Melissa: Max Scherzer just punched his ticket to retirement with a vintage seven-strikeout performance in the finale, but if you think the Toronto Blue Jays are done talking about their future, think again. We have three massive position battles that will define this team for 2027.
Ryan: And honestly, Melissa, looking at the depth chart right now, it’s less about who gets the job and more about who survives the spring training competition. The infield is crowded, the backstop is up for grabs, and the bullpen has more arms than we know what to do with.
Melissa: That is exactly why we’re here. I’m Melissa, this is Ryan, and welcome to another episode of the Beatline Podcast Network. We’ve got your daily dose of Blue Jays baseball, breaking down the roster moves, the stats, and the stories that matter.
Ryan: Right. And since we’re finishing out the regular season at 79-83, fifth in the AL East, there’s no pressure to win today. There’s only pressure to figure out who belongs on the field next April.
Melissa: So, here is your roadmap for today. First, we’re tackling the biggest positional battle in Toronto: the backup catcher spot behind Alejandro Kirk. Then, we’ll look at the chaotic middle infield competition. And finally, we’re making our roster cut predictions—who’s staying, who’s going, and who needs to wake up.
Ryan: It’s a fun puzzle. Scherzer’s 225th win was a historic moment, sure, but the real story is how this club constructs its bench and bullpen for next year. Let’s get into it.
Melissa: Okay, let’s start with the battery. Alejandro Kirk is an All-Star caliber catcher, so he’s not moving. But who is catching the other pitchers? We’ve got Brandon Valenzuela, Shawn Ross, and... wait, did anyone else catch last year?
Ryan: It’s essentially a two-horse race between Valenzuela and Ross. Valenzuela had a solid showing in the finale, hitting a home run against the Reds. But defensively, Ross brings a different vibe. He’s been with the organization longer.
Melissa: But Valenzuela is young. He hit that homer off the Reds, showed some pop. Isn’t that what they want from a backup? Someone who can contribute off the bench?
Ryan: Offensively, yes. But catchers are judged on framing and game-calling. Ross has more experience managing a pitching staff. If you look at the ABS challenge system data from this season, catchers were far more successful than batters. That implies the better framers are winning those close calls.
Melissa: So you’re saying Ross might be the safer bet for keeping the rotation tight?
Ryan: I am. Valenzuela has upside, but Ross has polish. If the Jays want stability in the ninth inning, Ross makes sense. If they want to develop a long-term successor to Kirk, Valenzuela is the play. Given they’re 79-83, maybe they take the risk on youth.
Melissa: That’s a tough call. I like Valenzuela’s energy. He brought the house in the finale. But I see your point about Ross’s defensive pedigree. It feels like a coin flip right now.
Ryan: It is. Unless they bring in an external veteran, it’s internal. And I’d lean slightly toward Valenzuela getting the nod simply because the offense needs all the help it can get behind the plate.
Melissa: Alright, we’ll table that. Let’s move to the dirt. The infield is a mess of possibilities. You’ve got Vladimir Guerrero Jr. at first, obviously. Andres Gimenez at short. But second base? Third base? It’s a zoo.
Ryan: Exactly. You have Ernie Clement, Charles McAdoo, Josh Smith, and Luis Urias all competing for time at second. And then Kazuma Okamoto at third. It’s too many bodies for four spots.
Melissa: Josh Smith has been the darling of the fanbase lately. His defense is elite. But is he a full-time everyday player, or does he platoon?
Ryan: He’s definitely an everyday talent if he keeps improving his plate discipline. But look at the platoon splits. Some of these guys struggle against left-handed pitching. If Smith faces a heavy lefty, you might see McAdoo or Clement in there.
Melissa: And Okamoto at third? He’s been quiet. Do you see him holding that job, or is he vulnerable?
Ryan: Okamoto is risky. He’s a strikeout artist. In a league where launch angle matters so much, if he isn’t driving the ball, he’s a liability. I think he’s on the bubble unless he shows consistent power in spring training.
Melissa: So, second base is open competition, third is shaky. This is going to be a busy February.
Ryan: Very busy. And don’t forget George Springer is listed as DH now. That opens up another slot. But he’s aging, and his health is always a question mark.
Melissa: Right. So if Springer sits, who takes the hits? Davis Schneider? Yohendrick Pinango? The outfield is also part of this equation.
Ryan: Myles Straw in center field is a given. Brett Bateman and Nathan Lukes are fighting for corner spots. It’s a lot of versatility required. The Jays need guys who can play multiple positions.
Melissa: Okay, I feel like we could talk infield forever. Let’s shift gears to the most critical battle of them all: the rotation. Specifically, that fifth starter spot.
Ryan: Ah, the holy grail of spring training. With Max Scherzer likely retiring after that final win, the door is wide open. You’ve got Spencer Arrighetti, Shane Bieber, Dylan Cease, Jose Soriano, Jameson Taillon, CJ Van Eyk, and Trey Yesavage.
