Scherzer's 225th Win & The AL East Aftermath

Toronto Blue Jays · 2026-10-02 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Melissa: A forty-two-year-old Max Scherzer, pitching on three days of rest, striking out seven batters to secure his 225th career victory. That is not just a stat line; that is a historical moment in Toronto.

Ryan: It’s the kind of performance that makes you forget the 79-83 record for a second. But we can’t ignore where the team sits, because the AL East landscape has shifted, and it affects everyone.

Melissa: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Melissa, and this is your daily look at the Toronto Blue Jays. I’m joined by Ryan, who’s ready to break down the final day of the 2026 season.

Ryan: Thanks, Melissa. We’ve got a lot to cover. From Scherzer’s farewell tour vibes to how the division rivals finished, and what this means for the offseason.

Melissa: Here is what we are diving into today: First, we’ll look at the division rivals and what their finishes mean for Toronto’s standing. Second, we’ll analyze how the Blue Jays stack up against those teams after a tough year. And third, we’ll talk about the outside results and what they signal for the path ahead in 2027.

Ryan: We’re also going to touch on the roster decisions, especially with Scherzer waiting to decide on his 20th season. Let’s get into it.

Melissa: Let’s start with the division. The Blue Jays finished fifth in the AL East at 79-83. It’s a tough pill to swallow, but let’s look at the context. How did the other teams in the East finish, and does that change the perception of this group?

Ryan: Well, finishing fifth in the AL East is never great, but the key here is who was above them. The competition was fierce. When you look at the headline about Silver linings for MLB's non-playoff teams, it’s clear that many teams missed the cut. For Toronto, the gap between them and the playoff teams was significant, but the internal storylines were more compelling.

Melissa: Right. And one of those storylines was the final series against the Reds. Cincinnati finished fifth in the NL Central at 75-86. So, Toronto actually had a better record than their direct opponent in the finale. Does that matter in the grand scheme of things?

Ryan: In terms of seeding or wild card chances? No. But in terms of momentum and morale? Absolutely. Winning the season finale 5-1, especially with the way Scherzer went, sends a message. JJ Bleday had hit a solo homer earlier in the series, and Hector Rodriguez added a two-run triple in the previous game, so the offense was trying to find its rhythm.

Melissa: And they found it Sunday. Brandon Valenzuela and Charles McAdoo homered in that win. It’s a nice capstone to a difficult year. But looking at the AL East specifically, how does Toronto compare to the top teams now that the dust has settled?

Ryan: They trail significantly in wins. The disparity in the East was stark. While Toronto was fighting for pride, the leaders were solidifying their playoff positions. This fifth-place finish highlights the need for improvement in both run prevention and offensive consistency throughout the season.

Melissa: It really underscores the challenge. Now, let’s pivot to the bigger picture. The headlines mentioned the ABS challenge system tracker. Where did the Blue Jays rank in that? It’s a newer metric, but it shows how much the team relied on umpire challenges versus making smart plays.

Ryan: The ABS challenge system ranks batters, catchers, teams, and umpires. For a team like Toronto, which often finds itself in close games, the efficiency of these challenges matters. If they were ranking lower, it might suggest a lack of plate discipline or poor situational hitting. But honestly, the focus right now is on the human element—the players themselves.

Melissa: That human element is Max Scherzer. He waited until Saturday to say he’d decide on his 20th season in the offseason. Now, after striking out seven over seven-plus innings on short rest, do you think that decision is getting easier for him?

Ryan: He’s 42. Pitching on three days of rest is an extraordinary feat. Earning his 225th win in such a manner suggests he still feels competitive. However, the physical toll is real. The fact that he’s waiting until the offseason implies he needs time to assess his body. This wasn’t just a regular outing; it was a statement performance.

Melissa: It was historic. And it leaves a void. With Scherzer potentially retiring, the rotation looks very different heading into 2027. We’ve talked about Jameson Taillon holding the fifth starter role before. Who else steps up?

Ryan: Spencer Arrighetti, Shane Bieber, Dylan Cease, Jose Soriano, CJ Van Eyk, and Trey Yesavage are all names in the mix. But without Scherzer, the depth chart changes drastically. The bullpen arms like Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas, and Paul Sewald will see more high-leverage work if the starters don’t go deep enough.

Melissa: Exactly. And that brings us to our support appeal. We rely on your help to keep this daily coverage free. A small contribution helps fund the research, editing, and ensures the feed keeps running every single day. Please check the link in the episode description to chip in. It truly makes a difference.

Ryan: Thanks for listening. Now, let’s dive deeper into how the Blue Jays stack up against those rivals. We know they finished 79-83, but when you look at the specific matchups, where did they lose ground?

Melissa: I think the bullpen usage was a big factor. In the series against Cincinnati, they lost 5-1 on Saturday before winning 5-1 on Sunday. That swing shows inconsistency. Héctor Rodríguez’s two-run triple highlighted the Reds' power, while Toronto’s offense struggled to string hits together until the finale.

Ryan: It’s about defensive positioning and launch angle. When you give up triples and home runs, it often points to a lack of pitch sequencing. The Reds beat them with timely power. Bleday’s solo shot and Rodriguez’s triple were clutch moments. Toronto’s defense couldn’t get back on top of those balls.

Melissa: And offensively, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. was a constant presence. He’s the anchor. But beyond him, who stepped up? Charles McAdoo and Brandon Valenzuela homered in the finale. Are they guys to build around, or were they just spark plugs for one game?

