Cardinals Roster Battles: Catcher Clash & Bullpen Chaos

St. Louis Cardinals · 2026-10-10 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Christine: Pedro Pages is the future, or he’s just another guy who can’t handle a lefty starter. One of those two defines this team’s October fate.

Jason: And if Pages doesn’t figure out the platoon split by spring training, Ivan Herrera might be starting more games than you think.

Christine: I’m Jason, and we are breaking down the roster battles that will decide whether the Cardinals bounce back in 2027.

Christine: Here is what we’ve got for you today. First, we’re settling the catcher debate once and for all: Pages versus Herrera. Second, we’re looking at the infield logjam at third base and shortstop with Wetherholt and Winn. And finally, we’re predicting which relievers make the cut and who gets sent down to Memphis.

Jason: It’s a tight race. The front office has some tough decisions to make before the winter meetings.

Christine: Let’s jump right into Segment One. We talked about the catcher hierarchy last week, but now that the season is over, it feels even more urgent. Pedro Pages had his moments, but Ivan Herrera was the steady hand when everything else went wrong.

Jason: Right. And let’s not forget Leo Bernal and Jimmy Crooks are still on the roster. But realistically, it’s Pages vs. Herrera for the everyday job. Pages has the arm, but his strikeout rate against left-handed pitching is a liability.

Christine: Exactly. You look at the data from this year, and Herrera’s plate discipline is just superior. He’s keeping pitchers honest. Pages needs to show more consistency in his swing mechanics.

Jason: I agree on Herrera’s approach, but Pages’ defensive metrics are off the charts. If he can just make contact, he’s an All-Star caliber catcher. The issue is his launch angle is too low; he’s popping up too many fly balls instead of driving the ball.

Christine: So, do you think the Cardinals keep both? Or do they have to trade one?

Jason: They’ll likely keep both as insurance, but I think Herrera starts every game against lefties until Pages proves otherwise. It’s about minimizing risk.

Christine: That makes sense. So, Pages has to win the job in spring training, or he’s stuck behind Herrera. No middle ground there.

Jason: Correct. And if he doesn’t, the Cardinals might look elsewhere in the offseason.

Christine: Alright, moving on. We mentioned the infield logjam. Masyn Winn is locked in at shortstop, but JJ Wetherholt is making noise at second base.

Jason: Wetherholt’s defense is elite. His range factor is top-tier. But can he hit enough to stay on the field every day? His OBP needs to climb if he’s going to displace someone like Thomas Saggese.

Christine: Saggese is fast, but he’s not a power threat. Wetherholt has the raw tools to be a five-tool player if he trusts his hands.

Jason: He does. But the competition at third base is even fiercer. Nolan Gorman, Blaze Jordan, and Cesar Prieto are all vying for playing time.

Christine: Gorman has the power, but his strikeout rate is unsustainable. Jordan is younger, but does he have the patience to learn from Gorman’s mistakes?

Jason: Jordan has the potential, but he needs to improve his defensive positioning. He’s getting beat on balls in the gap too often. Prieto offers a safer floor, but maybe less ceiling.

Christine: So, it’s a three-way battle with no clear favorite yet. That’s going to be fun to watch in camp.

Jason: It is. And don’t forget about Alec Burleson at first base. He’s solid, but he’s not a star yet.

Christine: We’ll get to him in a bit. For now, let’s stick with the infield. What’s your take on the outfield mix?

Jason: Jordan Walker is the centerpiece. Everson Pereira and Joshua Baez are providing depth, but Nathan Church and Victor Scott II are speed merchants who need to contribute offensively.

Christine: Church is fast, but he’s not a run producer. Scott is similar. They need to step up their batting average if they want to stay in the rotation.

Jason: Agreed. And Bryan Torres is still on the roster, which is interesting. He’s a versatile outfielder, but does he have a path to regular playing time?

Christine: Probably not unless someone gets injured. It’s a crowded room out there.

Jason: Very crowded. And that’s just the position players. The pitching staff has its own drama.

Christine: Speaking of the pitching staff, Cooper Hjerpe and Andre Pallante were the bright spots in the rotation. But who else is in the mix?

Jason: Hunter Dobbins and Richard Fitts showed flashes, but consistency is key. Kyle Leahy and Quinn Mathews are young arms that could surprise us.

Christine: Mathews has a great slider. If he keeps it in the zone, he’s a nightmare for hitters.

Jason: He does. But command is everything. One mistake inning and he’s in trouble.

Christine: Let’s wrap up this segment here. The catcher battle is the most critical, but the infield depth is a close second. Stick with us, because things are about to get even more intense.

Jason: Segment Two. Let’s talk bullpen. Ryne Stanek is the closer, but who is the setup man?

