Melissa: Max Scherzer just punched out seven batters on three days' rest to secure his 225th career win, and now the entire front office is trying to figure out if a forty-two-year-old ace belongs in the rotation next spring. Plus, do we really have three second basemen for two spots? We are diving into your mailbag right now.
Ryan: It’s a wild offseason already, Melissa. We’ve got questions about the bullpen, the position player logjam, and that historic finish against Cincinnati. Let’s get into it.
Melissa: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Melissa, and alongside our lead analyst Ryan, we are your daily source for everything Toronto Blue Jays. This is the Mailbag Special, October twenty-fifth, twenty-twenty-six.
Ryan: Hey everyone. It’s been a busy few days here at the network. We’ve covered the season finale, the standings, and the headlines. Today, you’re driving the bus.
Melissa: That’s right. We’ve got three segments today. First, we’re tackling the biggest question on everyone’s mind: Max Scherzer’s role in 2027. Then, we’re looking at the roster construction issues, specifically that infield clutter. And finally, a lightning round of quick hits and hypotheticals. So grab your notes, because this is going to be fast.
Melissa: Let’s start with the elephant in the room. @ScherzerFan99 asks: 'After striking out seven on short rest to beat the Reds 5-1, is Scherzer definitely a starter in 2027 or is he moving to the pen?'
Ryan: Well, the performance was undeniable. Seven strikeouts over seven-plus innings on three days' rest is elite stuff. But context matters. He earned his 225th victory, which is historically significant, but he’s also forty-two years old.
Melissa: Right, and we talked about this yesterday. The team finished 79-83, second in the AL East. They aren’t in a desperate win-now mode, but they need stability. Do you think John Schneider wants him as a fifth starter?
Ryan: I think they want him wherever he provides value. If he stays in the rotation, he’s likely a back-end guy, similar to where Jameson Taillon might slot in based on our previous analysis. But given the age and the workload, a hybrid role or limited starts makes sense.
Melissa: Wait, limited starts? You’re saying they might actually ride Shane Bieber and Dylan Cease hard while Scherzer goes eight games a year?
Ryan: I’m saying that’s a smart baseball move. You protect the asset. Spencer Arrighetti is another name we’ve discussed as a breakout candidate, so maybe Scherzer’s spot opens up for younger arms like CJ Van Eyk or Trey Yesavage.
Melissa: Okay, but what about the fan who asked about the ABS system impact? '@BlueJayNation' says: 'The robot umpires flipped 54% of challenged calls this season. How does that change how Scherzer pitches differently than in his prime?'
Ryan: That’s a huge data point. Catchers were far more successful than batters in challenging calls. For a pitcher like Scherzer, who relies on command, the consistency of the zone helps. He doesn’t have to chase perfection; he just has to locate. That’s probably why he was able to strike out seven even on short rest.
Melissa: So, no more arguing with the home plate umpire? Just throw strikes and let the algorithm do the work?
Ryan: Exactly. It removes one variable. For a veteran, that clarity is gold. He knows exactly where the edges are.
Melissa: Alright, let’s pivot. Sarah from Rochester writes in: 'With Brandon Valenzuela and Charles McAdoo homering in the finale, and guys like Ernie Clement and Andres Gimenez on the roster, where does everyone fit in 2027?'
Ryan: This is the messy part. You’ve got Vladimir Guerrero Jr. locked at first base. Alejandro Kirk behind the plate. Shawn Ross and Brandon Valenzuela catching. Then look at the infield: Ernie Clement at second, Andres Gimenez at short, Kazuma Okamoto at third. Plus Josh Smith, Luis Urias, and Charles McAdoo all capable of playing second.
Melissa: That’s three second basemen and a utility man who can play second? It’s crowded, Ryan. We predicted earlier that one of those second basemen would be traded by November.
Ryan: We did. And I stand by it. You cannot carry four guys who primarily play second base unless one is a clear trade chip. I still think it’s Josh Smith or Luis Urias moving out for pitching depth.