Ryan: McAdoo and Valenzuela provided necessary production. But we have to look at the lineup as a whole. Kazuma Okamoto at third base, Andres Gimenez at shortstop—these are young cores. Last week, we predicted Gimenez could develop into a top-five shortstop if he adds more power. This series showed flashes, but consistency is key.

Melissa: Right. And George Springer? We mentioned his reduced defensive duties last time to preserve availability. How did he perform in the finale? DH duty allowed him to stay fresh for those late-inning at-bats.

Ryan: Springer’s value is in his experience and OBP. Even if he isn’t playing the field, his presence in the lineup forces pitchers to be careful. In the finale, the Jays won 5-1. Every run mattered. Springer’s ability to get on base and move runners was crucial, even if the box score doesn’t always capture that nuance.

Melissa: It’s about the whole team effort. Davis Schneider and Yohendrick Pinango in left field, Myles Straw in center—they all contributed defensively. But the headline says 'Silver linings for MLB's non-playoff teams.' What was the silver lining for Toronto?

Ryan: The silver lining is development. Young players like Josh Smith and Luis Urias at second base got valuable at-bats. They learned how to handle pressure situations. Also, the ABS challenge system data gives the front office concrete metrics to improve plate discipline next year. It’s not all bad news.

Melissa: I agree. And let’s not forget the catcher spot. Alejandro Kirk is elite behind the plate. Shawn Ross and Brandon Valenzuela provide depth. Kirk’s framing likely kept some close games alive. Did his performance stand out in this final series?

Ryan: Kirk is always a factor. His ability to control the strike zone is vital for a rotation that includes Scherzer and Taillon. Against Cincinnati, he handled the pitchers well. The fact that Toronto won the finale 5-1 suggests their defensive mettle improved as the series progressed.

Melissa: So, stacking up against rivals: Toronto showed resilience. They bounced back from a loss to win the finale. But the gap in wins remains. How do you view the competitiveness of this roster compared to last year?

Ryan: It feels similar in terms of talent, but the execution was lacking. The 79-83 record reflects that. However, the core pieces—Guerrero, Kirk, Scherzer—are still there. The question is whether the supporting cast can improve enough to close the gap in the AL East.

Melissa: That’s the million-dollar question. Now, let’s look at Segment Three. What do these outside results mean for the Blue Jays' path? Specifically, the impact of Scherzer’s potential retirement.

Ryan: If Scherzer retires, Toronto loses a veteran leader and a proven winner. His 225th win is historic, but it’s also a milestone that might signal the end. The rotation needs a new identity. We predicted Taillon would hold the fifth spot. Without Scherzer, maybe he moves up, or maybe they acquire someone new.

Melissa: And the bullpen? We predicted half the current arms would be released or optioned. With the ABS challenge system showing umpire tendencies, maybe they lean on relievers who can exploit those trends. Guys like Ricky Tiedemann or John Klein might see increased usage.

Ryan: Exactly. The bullpen is crowded. Devereaux Harrison, Mason Fluharty, Spencer Miles—all these arms are competing. If the starters don’t eat up innings, the bullpen gets tired. That’s a risk. Toronto needs to ensure their rotation can go six innings consistently to protect the relievers.

Melissa: It’s a balancing act. On the field, they showed they can compete. Off the field, they need to make smart moves. The final day guide said there was much to play for. For Toronto, it was about dignity and preparation for next year.

Ryan: Dignity is important. Winning the finale against the Reds, who finished 75-86, proves they can beat anyone on any given day. But consistency over 162 games is the goal. They fell short this year, but the foundation is there.

Melissa: Let’s wrap this up with the path ahead. The Blue Jays finished fifth in the AL East. Scherzer is deciding on his future. The roster is young. What is your concrete prediction for 2027?

Ryan: I’m sticking with my previous prediction: the Blue Jays will finish between 78 and 82 wins. It’s a realistic range given the uncertainties in the rotation and bullpen. They won’t crash, but they won’t dominate unless something changes drastically.

Melissa: And regarding the roster? Do you think they’ll make a major trade before spring training?

Ryan: Unlikely to make a splashy move immediately. They might address specific needs, like starting pitching depth, but I expect them to ride the internal prospects like Arrighetti and Bieber. Trusting their own system is the safest bet.

Melissa: So, no panic mode. Just steady improvement. And Scherzer? If he comes back, it’s a boost. If he goes, it’s a transition.

Ryan: Correct. Either way, the focus shifts to the younger players. Kimura Okamoto, Andres Gimenez, Vlad Jr.—they need to step up. The silver lining is that they have time to grow.

Melissa: We’ll see how it unfolds. One last thing: the ABS challenge system. Did Toronto learn anything from their rankings that they can apply next season?

Ryan: Definitely. Understanding umpire tendencies helps batters adjust their approach. If they were challenged often, it might mean they were swinging at bad pitches. Improving plate discipline could lead to more walks and higher OBPs, which is crucial for scoring runs.

Melissa: Smart baseball. Okay, Ryan, any final thoughts on that Scherzer performance? Seven strikeouts, seven-plus innings, on short rest. It was magnificent.

Ryan: It was legendary. Regardless of whether he returns, that performance cemented his legacy. It was a perfect ending to a chapter. The Blue Jays gave him a win to remember.

Melissa: We covered the division rivals, the roster battles, and the path forward. Max Scherzer’s 225th win was the highlight, but the future rests on the shoulders of the young core. Thanks for listening!

Ryan: If you enjoyed the show, please subscribe, rate, and review. Share it with a fellow Blue Jays fan. Your support keeps us going.

Melissa: Head to the link in the episode description to support the network directly. Every bit helps us bring you this content daily. Until next time, Go Jays Go!