Christine: Justin Bruihl has been effective, but Gordon Graceffo and Matt Svanson are also options. It’s a deep group.

Jason: Graceffo has the best stuff. His fastball velocity is elite. But can he handle high-leverage situations? Pressure gets to some guys.

Christine: I think he thrives under pressure. He’s a competitor. But Svanson is the wild card. His changeup is plus-plus.

Jason: The changeup is lethal. But if he can’t find the strike, he’s gone. Command is the issue.

Christine: So, Stanek closes, Graceffo sets up, and Svanson is the long relief option who could move up.

Jason: Sounds like a plan. But what about the lefty specialists? George Soriano and Luis Gastelum are both right-handed.

Christine: That’s a problem. They need a lefty specialist. Maybe they bring in a free agent.

Jason: Or maybe they promote someone from Memphis. There are lefty relievers in the minors who could help.

Christine: That’s a smart move. Keeps costs down and gives young guys experience.

Jason: Exactly. And don’t forget about Ryan Fernandez. He’s a rookie who showed promise.

Christine: Fernandez has a great delivery. If he adds a slider, he could be a lock for the bullpen.

Jason: He does. But again, it’s about refinement. The margins are thin.

Christine: Let’s pivot to the DH spot. Ivan Herrera is there, but what about other options?

Jason: Herrera is the primary option. He hits well enough to DH when he’s not catching. But if he’s catching, who is the DH?

Christine: Maybe Alec Burleson moves to DH? Or Jose Fermin?

Jason: Fermin is a good candidate. He’s a switch-hitter with some pop. Burleson is better suited for first base or left field.

Christine: Makes sense. Fermin provides flexibility. He can play left field if needed too.

Jason: Right. Versatility is key in modern baseball. Coaches love it.

Christine: So, we have Herrera as the backup catcher/DH hybrid, Fermin as the utility bat, and Burleson anchored at first.

Jason: That’s a solid lineup construction. But it depends on health. Injuries always shake things up.

Christine: True. And speaking of health, how are the starters looking heading into next year?

Jason: Hjerpe and Pallante are anchors. Bruihl is emerging. But the rest of the rotation is a question mark.

Christine: Question mark is an understatement. They need a veteran presence.

Jason: They do. And that brings us to our support appeal. If you enjoyed this breakdown of the Cardinals' roster battles, please consider supporting us. Your contribution helps keep this show free and daily. Check the link in the episode description.

Christine: Thanks for that. Now, let’s get to Segment Three. Who’s making the roster and who’s getting sent down?

Jason: I think the core is set. Winn, Walker, Herrera, Hjerpe, Pallante, Stanek. Those seven are locks.

Christine: Seven locks. That leaves four spots. I’d say Graceffo, Burleson, Fermin, and maybe a fifth starter.

Jason: Graceffo is a lock for the bullpen. Burleson is solid. Fermin is versatile. The fifth starter spot is the hardest to predict.

Christine: I’m leaning towards Dobbins. He has upside. But Mathews is the dark horse.

Jason: Mathews has the stuff. If he wins the job, it’s based on performance, not pedigree.

Christine: What about the guys who are trending down? Like Nolan Gorman?

Jason: Gorman is risky. If he doesn’t improve his strikeout rate, he’ll be traded or demoted.

Christine: Ouch. But fair. What about Pedro Pages?

Jason: Pages is trending up if he shows improvement in spring training. But if he regresses, he’s done.

Christine: High stakes for everyone. That’s the beauty of baseball.

Jason: It is. And that’s why we watch. Every at-bat matters.

Christine: Let’s talk about the minor leaguers who could impact the big club. Like Chase Hampton.

Jason: Hampton is a prospect. He’s not ready for the majors yet. Give him another year.

Christine: Fair point. Patience is key. What about Andre Pallante’s development?

Jason: Pallante is improving. His command is getting better. He’s becoming a reliable #3 starter.

Christine: That’s huge. A reliable #3 changes the whole dynamic of the rotation.

Jason: It does. And it takes pressure off Hjerpe and the bullpen.

Christine: So, final predictions. Who is the breakout star of 2027?

Jason: JJ Wetherholt. He’s going to steal bases and score runs. He’s underrated.

Christine: I’ll go with Pedro Pages. If he fixes his swing, he’s a star.

Jason: Both are possible. But I’m sticking with Wetherholt. Speed wins games.

Christine: We’ll see. Until then, keep your eyes on the Cardinals.

Christine: That’s it for today! We covered the catcher battle, the infield logjam, and our roster predictions.

Jason: If you learned something new about the Cardinals, please subscribe, rate, and review the show.

Christine: Share this with a fellow Cardinal fan. Let’s get this team back to the playoffs!

Jason: Go Cards!