Cardinals Mailbag: Post-Season Roster Battles & The Walker Projection

St. Louis Cardinals · 2026-10-08 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Christine: If Jordan Walker hits thirty home runs next season, does the St. Louis Cardinals finally break through in the NL Central? We’re answering your mailbag questions on a roster that finished 77-85, and we’ve got some bold predictions for 2027.

Jason: It has been, Christine. A tough one to swallow, finishing fourth in the NL Central behind a Brewers team that won 102 games. But now we look forward. Today, we’re diving into your emails about the catcher situation, the infield depth chart, and whether our young arms can actually stick.

Christine: We’ve got three big things coming up. First, we’re tackling the biggest question on everyone’s mind: who wins the starting catcher job between Leo Bernal, Jimmy Crooks, and Pedro Pages? Second, we’re breaking down the infield battles at third base and shortstop. And third, we’re looking at the pitching staff composition for 2027 and whether we need to add a veteran starter this offseason.

Christine: Let’s get right into it. Sarah from Rochester wrote in with a huge question about the catching hierarchy. She asks: 'With Pedro Pages being the prospect everyone knows, but Leo Bernal having more MLB experience, how do you see the everyday role splitting?' Jason, walk us through the tactical side of this.

Jason: So, Sarah, this is the classic prospect versus proven commodity debate. On paper, Pedro Pages is the future. He’s got the defensive upside and the arm strength that fits the modern catcher profile. But Leo Bernal is already here. He knows the system. He knows the pitchers. In a win-now mode, or even a transition year, Bernal offers immediate stability.

Jason: He is, but he’s not ready for an everyday workload yet. If you put Pages in the lineup daily right now, you risk stunting his growth by forcing him to face elite pitching before he’s fully refined his approach. Bernal might not be the long-term answer, but he’s the bridge. I think we see Bernal taking the majority of starts in early 2027, with Pages getting significant time as the platoon partner against lefties.

Jason: Crooks is the wild card. He’s got power, but his defense needs work. I see him as a DH option or a late-inning defensive replacement if they need to protect a lead. He’s not winning the starting job over Bernal unless Pages struggles significantly in camp.

Christine: Okay, moving on to another fan question. Marcus in Denver asks: 'The Cardinals finished 77-85. Given the Brewers’ dominance with 102 wins, is there any hope for an 85-90 win season in 2027 if the catcher role is clarified?'

Jason: Marcus, that’s the million-dollar question. Finishing 77-85 hurts, especially when you’re watching Milwaukee cruise to 102 wins. But let’s look at the positives. We have young talent. We have a rotation that showed flashes. The key is consistency. If we secure a stable everyday catcher and Jordan Walker hits those 30 home runs we talked about last week, then yes, 85-90 wins is very realistic.

Christine: Right, and remember, the Brewers aren’t going to drop that win total easily. They’ve got Jacob Misiorowski leading the majors in ERA, strikeouts, and opponents' batting average. That’s historic stuff. How do the Cardinals plan to compete with that kind of pitching dominance?

Jason: You don’t beat Misiorowski with one thing. You beat him with volume. You need your outfielders to get on base. You need your bullpen to keep the game close. The Cardinals need to improve their OBP. If Walker gets to 30 homers, that changes the leverage in half the games. It forces opposing managers to use their best relievers earlier.

Christine: So, the takeaway is: stabilize the backstop, empower Walker, and watch the run support. Let’s move to Segment Two. We’ve got questions about the infield depth chart. Tyler from Chicago asks: 'With Masyn Winn at shortstop and JJ Wetherholt at second, who wins the third base job? Is it Nolan Gorman, Blaze Jordan, or Cesar Prieto?'

Jason: Tyler, this is a fascinating battle because it’s not just about who hits best. It’s about versatility. Masyn Winn and JJ Wetherholt are both young, dynamic players. At third base, Nolan Gorman has the most MLB experience and the power stroke. But Blaze Jordan has shown immense promise in limited action. Cesar Prieto is the defensive specialist.

Jason: I think Jordan will push him hard. Gorman is coming off a season where he had to adjust to a new role. Jordan is hungry. But Gorman’s ability to handle different pitching types gives him the edge initially. I see Gorman starting the year, but Jordan could be the guy who takes over by July if he keeps up that hot start.

Jason: Jordan Walker is the centerpiece. We predicted he’d hit 30 home runs last week, and I stand by that. If he improves his launch angle, he becomes a force. Pereira is the defensive jewel in center field, but he needs to show more consistency at the plate. Baez is the utility piece, someone who can fill in anywhere.

Christine: Okay, before we jump into our final segment, I want to take a quick moment to talk to you, our listeners. If these daily breakdowns are part of your morning routine or commute, a small tip is what keeps them coming. Your support helps us bring you this content for free every single day. Please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. Thank you for keeping the Beatline alive.

Christine: Welcome back. Let’s get into our fun hypothetical. @CardinalsFan99 asks: 'If the Cardinals could only sign one free agent this offseason—a veteran starter or a reliable reliever—who do you pick and why?'

Jason: @CardinalsFan99, great question. This goes back to what we said yesterday. I’d pick the veteran starter. Why? Because the bullpen has guys like Ryne Stanek, Matt Svanson, and Cade Winquest who are solid, but the rotation needs a true ace to anchor it. Guys like Cooper Hjerpe and Andre Pallante are promising, but adding a veteran presence would elevate the whole staff.

Christine: I agree. A top-of-the-line starter changes the tone of the season. Now, let’s do a lightning round. Quick takes on these topics. First: Brice Turang’s clutch hitting against the Cardinals. What did you make of his performance?

Jason: Painful to watch. Turang went 3-for-3 with a two-run homer and a tiebreaking single. He was clutch. It shows exactly why Milwaukee is the team to beat in the NL Central. Their offense can explode in a hurry.

Christine: Second: Jacob Misiorowski’s historic Cy Young push. Leading the majors in ERA, K’s, and opponents' batting average. Is he the clear favorite?

Jason: Absolutely. He’s been brilliant. Allowing two hits in 5 1/3 shutout innings in the finale was the cherry on top. Fourth pitcher since 1950 to do that triple crown feat. He’s not just a Cy Young candidate; he’s the winner.

Christine: Third and final quick take: The ABS challenge system. How important is that for umpire accountability moving forward?

Jason: Huge. It adds transparency. Fans and teams can track who is challenging, who is winning, and how umpires are performing. It’s a step in the right direction for the game.

Christine: Alright, that’s our mailbag! We covered the catcher battle, the infield depth, and the path to 85-90 wins. Remember, subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you get your podcasts. Share this episode with a fellow Cardinal fan.

Jason: Keep your eyes on Jordan Walker’s launch angle. If he adjusts, we’re in for a special year. Go Birds!

Christine: From the Beatline Podcast Network, I’m Christine, along with Jason. Thanks for listening!