Melissa: A forty-two-year-old Max Scherzer, pitching on three days' rest, striking out seven in a season finale that felt like an October playoff game. That is the kind of baseball we are talking about today.
Ryan: It was historic. 225 wins in his career. But while Scherzer closed the chapter with a bang, the rest of the league is dealing with some massive shifts in how the game is played and who is standing where.
Melissa: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Melissa, and I’m here with Ryan. We are your daily source for everything Toronto Blue Jays, but today we are zooming out. It’s an Around the League episode, so strap in.
Ryan: That’s right. We’ve got three big things coming up. First, we’re looking at the robot umpires flipping the script on challenged calls across MLB. Second, we’re breaking down how the Blue Jays stack up against their AL East rivals after finishing second.
Melissa: And third, we’re looking at those silver linings for non-playoff teams, specifically why this 79-83 season wasn’t a total loss. Let’s dive into the headlines.
Ryan: Let’s start with the most controversial story in baseball this year. The automated ball-strike system, or ABS. It’s been a wild ride.
Melissa: It really has. The headlines are saying robot umpires flipped 54% of challenged calls in their first full season. That is a staggering number.
Ryan: It is. And what’s interesting is the breakdown between batters and catchers. Catchers were far more successful in challenging than batters were. It changes the tactical side of the game completely.
Melissa: So now you have managers and coaches analyzing pitch frames differently because they know the robot doesn't lie. Did the Blue Jays benefit from this?
Ryan: I think it helped everyone equally, which is the point. But look at the Reds. They led the way in these challenges. And ironically, they were the team Scherzer beat in the finale.
Melissa: Speaking of Scherzer, can we just take a moment? A 42-year-old man, short rest, seven strikeouts, 225th win. This is legendary stuff.
Ryan: It is absolutely legendary. He didn't just pitch; he dominated. Seven-plus innings, five-one victory over Cincinnati. Brandon Valenzuela and Charles McAdoo homered, but Scherzer was the engine.
Melissa: It feels like a movie ending. But let’s pivot to the division. The Blue Jays finished second in the AL East at 79-83. How does that compare to the chaos around them?
Ryan: Well, if you look at the standings, the Reds were fifth in the NL Central at 75-86. So Toronto actually had a better record than Cincinnati. It’s funny how the standings work out when you aren't playing for October.
Melissa: Right. And remember, earlier in that series, the Reds beat the Blue Jays 5-1. JJ Bleday hit a solo homer, Hector Rodriguez added a two-run triple. So it was a split, but Scherzer gave us the final word.
Ryan: Exactly. And Héctor Rodríguez getting that two-run triple... that’s the kind of offensive spark this team needs more often. Lowder pitched six innings for his first win since August for Cincinnati, so it was a tight battle.
Melissa: Okay, so we have the robot umpires shaking up the rules, and Scherzer going out on top. Now let’s talk about the team itself. Segment Two: How the Blue Jays stack up.
Ryan: We talked about the rotation in previous episodes. Remember, we predicted Jameson Taillon would hold the fifth starter role. With Scherzer retiring or moving on, that spot is wide open.
Melissa: And we also discussed the bullpen volatility. Looking at the roster, you’ve got guys like Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas, Braydon Fisher... lots of arms.
Ryan: Lots of arms, yes. But consistency is key. Paul Sewald brings experience, but you need depth. Devereaux Harrison and Chase Lee are there too. The bullpen usage patterns will be critical next season.
Melissa: What about the offense? Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is always the anchor. But who else stepped up?
Ryan: Brandon Valenzuela and Charles McAdoo were huge in that finale. Valenzuela is still our backup catcher candidate, right? We mentioned him before.
Melissa: Yes! We predicted Valenzuela would make the Opening Day roster as the backup. If he keeps hitting like that, especially with power, he’s solidifying that spot.
Ryan: And Alejandro Kirk remains the primary catcher. But having Valenzuela behind the plate gives flexibility. Offensively, you want guys who can drive runs. McAdoo’s home run was timely.
Melissa: What about the infield? Andres Gimenez at short, Kazuma Okamoto at third. The defense has been a question mark all year.
Ryan: It has. Infield inconsistency was a theme. Josh Smith and Ernie Clement provide options at second, but defensive positioning and range matter. You need to stop giving up extra bases.
Melissa: So, the takeaway: Scherzer was the highlight, the bullpen needs structure, and the infield needs to find its footing. What do outside results mean for the Jays?
Ryan: If other teams are struggling with the robot umpires, maybe that levels the playing field. Everyone has to adapt. The Reds struggled, the Jays adapted.
Melissa: But wait... stick with us. Because there’s a bigger picture here about the future of the franchise.
Ryan: The silver linings. ESPN highlighted that non-playoff teams aren’t a total loss. For Toronto, 79-83 is better than many expected.
Melissa: We predicted the Jays would finish between 75 and 82 wins last time. Well, we missed by four wins! But hey, close enough.
Ryan: It’s a development year. Young guys like Ricky Tiedemann in the bullpen, Spencer Arrighetti in the rotation... they are gaining experience.
Melissa: And George Springer is still there. His presence in the DH spot matters. Leadership. Experience. That’s crucial for a rebuilding core.
Ryan: Absolutely. The OBP numbers might not have jumped off the page every day, but the clutch hits—like Scherzer’s strikeout-filled inning—show resilience.
Melissa: So, as we wrap up the regular season, what’s the one thing to watch for in spring training?
Ryan: Who starts on the mound for Game One. Is it Taillon? Or does someone new emerge? The competition will be fierce.
Melissa: And can the bullpen gel early? Because if you give up early runs, you need those middle-inning outs to hold firm.
Ryan: From Scherzer’s 225th win to the robot umpire revolution, it’s been a wild season. Thanks for listening to the Beatline.
Melissa: Before we go, we need your help. Your support allows us to keep doing the daily research, the editing, and keeping the feed running for free. Please chip in via the link in the episode description.
Ryan: It makes a huge difference. Help us keep bringing you the best Blue Jays coverage.
Melissa: Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Go Jays!