Mailbag: Scherzer's 225th Win, Bullpen Chaos & The Fifth Starter Race

Toronto Blue Jays · 2026-10-04 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Melissa: Max Scherzer just punched out seven over seven-plus innings on three days' rest to secure his 225th career victory. That is a historic finale against the Reds. But here’s the question haunting every Blue Jays fan right now: does he come back next year, or do we start building around Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and the kids immediately?

Ryan: It’s a tough pill to swallow if he retires. We’ve talked about this rotation all week. You have Spencer Arrighetti, Shane Bieber, Dylan Cease, Jose Soriano, Jameson Taillon, CJ Van Eyk, Trey Yesavage... that is a lot of arms competing for very little room. And then you look at the bullpen, which looks like a revolving door.

Melissa: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Melissa, and I’m with Ryan. Today is our mailbag episode. We are diving into your questions about the 79-83 season, the fifth-place finish in the AL East, and what comes next for Toronto.

Ryan: We’re going to tackle the biggest storylines from the final weekend. Specifically, that Scherzer performance, the infield depth chart with guys like Ernie Clement and Andres Gimenez, and whether Brandon Valenzuela can stick as the primary catcher alongside Alejandro Kirk.

Melissa: Before we get to the questions, a quick favor. If today’s breakdown helped make sense of that wild bullpen usage or clarified where the team stands heading into winter meetings, please consider supporting us. It keeps this show free and daily for everyone who loves baseball. Just tap the link in the episode description. Now, let’s get to the mailbag.

Melissa: First question comes from Sarah in Hamilton. She asks: 'With Max Scherzer striking out seven in the finale and hitting 225 wins, is there any realistic chance he returns for 2027? Or should we be preparing for a full rebuild?'

Ryan: Sarah, great question. Let’s look at the facts. He’s 42 years old. He threw 75 pitches in that finale on short rest. Statistically, that is an outlier performance. While it was beautiful, relying on that kind of workload in April or May is a gamble no general manager wants to take unless they’re desperate.

Melissa: Right. And remember, we discussed yesterday how the team finished 79-83. If they are looking to improve, they need youth. They have Spencer Arrighetti and Shane Bieber under control. Bringing back Scherzer might actually block the development of those younger arms.

Ryan: Exactly. It’s about opportunity cost. If Scherzer takes a spot in the rotation, who gets the fifth starter job? We predicted Jameson Taillon would hold that role last week, but now you have CJ Van Eyk, Trey Yesavage, and Jose Soriano pushing hard. Scherzer staying makes that competition moot, which isn’t good for morale.

Melissa: Ooh, that’s a sharp point. So if Scherzer sits out, Taillon is the favorite? What about Dylan Cease? He’s coming off a solid year too.

Ryan: Cease is a frontline arm. He’s not the fifth starter. He’s more likely a two or three. So it really comes down to Taillon versus the lefty options or Van Eyk. But honestly, Sarah, I think Scherzer is retiring. The body doesn’t lie, especially after that short-rest effort.

Melissa: Alright, moving on. Marcus in Toronto asks: 'The bullpen was a disaster all year. With guys like Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas, and Paul Sewald on the roster, how do we fix the late-inning chaos? Do we trade for help or promote from within?'

Ryan: Marcus, this is the glaring weakness. You had nine relievers listed on the roster: Cellucci, Dallas, Fisher, Fluharty, Harrison, Klein, Lee, Little, Miles, Rodriguez, Rogers, Sewald, Tiedemann, Varland. That is too many bodies. It creates confusion in the dugout.

Melissa: It really does. And when you look at the stats from the season, the ERA in the ninth inning was painful. Paul Sewald has experience, but he’s aging. Is he still the guy?

Ryan: Sewald is a bridge. He’s not a closer yet. I think the front office needs to clear out some of these middle relievers. Guys like Mason Fluharty and Devereaux Harrison didn’t see much action. If you trim the roster to eight reliable arms, you can focus on high-leverage situations rather than just throwing anyone available at the plate.

Melissa: So, cut the depth, keep the arms that work. Makes sense. Next up, @JaysFan99 on X asks: 'Vladimir Guerrero Jr. had another great year, but what about the infield defense? Andres Gimenez and Ernie Clement at second base—should we be worried about their range?'

Ryan: @JaysFan99, this is a valid concern. Gimenez is a defensive wizard at short, but moving him to second or keeping him there requires a specific defensive alignment. Clement is more of a contact hitter. If the league is pulling up the infield because of Vlad’s power, you need range to cover the gaps.

