Scherzer’s Finale & The Robot Umpire Revolution

Toronto Blue Jays · 2026-10-17 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Melissa: Seventy-nine wins. Eighty-three losses. A season that felt like it ended before it really began, yet somehow, we found a moment of pure magic on the very last day.

Ryan: And not just any magic. Max Scherzer, at forty-two years old, on three days’ rest, striking out seven batters to secure his two hundred and twenty-fifth career victory. That is not just a win; that is a statement.

Melissa: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Melissa, and this is your daily look at the Toronto Blue Jays. Ryan, you’re ready to dive in?

Ryan: I am. We’ve got a lot to unpack today, Melissa. First, we’re looking at how the AL East rivals are shaping up for next year while the Jays sit at second place in the standings but fifth in actual performance metrics.

Melissa: Then we’ll talk about that bullpen volatility we mentioned last week—is it fixed or just buried under Scherzer’s heroics? And finally, the big one: the new robot umpires are changing the game, and we need to see what that means for Brandon Valenzuela and the catchers.

Ryan: It’s a weird off-season already, folks. The regular season is over, but the storylines are just getting started.

Melissa: Let’s get right into it. Segment One: Division Rivals and League News.

Melissa: So, Ryan, the Blue Jays finished second in the AL East standings with a 79-83 record. But when you look at the headlines coming out of MLB today, it feels like everyone else is moving faster than us.

Ryan: They are. You look at the Reds, who beat us in the series finale rubber match earlier this week. They finished 75-86, fifth in the NL Central, but they’re young. JJ Bleday hit his twenty-fourth homer, Héctor Rodríguez added some power with that two-run triple. They’re building something.

Melissa: Right. And for us, the headline was obviously Scherzer. But beyond him, what do we see in the rest of the league that impacts our division outlook?

Ryan: The biggest shift isn’t player movement; it’s the rules. The automated ball-strike system is here. Fifty-four percent of challenged calls were overturned by robot umpires in their first full season. Catchers were far more successful than batters in using challenges.

Melissa: That is a massive change. For Alejandro Kirk and Brandon Valenzuela, that changes the entire dynamic of pitch-calling. No more arguing strikes to take the heat off the pitcher?

Ryan: Exactly. It removes the emotional component. If you challenge and lose, you might be penalized or just waste a challenge. The data shows catchers won more often. That suggests pitchers are commanding the zone better now, or hitters are being too aggressive.

Melissa: Does that help or hurt our guys? Because if hitters are swinging at bad pitches hoping to draw a strikeout from the pitcher, that’s trouble for Vladimir Guerrero Jr.

Ryan: It hurts plate discipline overall. If the zone is robotic, there’s no gray area. You either swing or you don’t. For Vlad, whose strength has always been controlling the zone, this is a adjustment period. He can’t use the 'bad call' excuse anymore.

Melissa: Meanwhile, across the league, ESPN is running those silver linings pieces for non-playoff teams. Are we hearing anything about roster certainty for us yet?

Ryan: Not really. We talked about this on Monday and Tuesday. The rotation battle for the fifth starter spot is still wide open. Jameson Taillon was our pick to hold it, but with Scherzer’s final start, the front office is seeing a lot of different arms.

Melissa: Spencer Arrighetti, Shane Bieber, Dylan Cease—they’re all names in the mix. But none of them had a defining moment like Scherzer did on Sunday.

Ryan: None of them did. And that’s the problem. Scherzer carried the team to that five-one win against Cincinnati. Brandon Valenzuela and Charles McAdoo homered. It was a perfect storm. But can anyone replicate that consistency?

Melissa: Probably not. That’s why we have to look at the supporting cast. Let’s move to Segment Two: How We Stack Up Against Those Rivals.

Melissa: Okay, Ryan. We know Scherzer was historic. But let’s talk about the rest of the roster. Last week, we predicted Jameson Taillon would secure the fifth starter role for 2027. Do you still stand by that?