Melissa: Because the bullpen needs help?
Ryan: Absolutely. Look at the relief corps. You’ve got Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas, Braydon Fisher, Mason Fluharty, Devereaux Harrison, John Klein, Chase Lee, Brendon Little, Spencer Miles, Jose Rodriguez, Tyler Rogers, Paul Sewald, Ricky Tiedemann, and Louis Varland. That’s fifteen relievers. You don’t need fifteen relievers.
Melissa: Fifteen?! That’s an overflow. Who gets cut?
Ryan: Probably the lower-tier arms. Guys like Spencer Miles or Chad Dallas might be non-tendered or traded. But the key is using that infield surplus to upgrade the back end of the bullpen.
Melissa: Before we go to segment two, we need to talk about keeping this show running. Our listeners keep the Beatline free, with no ads and no paywall. Your support protects that independence. Please check out the link in the episode description to chip in if you can—it keeps us daily and honest.
Melissa: Welcome back. Let’s talk roster battles. '@JaysFanatic' asks: 'Is George Springer still the everyday DH, or does Davis Schneider take over?'
Ryan: Springer brings experience and leadership. Schneider has power potential. But looking at the outfield, you’ve got Brett Bateman in center, Nathan Lukes and Rudy Martin Jr. in right, and Yohendrick Pinango in left. Springer fits best as a DH to give them rest.
Melissa: And what about Myles Straw? He’s in center too. Is there a platoon there?
Ryan: Straw is a defensive specialist. If Pinango struggles defensively in left, Straw might see time in center or right. It’s a complex puzzle. Sean Keys is also listed as a DH, so the competition is real.
Melissa: Okay, big question from Marcus in Denver: 'Spencer Arrighetti was mentioned as a breakout star. What’s the plan for him versus Trey Yesavage and CJ Van Eyk?'
Ryan: Arrighetti has shown flashes. If Scherzer moves to a limited role, Arrighetti could step into the fourth or fifth spot. Yesavage and Van Eyk are also options. It depends on spring training performance.
Melissa: So, no guaranteed job yet?
Ryan: None. Baseball is merit-based. Whoever throws the best strikes wins the job.
Melissa: Let’s hear from '@RookieYear': 'What happens to Jose Soriano and Jameson Taillon if the rotation shakes up?'
Ryan: Taillon is a veteran presence. We’ve said before he might hold the fifth starter role. Soriano is younger. If Taillon isn’t effective, Soriano could push for more innings.
Melissa: And if neither works? We discussed trading for pitching.
Ryan: Exactly. The infield surplus is currency. Use it wisely.
Melissa: One last question for this segment. '@PitchingNerd' asks: 'Will Paul Sewald remain the closer?'
Ryan: Sewald has experience. But with so many arms in camp, competition is inevitable. Ricky Tiedemann is another option. Don’t assume it’s set in stone.
Melissa: Thanks for the insights, Ryan. Before we go to our final segment, remember: our community keeps this show free. No ads, no paywall. Help us stay independent by visiting the link in the episode description.
Melissa: Lightning round! First hypothetical: If the Blue Jays won the World Series this year, who would be the MVP?
Ryan: Vladimir Guerrero Jr. He’s the anchor. Without him, the lineup lacks power.
Melissa: Second: Who is the most underrated player on the roster?
Ryan: Alejandro Kirk. His defense and pitch framing are invaluable, especially with the ABS system.
Melissa: Third: Will the Blue Jays make the playoffs in 2027?
Ryan: If they stabilize the bullpen and manage the rotation wisely, yes. We’ve predicted low 80s wins, which is competitive in the AL East.
Melissa: Final quick take: What’s the biggest risk for the team off-season?
Ryan: Losing key veterans without replacement depth. They need to be careful with contracts.
Melissa: That’s it for today’s mailbag! We covered Scherzer’s future, the infield logjam, and your burning questions. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network.
Ryan: Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Share this with a fellow Blue Jays fan.
Melissa: Up North! Go Jays Go!