Melissa: And don’t forget Kazuma Okamoto at third. He’s not known for his glove either. The whole infield feels heavy offensively, which is fine if the bats are producing, but defensively, it leaves you exposed on balls hit to the left side.

Ryan: Agreed. I think Josh Smith could provide some versatility there. He’s young, he’s fast. If the team is serious about improving defense, they need to evaluate if Clement or Okamoto are worth the defensive liabilities. Sometimes you just have to accept the offensive upside and play smart positioning.

Melissa: Let’s shift gears to roster battles. Emily in Mississauga writes: 'Brandon Valenzuela hit a home run in the finale. Does he have a real shot to beat out Shawn Ross for the backup catcher job behind Alejandro Kirk?'

Ryan: Emily, that homer was sweet. But catching is about more than power. You have Alejandro Kirk, who is arguably the best defensive catcher in the game. The backup needs to handle pitchers and have a low OBP threat level.

Melissa: Right. Kirk is the anchor. Valenzuela showed flashes, but Shawn Ross has been with the organization longer. Who do you think wins the job, Ryan?

Ryan: I think Ross holds the edge due to familiarity with the pitching staff. Valenzuela is intriguing because he can swing the bat, but if he doesn’t establish himself in spring training, he might end up in the minors. The Jays have limited roster spots, so they need a catcher who can play every day without struggling defensively.

Melissa: Okay, so Ross is the incumbent. What about the outfield? Davis Schneider and Brett Bateman both played significant minutes. Who has the better future in Toronto?

Ryan: Schneider has shown he can hit for average and get on base. Bateman is a power tool but struggles with strikeouts. In today’s game, launch angle matters, but so does plate discipline. I lean towards Schneider having a longer tenure here unless Bateman figures out his strikeout rate.

Melissa: That’s a tough call. Power vs. Contact. David in Buffalo asks: 'George Springer and Sean Keys both DHed this year. With Springer’s age and Keys’ youth, who starts more games next season?'

Ryan: David, this is tricky. Springer brings leadership and clutch hitting. Keys is a platoon option. If the team is rebuilding, they might go with Keys to save Springer’s legs for occasional appearances. But if they want to contend, Springer’s presence in the lineup is valuable.

Melissa: I think it depends on health. If Springer stays healthy, he starts most days. But if he misses time, Keys steps up. It’s a nice problem to have. Next question: 'What is the plan for Luis Urias? He’s been useful as a utility man.'

Ryan: Urias is a veteran presence. He can play multiple positions. If the team adds a younger prospect, Urias might be traded for a return. Otherwise, he’s a solid bench piece. His contract situation will dictate his future more than his performance.

Melissa: Alright, let’s have some fun. Hypothetical time. If the Blue Jays were to trade one of their starting pitchers today to acquire a proven closer, who goes and who comes back?

Ryan: Who goes? Not Bieber. Not Cease. Maybe Shane Bieber? No, wait, he’s young. Actually, I’d move Jose Soriano. He’s got stuff, but he’s not a ace. Trading him for a high-leverage arm like a Kenley Jansen-type would stabilize that bullpen instantly.

Melissa: Wow, trading Soriano? That’s bold. I thought you said he was part of the core? But I get it—the bullpen needs help. Okay, lightning round. Quick takes. First: Did Max Scherzer deserve the 225th win celebration?

Ryan: Absolutely. It was a masterclass. Seven strikeouts, seven-plus innings, on short rest. That is Hall of Fame caliber performance at age 42.

Melissa: Second: Is the AL East still the toughest division in baseball?

Ryan: Yes. Even with Toronto at 79-83, the other teams are strong. The Yankees, the Red Sox, the Rays—they all have deep rosters. It’s a grind every night.

Melissa: Third: Who is the most underrated player on the Blue Jays roster?

Ryan: Myles Straw. He provides speed and defense in center field. People forget how valuable that is when you have power hitters like Vlad and Springer.

Melissa: Fourth: Will the Blue Jays make the playoffs in 2027?

Ryan: If they fix the bullpen and get healthy, yes. But it won’t be easy. They need to win between 78 and 82 games to compete, which means consistency.

Melissa: There you have it. From Scherzer’s historic finale to the bullpen debates, we covered it all. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network.

Ryan: Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and review. Your support helps us bring you daily content. See you next time.

Melissa: Go Jays Go!