Louis Varland. That is fifteen relief pitchers. Fifteen! For a team that only plays one hundred and sixty-two games, that is way too many arms vying for nine spots.

Melissa: Fifteen names for nine spots? That’s not a roster, that’s a committee meeting. And this ties directly into what we talked about in the mailbag yesterday—the idea that they need to trade one of those second basemen to bolster the bullpen. Do you think that’s the right move?

Ryan: I think it’s the *only* logical move. You have too many middle infielders who can play second base, and you don’t have enough reliable arms in late-inning roles. Trading someone like Josh Smith or Ernie Clement for a proven closer or a high-leverage setup man makes perfect sense. You clear out the clutter, you stabilize the back end, and you give your starters a chance to actually win games in the ninth inning instead of just hoping they go twelve innings themselves.

Melissa: Exactly. And let’s not forget the impact of the Automated Ball-Strike system this year. We saw robot umpires overturn fifty-four percent of challenged calls. How does that affect these pitchers? Does it help the bullpens manage stress, or does it make them less effective because they can’t manipulate the zone as much?

Ryan: It actually helps them, ironically. When you take away the ability to argue balls and strikes, pitchers focus more on execution. Paul Sewald, for instance, thrives on command. In a world where the strike zone is absolute, his precision becomes even more valuable. The challenge is for the younger arms who rely on framing or pitcher-catcher默契. But for veterans like Sewald or even Scherzer, the ABS system removes a variable. It’s cleaner. It’s tougher, but it’s fairer.

Melissa: Fairer and tougher. I like that. So, if we’re trading a second baseman for a reliever, and Arrighetti is emerging, and Scherzer is finishing his career on a high note... what does the rest of the roster look like? What about Vladimir Guerrero Jr.? He’s the anchor at first base, but does he carry enough weight to offset the infield confusion?

Ryan: Vladimir Guerrero Jr. carries everything. He’s the constant. While everyone else is shuffling around second base, Vlad is putting up MVP-caliber numbers at first. He’s the face of the franchise. But he can’t do it alone. The offense needs contributions from Davis Schneider in left field, Alejandro Kirk behind the plate, and maybe a breakout from someone like Brandon Valenzuela or Shawn Ross. The batting order is talented, but it lacks consistency outside of Vlad.

Melissa: Consistency is the keyword. And that brings us to our final segment. Outlook and projections. Where do we see the Blue Jays going in twenty-seventeen? Are we looking at eighty-five wins? Ninety? Or are we stuck in the same seventy-nine-win groove?

Melissa: Segment Three. Realistic Season Outlook. Ryan, we’ve talked about the rotation getting stronger with Arrighetti’s emergence. We’ve talked about potentially fixing the bullpen by shedding infield depth. If those two things happen, how many wins are we adding?

Ryan: I think we add six to eight wins. If the bullpen stabilizes, you stop losing close games in the ninth. If Arrighetti develops into a true number three starter, you stop getting swept by the top-tier teams. I’m projecting somewhere between eighty-five and eighty-eight wins. That puts them firmly in the wild card hunt, if not fighting for a division title again.

Melissa: Eighty-five to eighty-eight. That’s a significant jump from last year’s seventy-nine. And remember, we also predicted that the team would finish between eighty-two and eighty-three wins in twenty-six... wait, no, that was last year’s projection. We predicted they’d hit eighty-three. So we’re aiming higher this time?

Ryan: We are. And it’s because the ceiling is higher. Last year, the ceiling was capped by the bullpen’s inconsistency. This year, if they make that trade we discussed—moving a second baseman for a reliever—they unlock that potential. Plus, Scherzer’s presence, even if he’s winding down, raises the floor. Young guys like Ricky Tiedemann or Louis Varland can learn from watching him work. That mentorship value is priceless.

Melissa: Mentorship value. I hadn’t thought of it that way. So, it’s not just about Scherzer’s stats; it’s about his influence. And what about the other rookies or young guys? Like Kazuma Okamoto at third base? Or Myles Straw in center field? Do they factor into the win total?

Ryan: They do. Okamoto provides power depth, which is crucial in the long grind of a season. And Straw’s speed and defense in center field take runs away from the opposing hitters. Every little bit counts. When you’re trying to squeeze out those extra five or six wins, defensive positioning and speed matter. The Blue Jays have the tools to do it; they just needed to organize the roster properly.

Melissa: Organize the roster. That’s the theme of the offseason. Clear the infield, fix the bullpen, let Arrighetti shine, and watch Vlad carry the load. It sounds like a plan. Before we head to sign-off, I want to take a quick moment to talk about you, our listeners. If today’s breakdown helped you see the Blue Jays in a new light—if understanding the infield logjam and the bullpen strategy made your fantasy lineup or your betting picks sharper—then consider supporting the show. We keep this content free and daily because of fans like you. Please chip in via the link in the episode description. It helps us keep the mic open and the analysis sharp.

Melissa: Thank you so much for that support. Ryan, any final thoughts before we wrap up this power rankings episode?

Ryan: Just this: respect the process. The Blue Jays are rebuilding, but they’re doing it with character. Scherzer’s final bow was perfect. Now it’s time for the next generation to step up. I’ll be watching closely.

Melissa: We will too. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network. Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and review wherever you get your podcasts. Go Jays!