Jays Roster Battles: Infield Chaos, Bullpen Depth & Scherzer's Legacy

Toronto Blue Jays · 2026-10-21 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Melissa: You think you know the Toronto Blue Jays? You think you’ve seen the whole board? Think again. Because right now, in Toronto, there is a position group so crowded it could split into two teams just to play each other in spring training.

Ryan: And we’re not talking about the outfield. We’re talking about second base and the bullpen. It’s a logjam of talent that might actually be a problem if they can’t figure out who plays where.

Melissa: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Melissa, and this is The Daily Jays. I’m joined by Ryan, and today we are diving deep into the 2026 roster battles. We finished 79-83, second in the AL East, but October is here, and the real work starts now.

Ryan: Right. So here’s what we’re tackling today. First, the absolute chaos at second base: Ernie Clement, Charles McAdoo, Josh Smith, Luis Urias. Four guys for maybe one spot. Second, the bullpen depth chart with over a dozen arms listed as RP. And third, who gets cut when the roster shrinks from 40 to 26?

Melissa: It’s going to be fun. Let’s get into it. Segment One: The Infield Logjam. Ryan, you predicted Jameson Taillon would hold the fifth starter role last week, which makes sense given the rotation has Scherzer, Bieber, Cease, Cellucci, and Tiedemann. But the infield? That’s a different story.

Ryan: Exactly. The rotation is set. Scherzer’s legacy is secure after that 225th win against the Reds, striking out seven on short rest. Bieber and Cease are anchors. But look at the infield. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is locked at first. Andres Gimenez is the everyday shortstop. So everything else is up for grabs.

Melissa: And at second base, you have Ernie Clement, Charles McAdoo, Josh Smith, and Luis Urias. Plus Kazuma Okamoto at third, but he’s more of a utility guy. Who do you see starting most days?

Ryan: This is where it gets messy. Josh Smith has the highest upside. He’s young, he’s athletic, and his defensive metrics at second base are elite. If the Jays want to build for 2027, Smith is the guy. But Ernie Clement is the veteran presence. He knows the system. He’s consistent.

Melissa: But wait, Charles McAdoo came up late in the year. He had some big moments, including that homer in the season finale. Does he push Smith off the bench?

Ryan: McAdoo is a power bat, but defensively, he’s more suited for third or first. At second, Smith is superior. The Jays might end up using a platoon or a daily matchup game. But if I had to pick one everyday player, it’s Smith. Clement is the bridge. Urias? He’s depth. He’s solid, but he’s not winning the job outright.

Melissa: So Smith wins the starting gig, Clement is the super-utility man, and McAdoo shifts to third when Okamoto needs a break? That leaves Luis Urias... fighting for a roster spot?

Ryan: Urias is in danger. He’s a career backup. If Smith is the starter, and Clement/McAdoo cover the rest, Urias might be the first call-up when someone gets hurt. But he’s not starting 150 games. That’s the hard truth.

Melissa: Okay, so we have our infield hierarchy. Now, let’s talk about the battery. Alejandro Kirk is the anchor behind the plate. But who’s the backup? Shawn Ross and Brandon Valenzuela are both catchers on the roster.

Ryan: Kirk is an All-CAL caliber catcher. He’s not going anywhere. Between Ross and Valenzuela, it’s about defense and pitch framing. Ross has more experience. Valenzuela is younger. I think Ross holds the backup role because of his ability to manage a pitching staff, especially with a young rotation like this.

Melissa: Makes sense. You need a veteran voice in the dugout. Okay, let’s move to Segment Two. The Bullpen. This is where the Blue Jays have the most options and the least clarity. We have Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas, Braydon Fisher, Mason Fluharty, Devereaux Harrison, John Klein, Chase Lee, Brendon Little, Spencer Miles, Jose Rodriguez, Tyler Rogers, Paul Sewald, Ricky Tiedemann, Louis Varland. That’s fourteen relief pitchers!

Ryan: Fourteen arms. It’s overwhelming. And it’s not even all of them. You have Max Scherzer still technically on the roster, though he’s done. You have Jose Soriano and CJ Van Eyk as starters who might flip to long relief. The competition for the middle innings is fierce.

Melissa: Paul Sewald is the closer, right? He’s the only established high-leverage arm left from last year. Who takes over the eighth inning?

