Scherzer’s Finale & The Future: Blue Jays Mailbag

Toronto Blue Jays · 2026-09-29 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Melissa: Max Scherzer, age forty-two, three days of rest, seven strikeouts, and his two-hundred-and-twenty-fifth career win. That is not just a stat line; that is history being written on the mound in Toronto.

Ryan: It was a masterclass in efficiency and toughness. You don’t get to that number without elite stuff and a willingness to grind through fatigue. And let’s be honest, watching him close out that season finale against Cincinnati felt like a passing of the torch moment for this franchise.

Melissa: Welcome back to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we live for the game, every single day. I’m Melissa, and as always, I’m joined by my favorite analyst, Ryan. We are kicking things off with a full mailbag episode today because your questions have been pouring in since that five-one victory wrapped up the regular season.

Ryan: Exactly. We went into this series knowing the stakes were low for the standings—we’re sitting fifth in the AL East at seventy-nine and eighty-three—but high for individual legacies and roster construction. So, what did you guys want to ask?

Melissa: Before we dive in, I need to take a quick second. This show is completely free for you, no ads, no paywall, just pure baseball talk. But keeping it daily and free takes resources. If you love what we do, please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. It keeps us going and helps us keep this space ad-free for all of you. Thank you for supporting independent sports media.

Ryan: That means a lot. Now, let’s get into the good stuff. We’ve got three segments planned. First, we’re tackling the biggest storylines from the final weekend. Then, we’ll look at some depth chart battles and roster moves. Finally, we’ve got a fun hypothetical and a lightning round. Let’s start with Segment One.

Melissa: Okay, here is our first question from Sarah in Rochester. She writes: 'I loved the win over Cincinnati, but can we talk about Max Scherzer? He pitched on short rest and still looked sharp. Is this his last ever game, or is there a chance he comes back next year?' Ryan, you were talking about his retirement decision yesterday.

Ryan: Right, so Sarah, this is the big one. Yesterday we discussed how his impending retirement decision loomed over this series. Today, after striking out seven over seven-plus innings, it feels like he might have made his choice. A forty-two-year-old throwing on three days of rest is an anomaly. Most pitchers that age are managing their arms, not chasing milestone wins.

Melissa: It really is impressive. But Ryan, you mentioned 'managing arms.' Does that performance actually signal a return? Or is it a farewell tour?

Ryan: I think it’s a farewell. When you see that level of command and velocity on short rest, especially in a season finale where the outcome doesn’t matter for October, it often serves as a final statement. He earned his two-hundred-and-twenty-fifth win. That’s a career-defining number. He likely wants to go out on top, which he did, beating the Reds five-one with home runs from Brandon Valenzuela and Charles McAdoo backing him up.

Melissa: So, we might not see him in the dugout next spring. That’s a heavy realization for Blue Jays fans. Let’s move to another question about the pitching staff. Marcus in Denver asks: 'With Scherzer likely done, who is actually starting next year? The rotation looks thin.'

Ryan: Marcus, great point. Looking at the roster we have now, you’ve got John Klein, Jose Soriano, and Trey Yesavage. Those are the names on the paper. But remember, we also had injuries throughout the season that forced guys like Brendan Cellucci and Chad Dallas into various roles. The front office needs to address this in the offseason. Relying on Klein and Soriano to carry the load is risky if they aren’t proven starters yet.

Melissa: It’s a gap. And speaking of gaps, let’s look at the bullpen. We have Paul Sewald, Louis Varland, Mason Fluharty, Braydon Fisher, Chase Lee, Spencer Miles, Tyler Rogers, and Brendan Little. That’s a crowded group. Do any of those guys get moved?

Ryan: That is a lot of arms. In a mailbag context, we have to look at value. Paul Sewald is an established closer type. Louis Varland has shown promise. The others—Fluharty, Fisher, Lee, Miles, Rogers, Little—they’re depth pieces. If the team isn’t going to compete immediately, some of those contracts could be used as trade chips or they’ll fight for spots in Spring Training. It’s a deep bullpen, but maybe too deep without clear roles for everyone.

Melissa: Let’s pivot to the offense. David in Chicago asks: 'Vladimir Guerrero Jr. had a quiet end to the season. With George Springer seeing reduced defensive duties, is Vlad still the face of the franchise, or do we need to rebuild around younger talent like Andres Gimenez?'

Ryan: David, this ties back to what we said yesterday about Vlad’s off-field distractions and focus. Statistically, he’s still the anchor. But the question is about the future. We predicted earlier that Andres Gimenez could become a top-five shortstop if he adds more pop. That’s a key development. If Gimenez hits his stride, Vlad becomes more of a designated hitter or first base specialist, which opens up lineup flexibility.

