Melissa: Max Scherzer. Forty-two years old. Three days of rest. Seven strikeouts. A career-high twenty-fifth win in his illustrious career. It was a finale for the ages, and it might be the last time we see him on a mound at all.
Ryan: It really is hard to process. The Blue Jays closed out their 79-83 season with a 5-1 victory over the Reds, but the story wasn't just the win. It was the man who delivered it. Brandon Valenzuela and Charles McAdoo added power, but this was Max’s stage.
Melissa: Welcome back to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we live for the game. I’m Melissa, and I’m joined by Ryan. We are your daily source for everything Toronto Blue Jays. Today is a special one—it’s our mailbag episode. We’re answering your questions about the future, the roster battles, and what comes next for this team.
Ryan: That’s right. Before we dive into the inbox, I want to give a quick shout-out to our supporters. You know, putting out a fresh, detailed show every single day takes a lot of work—research, analysis, editing. It’s a grind. But having a handful of you chip in makes that possible, keeping this show free and daily for everyone. If you haven’t already, check out the link in the episode description. It helps us keep the lights on.
Melissa: Thank you so much. We appreciate every bit of support. So, let’s get into it. We have three big topics today. First, we’re looking at the Max Scherzer question—is he done? Second, we’re tackling the crowded bullpen and those roster battles we talked about last week. And third, we’ve got a fun hypothetical about the 2027 lineup. Let’s start with the elephant in the room.
Melissa: First up, we have a question from Sarah in Buffalo. She writes: 'I saw Max Scherzer strike out seven guys on short rest. He looks like he still has it. Is there any chance he comes back next year, or should we start preparing for life without him?' Ryan, you were here for the game.
Ryan: He looked dominant, Sarah. But let’s be real about the context. This was a garbage-time finale against the Reds. He threw 108 pitches. For a forty-two-year-old arm, throwing seven-plus innings on three days of rest is heroic, but it’s also a massive red flag for durability. I don’t think he’s coming back. Not unless something changes dramatically.
Melissa: Right. And remember, we predicted yesterday that Jameson Taillon would likely hold the fifth starter role next season. If Max is gone, that spot is wide open. Who do you see stepping up?
Ryan: We mentioned Spencer Arrighetti and Shane Bieber earlier in the year, but looking at the current roster depth, it’s tricky. You’ve got CJ Van Eyk, Trey Yesavage, Jose Soriano. They’re all young arms. But honestly, the front office might need to look outside. With the bullpen so crowded, maybe they convert someone or bring in a veteran minimum contract guy to mentor the kids.
Melissa: Okay, moving on. Here’s a question from @JaysFan247. 'With Vladimir Guerrero Jr. being the anchor, how concerned should we be about the rest of the infield? Andres Gimenez had ups and downs, and Ernie Clement seems to be sliding around positions constantly.'