Cardinals Fall Short: Brewers' Historic 102 Wins and the NL Central Gap

St. Louis Cardinals · 2026-10-16 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Christine: Jacob Misiorowski didn’t just win the ERA title—he dominated. And while St. Louis finished with a 77-85 record, Milwaukee’s 102 wins are a different story entirely.

Jason: It’s a stark contrast in the NL Central. One team is celebrating a historic season; the other is looking at the horizon for 2027.

Christine: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Christine, joined by Jason. Today we’re breaking down that divisional gap, Jacob Misiorowski’s Cy Young campaign, and what Brice Turang’s late heroics mean for the Cardinals’ future.

Jason: We’ve got three things coming up. First, how Misiorowski became just the fourth pitcher since 1950 to lead the majors in ERA, strikeouts, and opponents' batting average. Second, the Cardinals’ recent struggles against Milwaukee, including Turang’s go-ahead homer. And third, what this means for the rest of the league as the non-playoff teams look toward spring training.

Christine: Let’s dive into Segment One: Division Rivals. Jason, start us off. How do you view Jacob Misiorowski’s season in isolation?

Jason: It’s elite. We’re talking about a pitcher who capped his brilliant season with two hits allowed in five and a third shutout innings against St. Louis on Sunday. But it’s the volume stats that stand out. Leading the majors in ERA, strikeouts, AND opponents' batting average? That is rarefied air.

Christine: Right, and he’s only the fourth pitcher since 1950 to do that triple crown of pitching dominance. What does that say about his stuff?

Jason: It says his pitch mix is unhit-able. When you hold opponents to such a low average while striking them out at a high rate, you’re controlling the zone completely. He’s not just relying on velocity; he’s manipulating launch angles and inducing weak contact consistently.

Christine: So if he keeps this up, he’s locking down the Cy Young Award push. Did Yordan Alvarez and Gabriel Moreno have strong finishes too?

Jason: They did. Alvarez won his first batting title with Houston, and Moreno took it with Arizona. It was a good year for offensive titles, but Misiorowski’s achievement feels more monumental because it requires total command.

Christine: Agreed. Now, let’s talk about the Cardinals’ side of this rivalry. They finished second in the NL Central at 77-85, but they were swept in that final series against Milwaukee.

Jason: Yeah, it stings. On Saturday, Brice Turang hit a go-ahead two-run homer that lifted the Brewers over the Cardinals 3-2. That was Milwaukee’s 102nd win of the season. By Sunday, after Misiorowski’s shutout, the Brewers had closed out the sweep 6-4.

Christine: So the Cardinals entered that series trying to break a skid, and instead, they watched their division rival set a franchise record for wins. How painful is that loss for the clubhouse?

Jason: Painful, but it highlights the gap. You can’t beat the best team in baseball twice in one weekend if you’re struggling with plate discipline. Turang’s homer wasn’t just luck; it came when the Cardinals’ bullpen likely had to stretch or rely on weaker arms.

Christine: Speaking of the bullpen, we mentioned Ryne Stanek and Gordon Graceffo earlier in the week. How did they fare in those losses?

Jason: It was tough. When you’re playing from behind, the bullpen gets exposed. With Justin Bruihl, Ryan Fernandez, and others involved, the pressure mounts. You need stability there, which ties back to what we discussed about needing a stable everyday catcher to keep the whole staff calm.

Christine: Exactly. Let’s move to Segment Two: How the Team Stacks Up. Jason, looking at the roster, who showed up for St. Louis in that final series?

Jason: Honestly, it was hard to find bright spots. The Brewers brought their A-game. But for St. Louis, we have to look at the young core. Masyn Winn and JJ Wetherholt at shortstop and second base. We predicted Wetherholt would emerge as a key contributor in 2027.

Christine: And Jordan Walker’s power development is still the engine for next year. Remember, we predicted he’d hit 30 home runs in 2027 if the rest of the puzzle fits.

Jason: Right. But right now, the offense struggled against Misiorowski. When a pitcher is limiting opponents’ batting average, you need exceptional plate discipline. Did Alec Burleson or Nolan Gorman get any solid at-bats?

Christine: Not many. The Cardinals looked stiff. And defensively, with Leo Bernal, Jimmy Crooks, and Pedro Pages behind the plate, the catching hierarchy is still fluid. Ivan Herrera has been solid, but Pedro Pages needs to show significant improvement in spring training to retain the everyday role.

Jason: That’s the critical piece. If the catcher isn’t calling a sharp game, the pitchers like Cooper Hjerpe or Andre Pallante don’t have the same confidence. The gap between 77 wins and 102 wins often starts with that intangible leadership on the mound.

Christine: So, is the Cardinals’ roster ready to compete with Milwaukee next year? Or is there another step needed?

Jason: Another step. Not because the talent isn’t there—Winn, Walker, Burleson are all capable—but because the execution wasn’t there in October. To close that gap, the Cardinals need to be more aggressive in stealing bases and turning double plays. Speed kills, and Milwaukee used theirs effectively.

Christine: I agree. If Everson Pereira and Victor Scott II can use their speed more, it puts pressure on the defense. But against a team like Milwaukee, you need more than just speed. You need clutch hitting.

Jason: Clutch hitting is elusive. Turang delivered when it mattered most. For St. Louis, the question is whether their young hitters can handle that pressure next season. It’s a tall order.

Christine: Let’s pivot to Segment Three: Outside Results and the Path Forward. The headlines mention silver linings for non-playoff teams. What’s the takeaway for St. Louis?

Jason: The takeaway is that losing doesn’t mean failure. It means evaluation. The ABS challenge system tracker shows how umpires and players performed all year. There’s data there to help the coaching staff refine their strategy.

Christine: And Sam Fuld declining the A’s presidency is interesting news around the league. Does that affect the Cardinals’ front office dynamics?

Jason: Not directly, but it shows that executive moves are happening everywhere. Taylor Smith remains a top candidate for Oakland. Meanwhile, the Cardinals need to focus on their own internal promotions. Who steps up in the minor leagues? Who becomes the everyday catcher?

Christine: True. The Cardinals have a lot of pieces: Quinn Mathews, Kyle Leahy, Hunter Dobbins in the minors. The path to 85 wins in 2027 is clear if they secure that catcher spot and if Walker hits his power.

Jason: And if Wetherholt emerges. We’re sticking with that prediction. He has the tools. It’s just about consistency.

Christine: Before we go, I want to take a quick moment. Producing this fresh, daily analysis takes a lot of time and passion. Your support helps keep the show free and accessible for everyone. If you enjoy our breakdowns, please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. It truly makes a difference.

Jason: Thanks for listening. The Cardinals have a foundation. Now they need to build on it.

Christine: Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Keep cheering loud for the Birds on the Bird Bath!