Cardinals Power Rankings: 4th in NL Central, Looking Ahead

St. Louis Cardinals · 2026-10-06 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Christine: It’s a brutal reality check for the St. Louis faithful. Fourth place in the NL Central. A 77-85 record that feels heavier than just numbers on a page. But before we dig into the power rankings, let me get you right where you need to be.

Christine: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, America’s number one daily sports podcast. I’m Christine, and alongside me as always is our lead analyst, Jason. Good morning, everyone!

Jason: Morning, Christine. And good morning to all the Cardinal fans tuning in from St. Louis and beyond. It’s October 6th, and while the playoffs are wrapping up elsewhere, we’re looking at the Silver Linings for MLB’s non-playoff teams. Today, we’re doing a deep dive into your Cardinals’ power rankings.

Christine: That’s right. We’ve got three big things for you today. First, we’re breaking down exactly where St. Louis stands in the NL Central hierarchy with that 77-85 finish. Second, we’re identifying the biggest strengths—and the glaring question marks—on this roster. And third, we’re giving you a realistic outlook and win projection for the 2027 season. Jason, we talked about Jacob Misiorowski’s historic ERA title last week, but today it’s about us.

Jason: Exactly. And speaking of helping keep this show running every single day, I want to take a quick second to ask for your support. If you love hearing deep dives like this, please consider chipping in via the link in the episode description. Your contribution directly funds the daily research, the editing, and keeps the feed free for everyone. It really helps us stay sharp for you.

Christine: Thank you so much. That means the world to us. Now, let’s get into it. Segment One: Where do the Cardinals rank in their division? Because finishing fourth isn’t just a footnote; it’s a statement about where this team is right now.

Jason: Well, Christine, when you look at the NL Central, the gap between first and fourth is massive. You had the Milwaukee Brewers sitting at 102-59, dominating the division. Then you have the Cardinals at 77-85. That’s a 25-win deficit. In baseball terms, that’s an eternity.

Christine: Twenty-five wins. That’s not a competitive miss; that’s a rebuild in progress. When we look at the standings, how does this 77-85 performance compare to recent years? Does it feel like a step back or just... stagnation?

Jason: It feels like a step back in terms of competitiveness, even if the core pieces are young. Remember, they finished 77-85. The offense struggled to string together consistent production. Look at the final series against Milwaukee. They got swept. Brice Turang hit a go-ahead two-run homer for the Brewers’ 102nd win. Then earlier in that series, Turang delivered a tiebreaking two-run single in the eighth inning. Those are clutch plays by the opponent that highlight defensive lapses and late-inning struggles for St. Louis.

Christine: Right, those late-inning collapses are painful. So, ranking-wise, they are firmly in fourth. But who was ahead of them? Who were the other teams in the mix? Did the Pirates or Cubs make a push that pushed the Cards down?

Jason: The brief highlights the Brewers as the clear favorite at 102-59. The Cardinals were 77-85, fourth in the NL Cent. Without specific data on the third-place team’s exact record in this snapshot, we know the Cardinals were outpaced. The key takeaway is the divergence. The top of the division was elite, led by Milwaukee’s historic 102 wins. The bottom half was a struggle for consistency.

Christine: So, in terms of power rankings within the division, they are dead last. No debate there. But let’s pivot. Every team has something to offer. What are the actual strengths here? We know the pitching staff had some moments, specifically with Jacob Misiorowski leading the majors in ERA, strikeouts, and opponents' batting average. But he’s on Milwaukee. How does that impact St. Louis’ own pitching evaluation?

Jason: It’s ironic, isn’t it? Their rival has the Cy Young candidate, Misiorowski, who allowed just two hits in 5 1/3 shutout innings in the finale. For St. Louis, the strength lies in the depth of their young arms. Look at the rotation: Cooper Hjerpe, Hunter Dobbins, Kyle Leahy, Andre Pallante, Quinn Mathews. That’s six starters right there. The bullpen also has plenty of options: Justin Bruihl, Ryan Fernandez, Gordon Graceffo, Ryne Stanek, Matt Svanson. The infrastructure is there. The talent pool is deep.

