Rays Roster Battles: Caminero’s Spot & The Bullpen Shuffle

Tampa Bay Rays · 2026-09-30 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Danielle: Junior Caminero just turned twenty-two, and he might be the most dangerous bat in baseball right now. But with a 98-64 record, does he make the playoff roster, or is he sitting on the bench? That is the question we are answering today.

Eric: It’s not just about power, Danielle. It’s about defensive value at third base and whether the Rays can afford to carry four infielders when their bullpen is already stretched thin after that Phillies loss.

Danielle: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Danielle, and this is your daily stop for everything Tampa Bay Rays. Eric is here to break down the tactical side of our final roster decisions before Game One against the Yankees and Red Sox.

Eric: Hey everyone. We survived the regular season at 98-64, first in the AL East. Now it’s time to see who stays in October and who gets sent back to Durham.

Danielle: Here is what we are tackling today: First, the battle for the fourth infield spot between Nick Madrigal and Richie Palacios. Second, the rotation depth with Brody Hopkins and Ian Seymour. And finally, which relievers are trending up as we head into October.

Eric: We’re looking at the ABS challenge system data, the platoon splits, and the sheer volume of arms available. Let’s get into the battles.

Danielle: Alright, Segment One. The biggest conversation on the internet right now is Junior Caminero. He’s been electric. But we have three other guys competing for playing time at the hot corner and second base: Nick Madrigal, Richie Palacios, and Ben Williamson. Who makes the cut?

Eric: Well, let’s look at the roster construction. You’ve got Yandy Diaz locking down first. You’ve got Taylor Walls and Jorge Mateo at shortstop. So the competition is really between Madrigal, Palacios, and Caminero for that fourth infielder role.

Danielle: Right. And remember, last week we talked about how the Phillies exploited our defensive gaps. If Caminero plays third, his defense is a liability. If he plays second, he’s unproven there. What do you think?

Eric: I think the Rays prioritize defense in October. Nick Madrigal is a contact specialist with elite plate discipline. His OBP is going to be huge against left-handed pitching. He’s the safer bet for a one-game series.

Danielle: But Caminero has the raw power. In a single-elimination environment, do you leave that kind of offensive upside on the table?

Eric: You don’t leave it on the table, but you manage it. I think Caminero starts on the bench as the designated hitter. He bats eighth or ninth. He’s not starting every day because the defensive shift required at third base would cost us runs.

Danielle: So Madrigal is the everyday guy, Caminero is the super-sub DH? What about Richie Palacios? He’s played all over the outfield too.

Eric: Palacios is likely the fifth outfielder. With Jonny DeLuca, Victor Mesa Jr., Ryan Vilade, Cedric Mullins, and Chandler Simpson, the outfield is crowded. Palacios provides versatility, but he doesn’t offer the same defensive stability at second base as Madrigal.

Danielle: That makes sense. Madrigal stays. Caminero gets limited at-bats. Palacios is the utility piece. So who is the odd man out for the infield specifically?

Eric: Ben Williamson. He’s talented, but he’s behind Madrigal and Caminero on the depth chart. Unless Caminero struggles significantly in spring training next year, Williamson is likely optioned.

Danielle: Ouch. Ben Williamson hears that and heads back to the minors. Okay, moving on to Segment Two. We need to talk about the pitching staff. Last week, Steven Matz was supposed to dominate, but we saw some cracks in the armor against Philadelphia.

Eric: Yeah, the bullpen usage was concerning. We had to call on guys like Garrett Cleavinger and Kevin Kelly earlier than we wanted. Now, with the playoffs starting, we have to look at the rotation depth.

Danielle: Exactly. Shane McClanahan is the ace, obviously. Freddy Peralta is coming off a strong stretch. But then we have Joe Boyle, Nick Martinez, Drew Rasmussen, Griffin Jax, and Ian Seymour. Who is the number four starter?

Eric: This is where it gets tricky. Drew Rasmussen has experience, but his velocity has dipped slightly. Nick Martinez brings a different flavor with his ground-ball rates. But I think the Rays are leaning younger here.

Danielle: You mean Brody Hopkins and Ian Seymour? We predicted last week that they’d see significant time in 2027, but are they ready for October pressure?

Eric: They aren’t ready to start Game One. But if the series goes five games, I think Ian Seymour gets the nod over Rasmussen. His stuff is sharper, and he thrives in high-leverage spots. The ABS challenge system shows his strikeout rate is climbing.

Danielle: So Seymour is the swingman who could slide into the rotation if needed. What about the bullpen? Who closes the game?

Eric: That’s still an open question. Bryan Baker and Casey Legumina are the veterans. Tyler Wells has been effective in relief recently. I think Baker gets the save opportunities, but it’s a committee approach.

Danielle: A committee. That means no one is truly settled. This feels risky for a team that wants to go deep into October. Do you agree?

Eric: It’s risky, but it’s also flexible. If Baker gets hit hard, you can switch to Legumina. The Rays have always valued adaptability over static roles. That’s their identity.

Danielle: Adaptability. Right. Well, before we dive into our final segment on roster cuts, I want to take a quick moment. If you love this podcast and want to help keep it free and daily, please consider supporting us. A small contribution covers the daily research, the editing, and keeps the feed running. Just click the link in the episode description. Thank you so much for your support!

Danielle: Okay, Segment Three. Roster cuts. We have 40-man roster spots to fill. We’ve talked about Caminero, Madrigal, and Seymour. Who else is on the bubble?

Eric: Let’s look at the catchers. You have Nick Fortes, Liam Hicks, and Kenny Piper. Fortes is the primary backstop. Hicks has shown promise with pitch framing. Piper is young.

Danielle: So Fortes and Hicks are locks. Piper is the odd man out? Or does he stay as insurance?

Eric: Piper is likely the odd man out. The Rays rarely carry three catchers unless there’s an injury concern. Since Hicks is solid, Piper gets sent down to ensure we have enough arms for the bullpen.

Danielle: Makes sense. What about the pitchers? Jesse Scholtens and Manuel Rodriguez haven’t seen much action lately. Are they safe?

Eric: Scholtens is trending down. His command has been inconsistent. Rodriguez is more volatile. I think either Scholtens or Rodriguez is the first one cut from the active roster.

Danielle: That’s a tough pill to swallow for those players. But with the workload of the playoffs, you need guys who are fresh. Who is trending up the most for you?

Eric: Ian Seymour. He’s been quiet, but his metrics are screaming. Also, Junior Caminero’s presence alone elevates the entire lineup’s threat level. Even if he’s not starting, defenses have to respect him.

Danielle: I love that take. Caminero changes the game even when he’s watching. So, final predictions. Who wins the AL East again next year?

Eric: The Rays win the AL East again in 2027. The core is too young and too talented to regress significantly.

Danielle: Agreed. And who makes the playoff roster tonight? Caminero starts at DH against the Yankees. Madrigal plays second. Seymour is the sixth starter.

Danielle: We’ve got a massive weekend ahead. The Yankees and Red Sox are in town. It’s going to be electric. Make sure you subscribe, rate, and review the show wherever you listen.

Eric: And bring your noise. The Tropicana Stadium crowd needs to be loud. Go Rays!

Danielle: Go Rays! I’m Danielle, joined by Eric. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network.