Ryan: I do, but with caveats. Taillon provides stability. When Scherzer goes on short rest and throws seventy-plus innings with seven strikeouts, he’s giving you an ace-level performance. But the guys behind him? They’re volatile.

Melissa: Volatile is the word. Look at the bullpen. Paul Sewald, Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas. They’re all there. But did anyone stand out in that finale?

Ryan: The bullpen didn’t have to work hard because Scherzer gave us seven-plus innings. But that’s the issue. If your starters aren’t going deep, the bullpen gets hammered. That’s why the depth matters. Ricky Tiedemann, CJ Van Eyk, Louis Varland—these are arms that need to step up if Taillon or Scherzer falter.

Melissa: And what about the infield? We saw Andres Gimenez at shortstop, Ernie Clement at second, Kazuma Okamoto at third. It was inconsistent all year.

Ryan: It was. Josh Smith and Luis Urias also saw time. The defensive positioning issues we talked about earlier in the year didn’t fully resolve. You need better range in the outfield too. Myles Straw and Davis Schneider were solid, but Brett Bateman and Nathan Lukes need to produce more offensively.

Melissa: So, comparing us to the Reds or other non-playoff teams... are we better positioned for 2027?

Ryan: We have the core. Vlad, George Springer, Alejandro Kirk—that’s a top-tier nucleus. The question is whether the pitching staff can support them without relying on a forty-two-year-old man on three days' rest.

Melissa: Which brings us to the elephant in the room. Scherzer’s 225th win. It’s beautiful. But it’s also a warning sign. If he’s our best option late in the season, where does that leave us in October?

Ryan: It leaves us vulnerable. Because Scherzer can’t do that every time. The rotation needs another arm who can give you six innings of reliable baseball. That’s where Taillon comes in. If he holds that spot, we’re okay. If not, we’re scrambling.

Melissa: Agreed. Now, before we wrap up this segment, I want to check in with you. If these daily breakdowns are part of your morning routine or your commute, a small tip is exactly what keeps this show free and coming at you every single day. It’s not about selling ads; it’s about keeping the lights on for the fans who love the game as much as we do. If you can chip in, please visit the link in the episode description. Thank you for listening.

Ryan: Thanks for the support, Melissa. Let’s finish strong with Segment Three: What Outside Results Mean for Our Path.

Melissa: Right. So, the league is changing. Robot umpires. Young teams like Cincinnati building through Bleday and Rodríguez. Where does the Blue Jays path lead in 2027?

Ryan: The path is clear: develop the young arms. Spencer Miles, Mason Fluharty, Devereaux Harrison. These relievers need to find their roles. And in the starting rotation, someone besides Scherzer needs to emerge.

Melissa: And the catching situation? We mentioned Brandon Valenzuela earlier. Do you think he makes the Opening Day roster as the backup?

Ryan: I do. With the ABS system, his ability to frame pitches without arguing calls becomes even more valuable. Shawn Ross is there, but Valenzuela has shown he can handle the staff. I’d stick with my prediction from Tuesday: he’s on the roster.

Melissa: Okay, final thoughts. We said the Jays would finish between 75 and 82 wins next year. Given Scherzer’s farewell tour and the league shifts, do you adjust that number?

Ryan: No, I don’t. Seventy-five to eighty-two feels right. If Taillon stabilizes the back end of the rotation, and the bullpen doesn’t collapse, we’re a playoff team. But if the infield defense stays shaky, we’re back in the .500 mire.

Melissa: It’s going to be an interesting offseason. Max Scherzer hangs up his cleats after a legendary final start, but the real work starts now. Who steps up? Who falls away?

Ryan: That’s the question. And we’ll be here to answer it every day. Thanks for tuning in to the Beatline.

Melissa: To recap: Scherzer’s historic 225th win caps a tough 79-83 season, but the focus now shifts to stabilizing the rotation and adapting to the new robot umpire rules. If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen. Share it with a fellow Blue Jays fan!

Ryan: Go Jays Go.