Jays vs Reds Preview: Lukes’ Heroics, Scherzer’s Shadow & The Final Push

Toronto Blue Jays · 2026-09-26 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Melissa: Nathan Lukes just dropped a go-ahead single in the seventh, Kazuma Okamoto had three RBIs, and the Toronto Blue Jays rallied to beat the Cincinnati Reds 6-5. But with Vladimir Guerrero Jr. playing through regret over his contract comments and Max Scherzer looming over the entire roster like a ghost, is this final series against Cincinnati actually about winning, or is it about survival?

Ryan: It’s about survival of the fittest, Melissa. We’ve got a 78-82 record, fifth in the AL East, and a bullpen that has been stretched thinner than butter on cold toast. But let’s get into it. Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network.

Melissa: I’m Melissa, and I’m joined by Ryan. If you’re new here, you’re in the right place for deep dives into the MLB. Today, we’re breaking down the pitching matchup for tonight’s game, looking at the injury report that’s decimated both clubs, and figuring out who actually steps up when the season is on the line.

Ryan: And remember, last night we talked about how Scherzer’s impending announcement was weighing on everyone. Tonight, we see if the team can play baseball without that shadow hanging over every pitch. Let’s dive into Segment One.

Melissa: Okay, so the Reds are in town for the finale. Last night, Toronto won 6-5. It was a tight one. Who do you think starts tonight? The Reds have a pretty banged-up rotation with Shane Bieber on the 15-Day IL, Tony Santillan on the 15-Day IL, and Chase Burns on the 15-Day IL as well.

Ryan: It’s a mess over there. With Bieber, Santillan, and Burns all out, Cincinnati is likely turning to a reliever or a long-man type. For us, we have Max Scherzer, Jose Soriano, John Klein, and Trey Yesavage available. Given the stakes—well, not playoff stakes, but pride stakes—I’d expect Scherzer to take the mound one last time before he announces whatever it is he’s been hinting at.

Melissa: Right, the Scherzer elephant in the room. We mentioned yesterday how his shoulder inflammation and general career uncertainty were affecting the clubhouse. If he goes, does he have the stuff to shut down a Reds lineup that just scored five runs against us?

Ryan: If he goes, he needs to rely on location, not velocity. His velocity isn’t what it was, and against a team like Cincinnati, which has some power hitters despite their own injuries, you can’t give them free pitches. But honestly, I think they might save him for a symbolic appearance or keep him out to rest him for an interview tour. That’s the smart move.

Melissa: Smart move for Scherzer, maybe, but risky for the Jays’ morale. If he doesn’t start, who’s next? Jose Soriano? He’s got the experience, but has he been effective lately?

Ryan: Soriano is reliable. He’s not flashy, but he keeps the ball in the park. Against a Reds team missing Spencer Steer (60-Day IL) and Michael Toglia (60-Day IL), their offense is weakened. So even if it’s Soriano, I think Toronto wins this game if the defense holds up.

Melissa: So we’re leaning toward a Jays win in the pitching department. But let’s talk about the Reds’ bullpen. They’ve got guys like Julian Garcia on the 15-Day IL, so their relief options are also limited. This feels like a game where the starter goes deep.

Ryan: Exactly. If the Reds’ starter is a mop-up guy from the minors, they’ll burn through him early. Then their bullpen has to carry the load. And trust me, nobody wants to see Paul Sewald or Brendan Cellucci work back-to-back days again. They’re already taxed.

Melissa: Right, the bullpen fatigue is real. We talked about Pete Alonso’s power threat last week, and while he’s not in this series, the concept of high-leverage situations is exactly what we’re facing. Stick with us, because in Segment Two, we’re breaking down the offensive keys and the injury list that’s killing us.

Melissa: Let’s talk about the offense. Last night, Nathan Lukes hit that go-ahead single, and Kazuma Okamoto drove in three runs. Those two seem to be the heartbeat right now. Who else needs to step up tonight?

Ryan: Lukes and Okamoto are vital. But don’t forget Vladimir Guerrero Jr. He’s dealing with some off-field noise regarding his contract remarks—he apologized for saying he owed an apology for comments that weren’t what he wanted to say. It’s confusing, but you want your best player focused on hitting.

