Melissa: Max Scherzer at forty-two years old, pitching on three days’ rest, striking out seven over seven-plus innings to secure his 225th career victory. That is not just a win; that is a historical statement in the final game of the season.
Ryan: It’s a legendary performance from one of the greatest arms in baseball history, but it happened against a Cincinnati Reds team that finished fifth in the NL Central with a 75-86 record. It was a beautiful finale for Scherzer, but it leaves us with a lot of questions about this Blue Jays roster as we head into the offseason.
Melissa: Welcome back to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we live and breathe sports. I’m Melissa, and I’m joined by my analyst Ryan. Today is our mailbag episode, so let’s dive straight into the fan questions. We have three big topics today: Scherzer’s historic finale, the infield depth chart chaos, and what this bullpen actually looks like moving forward.
Ryan: Right. As we’ve talked about in recent episodes, this team finished 79-83, second in the AL East, but the story wasn’t the standings—it was the volatility. From infield inconsistency to bullpen swings, there’s a lot to unpack. Let’s start with the elephant in the room: Max Scherzer.
Melissa: Okay, first question comes from Sarah in Buffalo. She asks: 'Was Max Scherzer’s performance in the season finale against the Reds just a fluke, or does it signal he wants to come back next year?' Specifically, she mentions his age—42—and the short rest.
Ryan: It’s definitely not a fluke, Sarah. Throwing 7-plus innings on three days of rest requires elite command and durability that most pitchers half his age don’t have. He struck out seven batters. That’s not luck; that’s dominance. But whether he returns? That’s a different conversation.
Melissa: So you’re saying the performance itself was legitimate, but the contract situation is separate?
Ryan: Exactly. At 42, even if he feels great, the Blue Jays are already looking at their rotation for 2027. We have Spencer Arrighetti, Shane Bieber, Dylan Cease, Jose Soriano, Jameson Taillon, CJ Van Eyk, and Trey Yesavage. They don’t need Scherzer to fill a spot. They might want him for leadership, but he’s not coming back as a starter.
Melissa: That makes sense. Next question, this one from @JaysFan88 in Toronto. He’s asking about the infield. We saw Brandon Valenzuela and Charles McAdoo homering in that finale, but who actually owns those middle-infield jobs next year? Ernie Clement, Andres Gimenez, Josh Smith, Luis Urias... it’s crowded.
Ryan: It is incredibly crowded. And honestly, it’s inefficient. You’ve got Gimenez at short, which is his natural position, and then three other guys—Clement, Smith, Urias—who can all play second base. Plus McAdoo, who played some second in that finale, and Kazuma Okamoto at third. This is a classic case of having too many bats for too few positions.
Melissa: So what’s the move? Do they trade someone? Or do they stick with the current mix?
Ryan: They need to make a move. Keeping all five of those guys isn’t viable. I’d expect the front office to look at trading one of the utility guys, maybe Urias or Clement, to clear a spot for someone who can provide more defensive stability or power. McAdoo showed some pop in that finale, but can he hold a starting job? Probably not yet.
Melissa: Makes sense. You need clarity in the infield. Next up, another listener question. Marcus in Chicago asks: 'With the new automated ball-strike system flipping 54% of challenged calls, how did that impact the Blue Jays hitters this year? Did they adjust better than other teams?'
Ryan: Great question, Marcus. The ABS challenge system was a huge shift. Catchers were far more successful than batters in challenging calls. For the Blue Jays, it meant plate discipline became even more critical. If you swing at a borderline pitch because you think it’s a strike, the robot doesn’t care about your feeling—it’s either a ball or a strike.
Melissa: Did Vladimir Guerrero Jr. struggle with it, or did he adapt well?
Ryan: Vladimir adapted well. His OBP remained strong because he has excellent plate discipline. He didn’t chase as much. The guys who struggled were the ones with higher launch angle goals but lower contact rates. They had to learn to trust the zone exactly as it was called, no exceptions.
Melissa: So discipline wins in the ABS era. Got it. That wraps up our first segment. Before we move on, let’s talk about the bullpen. Because that was another major storyline this season. Who are the key relievers heading into 2027?
Ryan: Paul Sewald is the clear closer. He’s reliable. Then you’ve got Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas, Braydon Fisher, Mason Fluharty, Devereaux Harrison, John Klein, Chase Lee, Brendon Little, Spencer Miles, Jose Rodriguez, Tyler Rogers, Ricky Tiedemann, and Louis Varland. That’s a massive group. Some of these guys are veterans, some are young arms trying to break through.
Melissa: That is a lot of bodies. How do they decide who stays?
Ryan: Performance in spring training and minor league options. But realistically, they’ll likely keep Sewald, maybe Tiedemann if he develops, and a few others. The rest will be DFAed or sent down. It’s going to be a brutal culling process.
Melissa: We’ll get into that more later, but first, a quick word from us. If you love this show, please consider supporting us. Your contributions help cover the daily research, editing, and keep the feed running for everyone. Just check the link in the episode description. Thank you for listening.
