Melissa: Max Scherzer just added his 225th career victory at age forty-two, striking out seven on short rest in the season finale. But is that the end of an era, or the start of a new chapter for this roster? We’re answering your questions right now.
Melissa: This is the Beatline Podcast Network, home of the Toronto Blue Jays daily show. I’m Melissa, and I’m joined by Ryan. Ryan, what a way to close out the regular season with a historic performance.
Ryan: It really was. Seven strikeouts over seven-plus innings on three days’ rest. That’s not just good pitching; that’s veteran dominance. But today, we’re shifting gears. It’s mailbag day, so let’s get into the questions you’ve sent about where this team goes from here.
Melissa: We have a packed bag today. First up, we’re tackling the immediate future of Max Scherzer and how his recent outing changes the conversation around the rotation heading into 2027. Then, we’ll dive deep into those infield battles—specifically the second base logjam we talked about last week. And finally, we’ll look at the bullpen depth chart and answer your questions about who stays and who goes. Let’s start with the headline grabber.
Melissa: First question comes from @BlueJayFan90. They ask: 'Max Scherzer just got his 225th win in the finale. Does this performance make him the clear choice for the fifth starter spot next year, or is he too old to handle a full workload?' Ryan, what do you see?
Ryan: Well, it certainly makes a compelling argument. When you look at the line—seven strikeouts, only one run allowed over seven-plus innings—it shows his stuff is still there. But we have to be realistic about age. He’s forty-two. Throwing on three days’ rest is a luxury he can’t replicate every five days. If he starts, he needs proper recovery time.
Melissa: Right, and we’ve seen other pitchers struggle when they try to come back on short notice later in the year. So are we looking at a limited role? Maybe five starts, then moving to long relief?
Ryan: That’s a very plausible scenario. The Blue Jays have Spencer Arrighetti, Shane Bieber, Dylan Cease, Jose Soriano, Jameson Taillon, CJ Van Eyk, and Trey Yesavage all in the mix. Scherzer could provide a high-ceiling spark for five starts if the club manages his innings carefully. But relying on him for a full schedule is risky. His value is in quality, not quantity.
Melissa: So it’s less about locking him into the fifth slot permanently and more about seeing if he can mentor the younger arms like Arrighetti or Yesavage while providing ace-level outings when needed. That makes sense. Next question, from Sarah in Hamilton: 'With the robot umpires now fully implemented, how did the ABS challenge system impact the Blue Jays’ approach at the plate this year, and should that change their strategy in spring training?'
Ryan: This is huge. The data shows robot umpires overturned fifty-four percent of challenged calls league-wide, with catchers having much higher success rates than batters. For a team like Toronto, which relies on plate discipline and getting on base, this changes everything. You can’t just swing away anymore; you have to be precise.
Melissa: So players need to be smarter about what they challenge. If catchers are winning more challenges, maybe batters should be more selective rather than trying to force calls.
Ryan: Exactly. It rewards patience. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Alejandro Kirk are great examples of hitters who thrive in counts. If they can leverage the new system by being more disciplined early in counts, they can exploit the margins that human umpires might have missed. It’s a subtle shift, but over a sixteen-game stretch, those extra walks add up.
Melissa: Great point. One more from this segment, from Marcus in Mississauga: 'The Blue Jays finished second in the AL East at 79-83. Given the headlines about non-playoff teams finding silver linings, what is the biggest positive takeaway from this season besides Scherzer’s milestone?'
Ryan: I’d argue it’s the depth of the pitching staff. Even without making the playoffs, you saw guys like Brandon Valenzuela and Charles McAdoo contribute offensively, and the starters held their own. The fact that they were competitive enough to finish second shows the foundation is solid. It’s not a rebuild; it’s a refinement phase.
Melissa: Refinement. I love that. Okay, let’s move to Segment Two. We’re talking roster construction. Last week we discussed the crowded infield, specifically the battle for second base among Josh Smith, Ernie Clement, Charles McAdoo, and Luis Urias. This question from @JaysCountry asks: 'Who gets traded first? Is one of these guys going to be moved before November to acquire pitching depth?'
Ryan: This is the big one. We predicted earlier that the Blue Jays would trade one of their second basemen by November. Looking at the current roster, Josh Smith has the highest upside, but he’s also expensive. Charles McAdoo and Luis Urias offer versatility. If the front office wants to stabilize the bullpen, they might look to move McAdoo or Urias to address those relief corps holes we saw throughout the year.