Melissa: And George Springer? We talked about his reduced defensive load. Is he still productive enough to justify that spot?

Ryan: Absolutely. As long as he’s available and providing veteran leadership, his bat is valuable. Keeping him healthy is priority number one. But yes, the core is shifting slightly toward a mix of Vlad’s power and Gimenez’s speed/defense.

Melissa: Alright, that wraps up our first segment on the biggest storylines. Stick with us, because next up, we’re diving into specific roster battles and depth chart questions.

Melissa: Welcome back. Segment Two is all about the nuts and bolts. Emily from Seattle asks: 'Who is winning the center field job next year? We have Brett Bateman, Myles Straw, Nathan Lukes, and Davis Schneider sometimes playing out there. Who starts?'

Ryan: Emily, that’s a tough call because it depends on what the team wants. Myles Straw is an elite defender. If defense is the priority, he’s the starter. But Brett Bateman brings more power. Nathan Lukes showed some spark in the final series. Davis Schneider is primarily left-handed, so he’s a platoon piece. I think Straw gets the nod defensively, but Bateman might win it with his bat if the team wants to shift towards offense.

Melissa: So it’s a battle of styles. What about second base? We have Ernie Clement, Charles McAdoo, and Josh Smith. McAdoo homered in the finale, which was huge. Does that help his case?

Ryan: It definitely helps. McAdoo’s ability to hit from both sides and play solid defense makes him attractive. Ernie Clement is versatile and experienced. Josh Smith is young and has upside. I think McAdoo and Clement will compete for the primary spot, with Smith as a super-sub option. The coaching staff likes versatility, so whoever gives them the best lineup construction wins.

Melissa: Let’s talk catchers. Alejandro Kirk is the incumbent, but Brandon Valenzuela had a great finish, hitting a homer in the finale. Is Kirk’s job secure?

Ryan: Kirk’s job is secure. He’s one of the best defensive catchers in the league and a consistent offensive producer. Valenzuela provided a nice boost, but he’s still developing. Kirk is the everyday catcher unless he slumps. Valenzuela will likely split time or serve as a backup who can handle left-handed pitching well.

Melissa: What about third base? Kazuma Okamoto had a rough stretch, but we talked about him needing small-ball execution. How does he look heading into the offseason?

Ryan: Okamoto struggled with consistency. His strikeout rate was high. The team needs someone who can put the ball in play. If he doesn’t improve his plate discipline, he might find himself looking for opportunities elsewhere. The front office has to decide if they believe he can turn it around or if they need to explore other options at the hot corner.

Melissa: Tough love for Okamoto. Alright, we’ve covered the infield and outfield battles. Let’s move to Segment Three, where we get a bit more creative.

Melissa: Segment Three! First, a fun hypothetical from @JaysFan4Life: 'If the Blue Jays could only keep one pitcher from the current roster besides Scherzer (assuming he’s gone) and Sewald, who do you pick?'

Ryan: @JaysFan4Life, that’s a brutal choice. If I’m building for next year, I’d pick Louis Varland. He’s young, he has a good fastball, and he showed flashes of dominance. He has the highest ceiling among the remaining arms. Varland is the guy you bet on for the future.

Melissa: I agree. Varland has the stuff. Okay, lightning round! Quick takes on these three topics. First: Did the Blue Jays miss the playoffs, but still have reason to be optimistic?

Ryan: Yes. They finished seventh in the AL East wait, no, fifth at seventy-nine and eighty-three. But they have young talent like Varland, McAdoo, and potentially Gimenez breaking out. The foundation is there. It’s not a total rebuild; it’s a refinement phase.

Melissa: Second topic: Who is the most underrated player on the roster right now?

Ryan: Charles McAdoo. He wasn’t getting much attention until that final series, but his versatility and clutch hitting against Cincinnati showed he belongs. He’s a player who can fill multiple roles effectively.

Melissa: Third topic: What is the one thing the front office MUST fix in the offseason?

Ryan: Starting pitching depth. Beyond Scherzer’s departure, the rotation is unproven. They need to add at least one reliable starter to support Klein and Soriano. Without that, they’re gambling on youth again.

Melissa: Great points. Alright, we’re coming to the end of the show. Let’s wrap it up.

Melissa: To recap: Scherzer’s historic finale, the rotation needs a boost, and McAdoo is the surprise star. Thanks for listening to today’s mailbag. Please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you get your podcasts. Share this episode with a fellow Blue Jays fan.

Ryan: Enjoy the offseason, everyone. Keep supporting the team, and we’ll see you when the new season begins.

Melissa: This is the Beatline Podcast Network. Go Jays!