Blue Jays Power Rankings: Scherzer’s Final Act & The 2027 Outlook

Toronto Blue Jays · 2026-10-01 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Melissa: Max Scherzer, age forty-two, three days of rest, seven strikeouts, and his two hundred twenty-fifth career victory. That is not just a season finale; that is a statement.

Ryan: It was the kind of pitching performance that makes you forget about the seventy-nine wins for a moment. But now the confetti is swept up, and we have to look at the whole picture.

Melissa: Welcome back to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we break down every angle of your favorite teams. I’m Melissa, and this is our daily power rankings show. Ryan, how are you?

Ryan: I’m good, Melissa. Still buzzing from Sunday night in Cincinnati. It feels like yesterday we were talking about Gimenez’s pop potential and Springer’s defensive load.

Melissa: Right, and today we are putting those threads together into one big tape. Here is what we are covering: first, where the Blue Jays actually sit in the AL East hierarchy after finishing fifth with a seventy-nine-win season. Second, we are breaking down the roster strengths versus the glaring question marks heading into free agency. And third, we are giving you a realistic win projection for 2027 based on who stays and who goes.

Ryan: We also need to talk about the elephant in the room. Scherzer waiting until the offseason to decide if he plays a twentieth season. That changes everything about this franchise's identity.

Melissa: Let’s dive right in. Segment one: Division Standing. The Blue Jays finished seventh in the American League overall, fifth in the East. They lost the season finale five-one... wait, no, they won five-one against the Reds. But the record is seventy-nine and eighty-three.

Ryan: Seventy-nine wins sounds decent on paper, but in the AL East, it puts them firmly in the basement. You look at the gap between Toronto and the division leaders, and it’s significant. This wasn’t a team that hovered around .500; it was a team that struggled to find consistency.

Melissa: And yet, they managed to beat the Reds in the finale. Brandon Valenzuela and Charles McAdoo homered. Max Scherzer pitched seven-plus innings. Was that enough to salvage some pride?

Ryan: Pride? Sure. But looking at the standings, being fifth means you missed the postseason entirely. In a division that has been so competitive, finishing below .500 by ten games is a tough pill to swallow. It highlights the lack of depth in the lineup when the starting pitching isn't dominant every five days.

Melissa: So, if we rank them among all thirty teams, where do they land? Top half or bottom half?

Ryan: Bottom half. Easily. If you judge purely on the seventy-nine-win pace, they are outside the playoff picture. The issue is the ceiling. When Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is healthy, they can score runs. But as we saw against Cincinnati, if the bullpen struggles or the rotation falters early, there wasn't enough offensive firepower behind the stars to carry the team.

Melissa: That brings us to the core of the problem. Strengths and weaknesses. Let’s start with the obvious strength: Vladimir Guerrero Jr. He’s still an anchor at first base.

Ryan: Guerrero is elite. But you cannot build a playoff team on one player. You need Andres Gimenez to be that top-five shortstop we talked about last week. If he adds more power, he becomes a real asset. But defensively, the infield has been shaky. Ernie Clement and Josh Smith provide versatility, but they aren't defensive savants.

Melissa: What about the outfield? Brett Bateman, Nathan Lukes, Davis Schneider. Did they step up?

Ryan: They had moments, but it was inconsistent. George Springer returning to health was huge, especially given our prediction about reducing his defensive duties. He provides leadership and clutch hitting. But beyond him and Vlad, the middle of the order often went quiet. That’s the weakness. Lack of sustained production from the middle spots.

Melissa: And the rotation? We know Max Scherzer threw a gem on short rest. But beyond him, what do we have?

Ryan: Shane Bieber and Dylan Cease give you two solid anchors. Jameson Taillon holding the fifth starter role, as we predicted, was crucial. But when you lose Scherzer potentially, the drop-off is steep. You’re looking at Jose Soriano and CJ Van Eyk to fill gaps. That’s not a playoff-caliber rotation without help.

Melissa: So, the strength is a top-end talent in Vlad and a veteran ace in Scherzer. The weakness is the supporting cast around them. Ryan, does this team have a chance to bounce back quickly?

Ryan: Only if they address the bullpen. Half the current arms will be released or optioned, as we suspected. Paul Sewald is gone, and the rest of that group—Brendan Cellucci, Chad Dallas, Braydon Fisher—they weren't reliable. You need a closer who can shut the door, not just pitch eight innings of relief.

