Mailbag: Scherzer’s 225th, Robot Umpires & The Bullpen Puzzle

Toronto Blue Jays · 2026-10-18 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Melissa: Max Scherzer at forty-two years old. On three days' rest. Striking out seven over seven-plus innings to secure his 225th career win in the season finale. That is not just a stat line; that is a legend refusing to retire gracefully.

Ryan: It really was a statement performance against Cincinnati. But let’s be clear about the context: the Blue Jays finished 79-83, second in the AL East standings after a wild stretch, but effectively fifth in the division hierarchy by the final day. It was a season of highs and massive lows.

Melissa: Welcome to today’s Beatline Podcast Network mailbag episode! I’m Melissa, joined by my analyst Ryan. Today we are digging into the fan questions. We’ve got the robot umpire debate, the future of the bullpen, and what Vladimir Guerrero Jr. needs to do next year. Stick with us.

Ryan: We have a lot to unpack. From Scherzer’s historic night to the confusing infield depth chart with Ernie Clement, Josh Smith, Luis Urias, and Charles McAdoo all vying for space. Let’s get to it.

Melissa: Before we dive into Segment One, I want to take thirty seconds to talk about this show. You love getting daily, deep-dive baseball analysis without interruption. And here is the truth: we don’t run ads. We don’t have a paywall. It is completely free because of listeners like you. If you enjoy this content, please chip in via the link in the episode description. Your support keeps this network running and ensures we can keep bringing you honest, ad-free coverage every single day.

Melissa: Sarah asks: 'Ryan, Max Scherzer struck out seven on short rest in the finale. Is this a sign he wants one more year, or is this purely a farewell tour moment?' What do you think?

Ryan: Well, Sarah, looking at the mechanics, Scherzer was sharp. He earned his 225th victory against the Reds, who finished 75-86. But physically? At forty-two, throwing on three days of rest is risky business. It feels less like a contract extension negotiation and more like a bow on the season.

Melissa: Right. He beat the Reds 5-1. Brandon Valenzuela and Charles McAdoo homered. But relying on Scherzer for high-leverage innings in April seems unlikely. Do you see him sticking around as a mentor?

Ryan: I do. Especially with Spencer Arrighetti and Trey Yesavage in the mix for the rotation spots. Scherzer provides a stabilizing presence. But let’s pivot to something that frustrated fans all year: the automated ball-strike system.

Melissa: Oh, the robot umpires. Marcus in Chicago sent us this: 'The ABS challenge system tracker shows catchers were far more successful than batters. How did this specifically hurt the Blue Jays’ lineup this year?' Great question, Marcus.

Ryan: It’s a tough pill to swallow. Robot umpires flipped fifty-four percent of challenged calls overall. For a team like Toronto, which relies on plate discipline and OBP, having the strike zone become a rigid rectangle rather than a human judgment call changes everything. Batters couldn't manipulate the zone as easily.

Melissa: And Alejandro Kirk, our primary catcher, had to adjust his framing strategy entirely. Did you see any specific trends with Davis Schneider or George Springer when they came up?

Ryan: Schneider struggled with launch angle consistency on borderline pitches that used to go in his favor. When the zone tightens, you have to be perfect. The Blue Jays didn't adapt fast enough to the new reality of the ABS challenge system tracker rankings.

Melissa: So, no more leaning on marginal calls. Next question comes from @BlueJayNation99: 'With Jameson Taillon projected as the fifth starter, how does that impact the bullpen usage for Brendan Cellucci and Paul Sewald?'

Ryan: If Taillon holds the role, as we predicted last week, the bullpen doesn't need to eat up extra innings due to early pulls. That helps preserve Cellucci and Sewald for late-game situations. But the volatility we saw all year—remember Chad Dallas and Mason Fluharty struggling?—that remains a concern.

Melissa: Exactly. The relief corps has too many moving parts. Devereaux Harrison and Ricky Tiedemann are young arms that need seasoning. Let’s move to Segment Two: Roster Battles.

Melissa: First up, Emily in Hamilton asks: 'Who wins the backup catcher job? Is it Shawn Ross or Brandon Valenzuela?' We talked about Valenzuela hitting a homer in the finale, but Ross has been there longer.

Ryan: Emily, this is tricky. Valenzuela showed power against Cincinnati, but Ross offers defensive stability behind the plate. Given our previous prediction that Valenzuela makes the opening day roster, I still stand by that. His bat plays better in a platoon scenario.

Melissa: Okay, let’s talk infield chaos. David in Mississauga asks: 'Ernie Clement, Josh Smith, Luis Urias, Charles McAdoo... four guys for two spots. Who gets cut?'

Ryan: David, it’s brutal. McAdoo had that big finish against the Reds, but Urias has experience. Smith is an asset trade-wise. I think Urias stays for versatility, and McAdoo goes. It’s a painful decision, but roster construction requires hard choices.

Melissa: Painful indeed. Next question from @JaysFanatic: 'What about the outfield? Brett Bateman, Nathan Lukes, Rudy Martin Jr., Yohendrick Pinango, Myles Straw. Who is locked in for 2027?'

Ryan: Straw is likely gone unless he accepts a utility role. Bateman has the upside, but Lukes and Martin are depth pieces. Pinango is interesting because he can play left. I see a crowded spring training where everyone fights for minutes.

Melissa: So, no clear everyday right fielder yet. Last question for this segment: 'Will Vladimir Guerrero Jr. improve his defensive metrics?' Simple question, huge impact.

Ryan: Vladimir is going to stay at first base. The Blue Jays aren't moving him. The focus will be on his swing path and reducing strikeouts. His defense is fine; it’s his contact rate that needs work against elite pitching.

Melissa: Agreed. Let’s wrap up Segment Two there. Before we hit the fun stuff, remember to subscribe and rate us wherever you listen. Now, Segment Three: Hypotheticals and Lightning Round.

Melissa: Here is a fun hypothetical from Kevin in London: 'If the Blue Jays could trade for ONE starting pitcher from the Reds roster to pair with Scherzer’s legacy, who would it be?' Wait, Scherzer is retiring. Who would they trade for?

Ryan: Kevin, if we’re talking hypotheticals, maybe they look at JJ Bleday’s offensive production and swap a prospect for a proven arm. But realistically, the Blue Jays need internal development. Spencer Arrighetti needs to step up.

Melissa: Love it. Alright, lightning round. Quick takes. First: Shane Bieber. Where is he?

Ryan: Injured reserve. He’s not on the active roster list for the finale. A major loss for the rotation long-term.

Melissa: Second: Dylan Cease. Good or bad for the Jays?

Ryan: He’s listed on the roster. High ceiling, high variance. Depends on command.

Melissa: Third: CJ Van Eyk. Role?

Ryan: Long relief or spot start. Solid depth piece.

Melissa: Fourth: Jose Soriano. Future?

Ryan: Veteran presence. Likely re-signed or traded for prospects.

Melissa: Final thought: The Blue Jays finished 79-83. Second in the AL East standings but fifth in actual competitiveness. Are they contenders next year?

Ryan: If Taillon locks the fifth spot and the bullpen stabilizes, yes. They are close. Just need health and consistent offense from the middle infield.

Melissa: That’s a wrap on our mailbag! We covered Scherzer’s 225th win, the ABS challenges, and the infield battles. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network.

Ryan: Go Jays Go. Subscribe, rate, review, and share the show with your friends.