Melissa: A 42-year-old Max Scherzer. Seven strikeouts. Seven-plus innings. And his 225th career victory, all on three days’ rest in the season finale against Cincinnati.
Ryan: It was a legendary exit for a legendary arm, but let’s be real: that one win didn’t change the math. The Blue Jays finished 79-83, fifth in the AL East.
Melissa: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, home of the Toronto Blue Jays daily show! I’m Melissa, and this is Ryan. We are live on October 6th, 2026, right after the final out of the regular season.
Ryan: Hey everyone. It’s been a wild week for us here at the network. We’ve spent the last few days dissecting Scherzer’s retirement, the chaotic bullpen construction, and where Jameson Taillon fits into the rotation.
Melissa: Exactly. And today? Today we’re doing something different. We’re looking at the big picture. We’re ranking the team based on what actually happened this year. So here is your roadmap for today: First, we’ll break down exactly where the Blue Jays stand in the AL East and why that fifth-place finish hurts more than it looks. Second, we’ll analyze the biggest strengths—and the glaring question marks—in this roster. And third, we’ll give you a realistic outlook for 2027, including our official win projection.
Ryan: And before we get there, if you enjoyed these deep dives into the bullpen chaos and the catcher competition, make sure you’re subscribed. But first, let’s talk about that record.
Melissa: Okay, Ryan. Let’s start with the hard numbers. 79 wins. 83 losses. Fifth place in the American League East. When you look at that standing, what’s the immediate takeaway?
Ryan: The immediate takeaway is that talent exists, but consistency did not. Finishing fifth means you were behind four other teams who figured out how to win close games. You had the firepower—George Springer, Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Alejandro Kirk—but you couldn’t put it together over a 162-game marathon.
Melissa: Right. And looking at the division context, it’s frustrating because the gap between fourth and fifth isn’t always huge. But missing the playoffs entirely... that stings.
Ryan: It does. And part of it was the rotation. We talked about Scherzer’s finale—he struck out seven, won the game, looked dominant. But relying on a 42-year-old to carry the load in September is a symptom of a deeper issue. Who else started? Spencer Arrighetti, Shane Bieber, Dylan Cease, Jose Soriano, CJ Van Eyk, Trey Yesavage. That’s six starters plus Scherzer. Where was the stability?
Melissa: And we haven’t even mentioned Jameson Taillon yet, which brings us back to yesterday’s episode. You predicted he’d take the fifth spot next year.
Ryan: I still stand by that. If Scherzer retires, as seems likely after that emotional finale, Taillon has to step up. He’s the veteran presence. But in 2026, without him anchoring the back end, the rotation felt disjointed. You had good starts, but they were scattered.
Melissa: Let’s talk about the offense then. Because 79 wins suggests you scored enough runs to win some games, just not enough to win *enough* games. Was the lineup the problem?
Ryan: No, the lineup was fine. Vlad Jr. was solid. Davis Schneider was dangerous. Brett Bateman and Nathan Lukes provided power from the outfield corners. The issue was the middle infield depth. Ernie Clement, Andres Gimenez, Charles McAdoo, Josh Smith, Luis Urias... it was crowded, but it lacked a clear identity. Who was the everyday second baseman? Who was the primary shortstop? That ambiguity hurt the flow of the offense.
Melissa: And then there’s the catching situation. Brandon Valenzuela made the opening day roster last time we discussed it. Did he prove himself over the final series against the Reds?
Ryan: He certainly earned his keep. In that finale, he went yard. He showed he can hit. But defensively, the competition between him, Shawn Ross, and Alejandro Kirk remains open. Kirk is the starter, obviously, but Valenzuela proved he’s not just a placeholder. He’s a legitimate backup option with bat speed.
Melissa: So, putting it all together: 79-83, fifth in the AL East. Is that a failing season or a building season?
Ryan: It’s a building season with too many cracks. You have the core pieces—Vlad, Kirk, Springer, Scherzer (for now)—but the supporting cast is fragmented. You can’t build a playoff contender on fragments.
Melissa: That leads perfectly into our next segment. What were the actual strengths of this team, and where were the biggest question marks? Stick around, because the answer might surprise you.
Melissa: Welcome back. Segment Two: Strengths and Question Marks. Ryan, let’s start positive. What did the Blue Jays do well in 2026?
Ryan: Pitching depth. Seriously. Beyond Scherzer, you had guys like Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas, Braydon Fisher, Mason Fluharty, Devereaux Harrison, John Klein, Chase Lee, Brendon Little, Spencer Miles, Jose Rodriguez, Tyler Rogers, Paul Sewald, Ricky Tiedemann, and Louis Varland. That is an absurd number of arms.
Melissa: That’s a lot of names! But isn’t that also the problem? A crowded bullpen often means no one gets comfortable.
Ryan: Exactly. It’s a double-edged sword. On one hand, when someone got hurt or struggled, you had bodies. On the other hand, managers couldn’t figure out who their best relievers were. Who was the closer? Who was the setup man? It was chaotic.
Melissa: Let’s talk about the batting average on balls in play. With players like Myles Straw in center field and Andres Gimenez at short, was the defense a strength?
Ryan: Defensively, yes. Straw is an elite defender. Gimenez is fast and agile. Kazuma Okamoto at third base brought some pop and decent range. The infield wasn’t perfect, but it wasn’t a liability. The outfield was solid too, with Yohendrick Pinango in left and Sean Keys in right providing versatility.
Melissa: But the biggest question mark has to be the rotation beyond Scherzer. We know Spencer Arrighetti and Shane Bieber are talented. What about Dylan Cease? Or Jose Soriano?
Ryan: Cease had moments of brilliance, but inconsistency was his hallmark. Soriano was unpredictable. And Van Eyk and Yesavage were young arms trying to find their footing. The question mark isn’t just who starts; it’s who stays healthy and effective for 150 innings.
Melissa: And offensively, who steps up if Vlad Jr. has an off month? Or if George Springer’s age catches up to him?
Ryan: That’s the scary part. The lineup relies heavily on its stars. When they rest, the middle of the order—Ernie Clement, Luis Urias, Charles McAdoo—doesn’t provide consistent power. They’re contact hitters, but they don’t drive the ball consistently enough to compensate for slumps from the top.
Melissa: So, strengths: Pitching depth, defensive athleticism. Weaknesses: Bullpen clarity, offensive consistency, and the future of the starting rotation.
Ryan: Spot on. And that brings us to the most important part of the day: What does 2027 look like?
Melissa: Before we get to the outlook, I want to check in with you. If today’s breakdown helped you understand the Blue Jays better, consider supporting the show. It keeps us free and daily. Just use the link in the episode description.
Ryan: Thanks for listening. Here’s our outlook: 2027 will be a transition year. Scherzer is gone. Taillon takes the fifth spot. The bullpen needs sorting. Expect 75-80 wins.
Melissa: We’re projecting 78 wins. Same as last year, but hopefully with more playoff contention. Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Go Jays!