Christine: Okay, so the *potential* strength is the youth movement in the rotation. But potential doesn’t win games in September. Let’s talk about the question marks. We mentioned the offensive inconsistency earlier. Who is actually carrying the bat? Is it Jordan Walker? Masyn Winn? Or is the lineup too wide open?

Jason: The biggest question mark is definitely offensive identity. You have Alec Burleson at first base, Nolan Gorman and Blaze Jordan at third, JJ Wetherholt at second, and Masyn Winn at shortstop. It’s a lot of young, developing infielders. And in the outfield, you’ve got Everson Pereira, Jordan Walker, Nathan Church, Joshua Baez. It’s crowded. The problem is, without a consistent middle-of-the-order threat, the pitching staff gets exposed. Like in that 8-4 loss to Milwaukee where Turang had three hits. The defense couldn’t hold the line, and the offense couldn’t respond.

Christine: That 8-4 game stings. So, if I’m a fan listening, what should I be worried about most? Is it the lack of power? The lack of OBP? Or is it just that nobody is stepping up consistently? We talked about Jordan Walker hitting 30 home runs last week. Does he look like that guy yet?

Jason: Walker is the focal point. Last week we predicted he could hit 30 if he improved his launch angle. He’s still working on it. The issue with the entire lineup is plate discipline. You see guys swinging at pitches outside the zone because there’s no one to fear. If Ivan Herrera can catch the pitching staff and keep them disciplined, maybe the hitters can find rhythm. But right now, the catcher position itself is a question mark. Leo Bernal, Jimmy Crooks, Pedro Pages. Who is the everyday guy? Until that’s settled, the pitchers don’t have a clear voice behind the plate.

Christine: Pedro Pages. We haven’t seen enough of him yet. And that’s the issue. You have these tools—Masyn Winn’s speed, Walker’s power—but they aren’t clicking. So, moving into Segment Three, we need to look forward. Realistic outlook. Win projection for 2027. Last week we said 85 wins. Do we stick with that, or do we adjust based on this 77-85 reality?

Jason: I think we adjust slightly upward, but cautiously. 85 wins is a solid baseline if the health holds. The starting rotation is young and improving. Hjerpe and Dobbins are still growing. If the front office targets a veteran starter or a reliable reliever in the offseason—as we discussed previously—they can stabilize the bullpen. Matt Svanson and Ryne Stanek are good, but they need help. A mid-tier veteran arm could bridge the gap.

Christine: So, 85 to 88 wins? That sounds reasonable. It’s not a playoff year, but it’s a step above the 77 wins they just posted. What about the offense? If Walker hits 30, does that change the math significantly? Or is the rest of the lineup too weak to capitalize on his power?

Jason: If Walker hits 30, it adds 15-20 wins to the team’s total. That puts them firmly in the 90-win range. But it requires the guys around him to improve. Masyn Winn needs to get on base. JJ Wetherholt needs to hit for average. The infield defense needs to stop giving away cheap runs. Remember, the Brewers beat them 6-4, 3-2, and 8-4 in that final stretch. Small margins. Fix the defense, improve the OBP, and yes, you can project 90 wins.

Christine: 90 wins. That’s the target. It’s achievable if the pieces fit. But it requires patience from the fans. We’re talking about a rebuild, not a sprint. What’s the one thing the Cardinals must do this offseason to make that 90-win projection real? Just one move.

Jason: Clarify the catcher role. Get Pedro Pages or whoever wins the job locked in. A stable catcher stabilizes the entire pitching staff. If the pitchers trust the battery, they throw harder, more confidently. It’s the foundation. Without it, the rotation’s potential is wasted.

Christine: So, there you have it. Fourth in the NL Central, 77-85, but with a clear path to 90 wins if the catcher spot is secured and Walker delivers on that power potential. Thanks for joining us on the Beatline Podcast Network. Please subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen. Share this with a fellow Cardinal fan.

Jason: Keep the faith. The young arms are coming. See you tomorrow.

Christine: Let’s Go Cards!