Melissa: Because the bullpen has so many arms—Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas, Braydon Fisher, Mason Fluharty, Devereaux Harrison, John Klein, Chase Lee, Brendon Little, Spencer Miles, Jose Rodriguez, Tyler Rogers, Paul Sewald, Ricky Tiedemann, Louis Varland—it’s hard to keep them all. Trading an infielder for a proven reliever makes sense.
Ryan: Precisely. You have to balance the books. If you bring in a closer or a setup man, you need to create room elsewhere. McAdoo and Urias are tradeable assets because they can play multiple positions. Smith is more of a core piece, but if the price is right, you don’t say no. It’s about maximizing value before free agency hits.
Melissa: Next question, from Emily in Oshawa: 'Jameson Taillon was mentioned as a potential fifth starter. Do you still see him holding that role, or does Scherzer bump him down?'
Ryan: I still believe Taillon holds the fifth starter role. Scherzer’s situation is unique due to his age and the need for rest. Taillon provides consistency and durability. If Scherzer starts five games, Taillon takes the remaining spots. It’s a stable plan that doesn’t risk burning out a veteran arm or forcing a young pitcher into a premature debut.
Melissa: And what about the other starters? Spencer Arrighetti, Shane Bieber, Dylan Cease, Jose Soriano, CJ Van Eyk, Trey Yesavage. Who rounds out the top four?
Ryan: Cease and Bieber are locks for the top two. Arrighetti has shown promise as a young arm. Soriano is the wildcard—he’s been solid, but can he sustain it? Van Eyk and Yesavage will compete for the fourth spot. It’s a deep group, which is rare for Toronto. That’s a strength heading into 2027.
Melissa: Okay, final question for this segment, from David in Brampton: 'George Springer and Sean Keys are listed as DHs. With Vladimir Guerrero Jr. playing first base, who gets the most at-bats at DH, and how does that affect the lineup order?'
Ryan: Springer is the everyday DH. He brings power and experience. Keys is more of a platoon option or pinch-hit specialist. The lineup will likely feature Guerrero third or fourth, Springer fifth or sixth, and Alejandro Kirk behind the plate or filling in defensively. It’s a flexible offense that can adapt based on matchups.
Melissa: Flexible and deep. I like it. Before we go to our final segment, I want to take a quick moment to talk about you, the listener. We’ve been working hard to bring you this kind of detailed, fact-based analysis every single day, covering everything from Scherzer’s milestones to the intricacies of the ABS challenge system. To keep this show free and daily, we need your help. If you’ve enjoyed our breakdowns of the Blue Jays’ roster and playoff hopes, please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. Your support keeps the lights on and the mic open. Thank you for being part of the Beatline community.
Melissa: Welcome back. Segment Three: Fun Hypotheticals and Lightning Round. First, a hypothetical from @RaptorsRico (wait, wrong network! From @JaysFanatic): 'If the Blue Jays could sign one free agent pitcher to complement their current rotation, who would it be?'
Ryan: They don’t need another starter. They need bullpen help. A high-leverage reliever who can bridge the gap between the starters and the closer. Someone with strikeout ability to complement the ground-ball focus of Cease and Arrighetti.
Melissa: Agreed. Now, lightning round. Quick answers. Question one: Who is the MVP candidate for 2027?
Ryan: Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Melissa: Question two: Who is the surprise breakout star?
Ryan: Spencer Arrighetti.
Melissa: Question three: Will the Blue Jays win the World Series in 2027?
Ryan: It’s possible, but they need to tighten up the defense and stabilize the bullpen. If they do, they’re right in the mix.
Melissa: Final lightning round question: What is the one thing the fans should watch for in spring training?
Ryan: The competition for the fourth starter spot and the second base logjam. Those two areas will define the early season.
Melissa: Ryan, thanks for breaking down the mailbag with me. We covered Scherzer’s future, the infield shuffle, and the bullpen depth. It’s a lot to unpack, but the outlook for 2027 is promising.
Ryan: Absolutely. The foundation is there. Now it’s about execution. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network.
Melissa: If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, rate, and review us on your favorite podcast app. Share it with a fellow Blue Jays fan. Until next time, GO JAYS!