Ryan: Thanks, Melissa. Now, let’s dive into Segment Two: Roster Battles. First question from @BlueJayNation in Mississauga. They ask: 'Who wins the fifth starter job for 2027? Is it Jameson Taillon, or do the younger guys like CJ Van Eyk or Trey Yesavage get a shot?'
Melissa: Oh, we’ve been talking about this! In our last episode, we predicted Taillon would hold the spot. What do you think now, after seeing the whole season unfold?
Ryan: I still stand by it. Taillon has experience. He’s been there. He knows how to handle the pressure. Van Eyk and Yesavage are intriguing, but they need more time in the minors to refine their stuff. Taillon gives you stability, which is what this team needs right now.
Melissa: But what if Taillon struggles early in spring training? Do they pull the plug?
Ryan: If he struggles, yes. But I don’t see it happening. He’s a veteran. He’ll figure it out. The real question is whether the front office trusts him enough to give him the full-time nod without competition.
Melissa: Next question from David in Hamilton. He’s asking about the backup catcher spot. Alejandro Kirk is the starter, obviously. But who takes the backup role? Shawn Ross or Brandon Valenzuela?
Ryan: Valenzuela has more power. He homered in the finale. Ross is more of a defensive specialist. If the team wants offense off the bench, Valenzuela makes sense. If they want defense behind the plate, Ross is safer. Given the team’s offensive struggles, I’d lean toward Valenzuela.
Melissa: Power over defense? That’s an interesting take. Most teams prefer defense behind the plate.
Ryan: Usually, yes. But when you’re scoring 5 runs a game, every run counts. Valenzuela’s bat could be the difference-maker in tight games.
Melissa: Okay, one more for this segment. From @RaptorsRock in New York (wait, wrong team!) from @JaysLifer in London. He asks: 'What is the biggest area of need for the Blue Jays in the offseason? Pitching, hitting, or defense?'
Ryan: Pitching. Specifically, starting pitching depth. We have Scherzer leaving, and the rest of the rotation is unproven beyond Bieber and Cease. They need a reliable fourth starter, and maybe a fifth if Taillon doesn’t lock it down.
Melissa: Agreed. And the bullpen needs clearing out. But pitching is definitely the priority. Before we wrap this segment, let’s talk about the outfield. George Springer is listed as DH, but he’s an outfielder. Where does he fit?
Ryan: DH makes sense. He’s older, he needs rest. Brett Bateman, Nathan Lukes, Rudy Martin Jr., Yohendrick Pinango, Davis Schneider, Myles Straw—they’re all competing for spots. It’s a wide-open battle.
Melissa: Lots of names. Lots of uncertainty. That’s the Blue Jays in 2026. Let’s take a quick break. Stick with us, because next up, we’re doing a fun hypothetical and a lightning round of quick takes.
Melissa: Hey everyone, before we get to the fun stuff, a quick favor. Your support keeps our daily research deep, our editing crisp, and the feed running free for you. Grab a coffee via the link in the episode description. It helps us keep showing up for you every single day. Thanks!
Ryan: Alright, Segment Three: Fun Hypothetical and Lightning Round. First, a hypothetical from @JaysHypothetical in Calgary. 'If the Blue Jays could only keep three players from the current roster for 2027, who do they pick?'
Melissa: Ouch. That’s tough. I’m going with Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Max Scherzer (just kidding, he’s gone), and Paul Sewald. Wait, Scherzer isn’t coming back. So Vlad, Sewald, and... Andres Gimenez? Defense matters.
Ryan: I’d go with Vlad, Sewald, and Shane Bieber. You need your best hitter, your best closer, and your ace. Everything else is replaceable. Gimenez is good, but not irreplaceable. Bieber is.
Melissa: Okay, I can respect that. Ace, closer, and MVP candidate. Solid picks. Now, lightning round! Quick takes on these topics: 1) Will the Blue Jays make the playoffs in 2027? 2) Who is the most underrated player on the roster? 3) Should they sign a free agent starter?
Ryan: 1) Maybe, if the rotation stabilizes. 2) Brandon Valenzuela. He’s getting overlooked but has power. 3) Yes, absolutely. They need another arm.
Melissa: I disagree on number one. I think they miss the playoffs unless they make a splash. Number two, I’ll say Myles Straw. He’s fast, he’s smart, he plays great defense. Number three, yes, but only if it’s a mid-tier starter, not a superstar.
Ryan: Fair point on Straw. He’s a gem. And I agree on the mid-tier starter. They can’t afford another mistake.
Melissa: Last question from @LightningRound in Vancouver: 'What is one thing you loved about the 2026 season, and one thing you hated?'
Ryan: Loved: Scherzer’s 225th win. Hated: The bullpen volatility. It killed too many good games.
Melissa: Same here. Loved: The resilience of the team despite the losses. Hated: The lack of direction in the infield. Okay, that’s our time for the mailbag. Let’s recap.
Melissa: Today we covered Scherzer’s historic finale, the infield depth chart chaos, the ABS impact, and the bullpen culling process. If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, rate, and review us on your favorite platform. Share it with a friend who loves the Jays. Go Jays Go!