Melissa: It is confusing. He said he stood by his remarks that he received a $500 million extension for what he did in the past, then apologized. It’s a lot of mental baggage for a guy trying to drive in runs at first base. Do you think it’s affecting his plate discipline?

Ryan: I think it’s distracting him. Vlad is still going to get hits, but if he’s swinging at bad pitches to prove a point or just vent frustration, that’s trouble. We need him to stay disciplined. Also, George Springer and Sean Keys are listed as DHs. Springer brings that veteran presence.

Melissa: Springer is always a threat. What about the outfield? We have Brett Bateman on day-to-day, Davis Schneider, Myles Straw, and Nathan Lukes. Bateman being day-to-day is concerning given the defensive demands.

Ryan: Bateman’s status is key. If he’s out, Straw moves to center, which changes our defensive alignment. Straw is great defensively, but his bat is weaker. So we’re trading power for range. It’s a tactical shift that could matter in the late innings.

Melissa: And let’s not ignore the infield. Ernie Clement, Andres Gimenez, Charles McAdoo, Josh Smith. We have a lot of versatility there. But the injury list is staggering. On our side, Luis Urias is on the 10-Day IL. Jonatan Clase is on the 60-Day IL. Rudy Martin Jr. is on the 10-Day IL.

Ryan: That’s a lot of bodies missing. When you lose players like Urias and Martin, you’re relying on call-ups or guys playing out of position. It forces the manager to make tough choices. Does he play a rookie who hasn’t faced big league pitching yet? Or does he rest a veteran?

Melissa: It’s a dilemma. And with the ABS challenge system tracker showing team rankings, every run matters more now. The marginal gains are huge. A stolen base, a saved run in the field—those are the things that define these final games. Ryan, what’s your read on the bullpen usage tonight?

Ryan: I think they’ll try to get four or five outs from the main arms—Sewald, Cellucci, Fisher—and then use the lower-tier relievers like Chad Dallas or Mason Fluharty in garbage time. If it’s close, though, they’ll lean on their veterans regardless of the rest days.

Melissa: Garbage time or not, the legs have to be fresh. You can’t have a tired arm giving up a home run in the ninth. Stick with us, because in Segment Three, we’re laying out the keys to victory and making a bold prediction for tonight’s game.

Melissa: Alright, bold prediction time. We’ve got the Jays at 78-82. The Reds are also struggling with injuries. I’m predicting the Blue Jays win this game 5-3. Why? Because Lukes and Okamoto are hot, and the Reds’ bullpen is too depleted to hold a lead.

Ryan: I agree with the win, but I think it’s uglier. I’m going 4-3. The Reds will score some runs because their lineup is desperate, but our pitching—whether it’s Scherzer or Soriano—will keep it close. The key is avoiding big innings. If Toronto scores one run at a time, they win.

Melissa: One run at a time. That’s the strategy. Small ball, timely hitting. And what about the Scherzer factor? If he doesn’t start, does that demoralize the team? Or does it free them up to just play hard for each other?

Ryan: I think it frees them up. If Scherzer isn’t starting, there’s no pressure on him to perform one last time. The guys who are playing know it’s their last chance to impress for next year. That urgency usually leads to better defense and more hustle plays.

Melissa: Hustle plays. I love that. So, final takeaway: Trust the young guns like Lukes, watch out for the bullpen fatigue, and hope for the best with Scherzer. Ryan, any final thoughts before we sign off?

Ryan: Just keep an eye on the ABS challenge stats. If the umpires are calling balls and strikes strictly, that favors our pitchers. If it’s a loose strike zone, look for the power hitters to capitalize. It’s all about context tonight.

Melissa: Context is everything. Thanks for tuning in to the Beatline Podcast Network. We just broke down the Jays' 6-5 win over the Reds, the injury headaches, and the Scherzer mystery. Before we go, we need your help. Putting out a fresh show every single day takes a massive amount of coordination and passion, and it’s supporters like you that make that possible. Please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description—it keeps the show free and daily for all of us.

Ryan: We appreciate every listen, every share, and every contribution. It means the world to us. Now, get out there, grab some popcorn, and root for the Blue Jays tonight.

Melissa: Go Jays! See you tomorrow!