Melissa: Seven starters for five spots. That’s insane. And we talked about this yesterday—Taillon being the favorite for the fifth spot. Do you still stand by that?
Ryan: I do. Taillon is a workhorse. He eats innings. When you’re building around young arms like Arrighetti or Bieber, you need someone reliable in the back of the rotation. Taillon provides that floor.
Melissa: But what about Cesar Hernandez? Wait, no, he’s not on the roster. What about Jose Soriano? He’s got stuff. Why not him?
Ryan: Soriano has higher upside, but also higher variance. Taillon is the safe bet. If the Jays want to avoid a playoff-like intensity in March, they go with Taillon. If they want to gamble on a breakout, it’s Soriano or even Van Eyk.
Melissa: I think Taillon is the smart move. Consistency wins championships. Or at least, it prevents disasters.
Ryan: Agreed. Unless something wild happens, Taillon starts on Opening Day. Or at least, he’s the incumbent until proven otherwise.
Melissa: Alright, that wraps up our first major battle. We’ve got catcher, infield, and rotation covered. Next, let’s look at the bullpen. Because folks, the bullpen list is terrifyingly deep.
Melissa: We’re talking Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas, Braydon Fisher, Mason Fluharty, Devereaux Harrison, John Klein, Chase Lee, Brendon Little, Spencer Miles, Jose Rodriguez, Tyler Rogers, Paul Sewald, Ricky Tiedemann, and Louis Varland. That is fourteen relievers!
Ryan: Fourteen. For a team that finished 79-83. This is a luxury problem, but it’s also a logistical nightmare. How do you fit all these arms into a 40-man roster and a active lineup?
Melissa: Paul Sewald is the clear closer. He’s the ace. But who is the setup man? Who is the eighth-inning guy? It’s a free-for-all.
Ryan: Sewald is locked in. After that, it’s about velocity and swing-and-miss ability. Ricky Tiedemann has electric stuff. If he stays healthy, he’s a high-leverage arm. But he’s been injury-prone.
Melissa: What about Brendon Little? He’s been solid. Is he a lock for the setup role?
Ryan: Little is versatile. He can go multiple innings. That’s valuable. But in modern baseball, they want specialized matchups. Little might end up as a long-relief specialist or a spot starter.
Melissa: And what about the veterans? Tyler Rogers, John Klein. Are they journeyman roles?
Ryan: They’re probably 40-man stash guys. They provide experience. If a young arm gets hurt, Rogers can step in. But I don’t see them locking down a permanent role unless they dominate camp.
Melissa: This is crazy. Fourteen arms. I hope the front office knows what they’re doing. It seems like overkill.
Ryan: It is overkill. But it reflects the depth of the farm system. The Jays have developed a lot of pitching. The challenge now is managing careers. Who gets to pitch regularly? Who gets sent to Buffalo?
Melissa: Buffalo must be the most competitive place in baseball right now. Everyone wants to make the Jays.
Ryan: Absolutely. And remember, robot umpires are changing the game. With the ABS challenge system, relievers who rely on edge pitches might struggle more. They need pure strikes.
Melissa: Good point. So precision is key. Okay, let’s move to our final segment. Roster cuts. Who is trending up, who is trending down, and who is getting the axe?
Melissa: Let’s start with the trending up list. Brandon Valenzuela. He hit that homer. He looked confident. Do you see him sticking?
Ryan: I do. He’s young, he has power, and he’s familiar with the system. He’s trending up. I expect him to make the team as the backup catcher.
Melissa: And who is trending down? I’m thinking Kazuma Okamoto. His offensive numbers have been mediocre at best.
Ryan: Definitely. Okamoto is trending down. If he doesn’t show power in spring training, he’s out. He’s too one-dimensional. The Jays need more balance.
Melissa: What about the outfield? Nathan Lukes and Rudy Martin Jr. Are they in danger?
Ryan: Lukes and Martin are on the bubble. Myles Straw is safe in center. Brett Bateman has shown flashes. Lukes and Martin might be non-roster invitees who need to impress to stay.
Melissa: So, my prediction: Valenzuela makes the team, Okamoto is released or traded, and Taillon is the fifth starter. What’s yours?
Ryan: Same on Valenzuela and Taillon. On Okamoto, I think they try to trade him. If no takers, he’s out. It’s a harsh business.
Melissa: Before we go, I want to say something quick. If these daily breakdowns are part of your morning routine or commute, a small tip is what keeps them coming. Please check the link in the episode description to support us.
Melissa: Thank you so much. Alright, Ryan, let’s wrap this up. We talked about the catcher battle, the infield chaos, the rotation depth, and the bullpen overload.
Ryan: And we predicted Taillon holds the fifth spot, Valenzuela catches the bus, and Okamoto is on the block.
Melissa: If you agree, hit subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Share this with a fellow Blue Jays fan. Go Jays!