Ryan: Sewald is the closer. That’s settled. But the eighth? That’s where it gets interesting. Brendon Little has been dominant in the minors. He’s got a nasty slider. If he’s ready, he’s the favorite. But then you have John Klein, who’s a ground-ball machine. Great for holding runners. And Devereaux Harrison has velocity.

Melissa: Wait, Ricky Tiedemann is listed as RP? He was a top prospect starter. Did he get moved?

Ryan: He was moved. The front office decided his stuff wasn’t quite ready for the majors as a starter, but his stuff plays up in short bursts. He’s a reliever now. It’s a risk, but if he stays healthy, he could be a setup man. Same with Louis Varland. He’s raw, but he’s tough.

Melissa: So you have Little, Klein, Tiedemann, Varland, Harrison, plus the veterans like Sewald and Rogers. That’s nine guys competing for four spots. Who gets left off?

Ryan: Tyler Rogers is the odd man out. He’s a knuckleballer. Great flavor, but in today’s game, with robot umpires and launch angle optimization, the knuckleball is a liability. Unless there’s an injury crisis, Rogers doesn’t make the 26-man roster. He’ll likely go to Triple-A to refine it.

Melissa: That’s a bold take. A knuckleballer getting sent down? But you’re right, the margins are too thin. What about Chad Dallas and Braydon Fisher? Where do they fit?

Ryan: They’re depth. If the team goes on a road trip or deals with injuries, Dallas and Fisher are the ones called up. They’re safe arms. They don’t blow it early. But they aren’t going to close out a game. They’re fill-in pieces. So the core is Sewald, Little, Klein, and maybe Tiedemann or Varland for the seventh/eighth.

Melissa: Okay, so we have the infield and the bullpen mapped out. Let’s bring it home with Segment Three. Roster Cuts. We need to get from 40 to 26. That means cutting 14 players. Who’s trending up? Who’s trending down?

Ryan: Trending up: George Springer. Even if he’s DH, his leadership and clutch hitting are invaluable. Davis Schneider in left field is also trending up. He’s young, he’s got pop, and he defends well. He’s going to win the starting job over Yohendrick Pinango or Nathan Lukes.

Melissa: I agree on Springer. And Schneider? Yes. He’s the future of that corner outfield spot. Who’s trending down? I’m looking at Sean Keys. He’s a DH, but Springer and Guerrero Jr. eat up those spots. Keys is strictly utility.

Ryan: Keys is in trouble. Also, Myles Straw in center field. Brett Bateman is faster, better defender. Straw is a nice bench piece, but if you have to cut someone, he’s the one. And remember, we talked about the ABS challenge system earlier. Catchers are struggling more than batters. That puts pressure on the backup catcher spot. Shawn Ross has to perform to keep his job.

Melissa: Right. So my final cuts list? I’m keeping: Guerrero, Gimenez, Smith, Clement, Okamoto, Kirk, Springer, Schneider, Bateman. Then the pitching: Scherzer (just for show), Bieber, Cease, Tiedemann, Sewald, Little, Klein, Varland, Tiedemann... wait, I double counted. I’m keeping Rogers as a wild card.

Ryan: Rogers is a wildcard. But I’d cut him. I’d keep Joseph Rodriguez instead. He’s got a good fastball. Rogers is too risky. So my cuts: Rogers, Straw, Keys, Pinango, Lukes, Martin Jr., Urias, Ross (if Valenzuela performs), and maybe one of the minor league arms like Spencer Miles.

Melissa: We disagree on Rogers, but I respect the logic. This is a talented team. 79 wins isn’t bad, but in the AL East, it’s not enough. They need to sharpen up these decisions. Before we go, I need to ask you something personal. We put out a fresh episode every single day, analyzing every team, every stat, every roster move. It takes a lot of coffee, a lot of late nights, and a lot of love for the game. And honestly, it’s your support that keeps this network running free for everyone. If you enjoy what we do, please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. It helps us keep bringing you this daily coverage without ads or paywalls. Just a little help to keep the beatline going.

Ryan: Thanks for listening. Whether you’re a die-hard Blue Jays fan or just curious about the roster battles, we hope you found value in today’s breakdown. Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and review us on your favorite podcast platform.

Melissa: Join us tomorrow as we break down the ALCS history and predict the World Series matchups. Go Jays! And thanks for being part of the Beatline community.