Melissa: It’s a lot of moving parts. Before we get into the outlook, I want to take a quick second. If you love this show, please consider supporting us. We keep the Beatline completely free, with no ads and no paywall, because we believe great baseball analysis should be accessible to everyone. Your support is what keeps the lights on and the episodes coming daily. Check out the link in the episode description to help us keep doing what we love. Thanks for listening.

Ryan: Thanks, Melissa. Now, let’s talk about the biggest question mark: The Offseason Decisions. Scherzer is a free agent. He’s forty-two. He just threw a masterpiece on three days' rest. Do you re-sign him?

Melissa: He said he’ll wait until the offseason. That’s classic Scherzer. He wants to see how he feels. But realistically, a contract extension for a pitcher past forty seems unlikely unless it’s a minimal incentive deal.

Ryan: Exactly. If he retires, you lose your best left-handed starter. Who steps up? Trey Yesavage showed flashes. Ricky Tiedemann is a young arm with high upside but limited MLB experience. The organization needs to decide if they are buyers or sellers in free agency.

Melissa: And the catcher situation? Alejandro Kirk is still there. Shawn Ross and Brandon Valenzuela provided depth. Valenzuela hit a homer in the finale. Is the catching position locked in?

Ryan: Kirk is fine. He’s a solid defender. But offensively, he hasn’t exploded. The team needs more from the battery. If they bring in a new starter, they need someone who can handle the pitchers well. The bullpen management was chaotic this year. John Klein, Chase Lee, Spencer Miles—they rotated too much without a clear hierarchy.

Melissa: So, the biggest question mark is: Can they build a stable rotation and bullpen without Scherzer and with a depleted budget?

Ryan: Yes. And they might need to look externally. Maybe sign a mid-tier starter to pair with Bieber and Cease. Taillon is likely back for the fifth spot, but that’s not enough to compete in the AL East. You need another arm who can eat innings and keep the game close.

Melissa: What about the infield? Andres Gimenez at shortstop. We predicted he could become a top-five shortstop if he adds power. Did he improve?

Ryan: He showed some pop, but not enough to consistently drive runs. He’s a great glove man, but offense matters more in this era of baseball. If he doesn’t hit twenty home runs next year, he’s just a defensive specialist. The Jays need him to be an all-around player.

Melissa: And George Springer? We said his defensive duties would be reduced. Did that happen?

Ryan: It did. He spent more time at DH or in left field. It preserved his availability. He’s aging, but his bat is still valuable. Keeping him healthy is priority number one. If he can stay on the field for one hundred fifty games, he’s worth his weight in gold.

Melissa: So, stability in the outfield, instability in the rotation and bullpen. That’s the landscape. Now, segment three: The Outlook. Realistic projections for 2027.

Ryan: If Scherzer leaves, I see this team going sub-.500 again. Seventy-eight to eighty wins. Without a strong addition, the rotation drops in quality. Bieber and Cease can carry a lot, but they can’t carry it all alone.

Melissa: But Vlad is still Vlad. And if Gimenez breaks out, and Springer stays healthy, maybe they sneak into a wild card spot?

Ryan: A wild card is a stretch. The AL East is too deep. The Red Sox, the Yankees, the Rays—they are all improving. Toronto needs a major infusion of talent. I think they finish fourth or fifth again unless they make a splash in free agency. A realistic win projection is eighty-two wins if they sign a mid-level starter and develop Tiedemann.

Melissa: Eighty-two wins. So, still missing the playoffs. Does that frustrate the fanbase?

Ryan: It should. But rebuilding takes time. They have young arms in Tiedemann and Young. They have veterans like Vlad and Springer. It’s a transition period. Scherzer’s potential retirement accelerates the rebuild.

Melissa: So, the takeaway is patience. Enjoy Scherzer while he’s here, but expect a tougher road ahead. Ryan, any final thoughts on the season finale?

Ryan: Just remember that win. Five-one over the Reds. Scherzer, Valenzuela, McAdoo. It was a perfect ending to a frustrating year. It shows what this team can look like when everything clicks. But we need more of those games next year.

Melissa: It was a great way to end the regular season. Today we ranked the Blue Jays in the division, analyzed their strengths and weaknesses, and projected a tough 2027. Thank you for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network.

Ryan: If you enjoyed this breakdown, please subscribe, rate, and review us on your favorite platform. It helps more fans find the show.

Melissa: Share this episode with a fellow Blue Jays fan. Let’s keep the conversation going all winter long. Go Jays!

Ryan: See you next time.