Christine: Imagine a catcher’s mitt slapping leather in an empty stadium. That sound is about to define the St. Louis Cardinals’ next decade.
Jason: It’s not just about who catches the ball, Christine. It’s about who controls the game from behind the plate when the season is on the line.
Christine: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Christine, and this is your daily deep dive into the diamond. I’m joined by Jason, our lead analyst.
Jason: Hey everyone. Today we are looking at the roster battles that will decide the Cardinals' identity for 2027.
Christine: We’ve got three major fights to break down. First, the catcher controversy between Pedro Pages and Jimmy Crooks. Second, the infield logjam at third base with Nolan Gorman, Blaze Jordan, and Cesar Prieto. And third, which relievers survive the chop after a tough 77-85 season.
Jason: Exactly. The Brewers swept us to end the year, but this offseason isn't about regret. It's about building a winner. And it starts with these positional decisions.
Christine: Before we get there, a quick word from me and Jason. If you love this show, please consider supporting us. Your contribution helps fund the daily research, the editing, and keeps this feed running free for all of you. Just click the link in the episode description to help out. Thank you.
Christine: Let’s start with the most critical battle: Catching. We have Pedro Pages, Leo Bernal, and Jimmy Crooks. Who wins the job?
Jason: This is tricky because Pedro Pages has shown flashes of elite offensive potential. His plate discipline is improving, and his ability to hit for power is real.
Christine: But what about defense? Jimmy Crooks has been the defensive anchor. He frames well and controls the strike zone.
Jason: That’s true. In today’s game, defense still matters, especially with a young rotation. But if Pages can continue to develop his bat, he might be the more valuable asset long-term.
Christine: So you’re leaning towards offense over defense here?
Jason: I am. Leo Bernal is solid defensively but lacks the upside. Crooks is safe, but Pages is exciting. The Cardinals need excitement.
Christine: I agree. Pages needs to prove he can handle a full season of catching. If he stumbles, Crooks is the fallback.
Jason: Right. And Ivan Herrera at DH gives them flexibility. They don’t need one guy to do everything.
Christine: So, my prediction: Pages starts spring training, but it’s a competition until August. If he doesn’t produce, they move to Crooks.
Jason: I’d say Pages wins the job outright if he stays healthy. The front office wants to build around his potential.
Christine: Interesting. So Pages is the man. Let’s pivot to the infield. Third base is a mess of talent.
Jason: Nolan Gorman is the incumbent, but his strikeout rate is concerning. Blaze Jordan has raw power, and Cesar Prieto is a defensive specialist.
Christine: Gorman needs to cut down on strikeouts. Can he do it?
Jason: He has to. Otherwise, Jordan Walker taking more time at third might make sense. Or even moving J.J. Wetherholt around more.
Christine: Wetherholt at third? That’s a new look. But his swing-and-miss issues are real too.
Jason: True. This position group is ripe for change. I think Gorman gets demoted or traded unless he shows immediate improvement.
Christine: Agreed. Blaze Jordan feels like the future if he keeps developing his contact skills. Prieto is likely DFA material unless he proves versatile.
Jason: Spot on. Depth is key, but quality wins games. And right now, the quality is scattered.
Christine: Let’s keep talking about the infield. What about shortstop? Masyn Winn vs. Thomas Saggese.
Jason: Winn is the starter. No question. Saggese is depth. But Winn’s defense needs to stay sharp.
Christine: Winn is exciting. He brings speed and energy. But can he sustain it?
Jason: He has to. The Cardinals need that spark. Without it, the lineup feels stagnant.
Christine: Okay, so Winn is set. But third base is wide open. Let’s move to Segment 2.
Christine: Segment Two: Outfield and Pitching Depth. Who makes the cut in left and right field?
Jason: Jordan Walker is locked in at right. Everson Pereira is intriguing at center, but Nathan Church has experience.
Christine: Pereira’s defense is a question mark. Church is safer. But Walker at first or right could be huge.
Jason: Walker at first opens up RF for someone else. But let’s stick to the brief. Pereira vs. Church in CF.
Christine: I think Pereira wins the job. Young teams need youth. But Victor Scott II is a factor too.
Jason: Scott is a speedster. Good for pinch-running. But Pereira has more pop. The Cardinals need pop.
Christine: What about left field? Joshua Baez, Jose Fermin, Bryan Torres.
Jason: Baez is the favorite. He’s young, athletic, and showed promise. Fermin is a backup option. Torres is depth.
Christine: Baez needs to improve his batting average. Can he?
Jason: He has to. Plate discipline is key. If he can’t make contact, he’s a bench player.
Christine: Okay, so Baez starts. Now, the bullpen. It’s chaotic. Justin Bruihl, Ryan Fernandez, Gordon Graceffo, Ryne Stanek.
Jason: Stanek is the veteran leader. He provides stability. But his performance has been inconsistent.
Christine: Graceffo has high velocity. Is he ready for a bigger role?
Jason: He’s trending up. If he keeps his command, he could be a setup man. Bruihl is also promising.
Christine: Fernandez is risky. High risk, high reward. Do they trust him?
Jason: They should. He’s young and hungry. The Cardinals need hunger in the bullpen.
Christine: So Stanek for closure, Graceffo for setup, and Fernandez for middle relief?
Jason: That’s the plan. But Matt Svanson and Cade Winquest are also in the mix. Don’t count them out.
Christine: Winquest has been solid. He’s a safe bet. Svanson is the wild card.
Jason: Svanson needs to find his slider. Without it, he’s vulnerable.
Christine: Got it. Stanek, Graceffo, Fernandez, Winquest as the core. Others compete for spots.
Jason: Correct. And Hancel Rincon adds depth. He’s reliable.
Christine: Okay, let’s wrap up the pitching. Starting rotation. Cooper Hjerpe, Matthew Liberatore, Andre Pallante.
Jason: Hjerpe is the ace. He’s consistent. Liberatore is the workhorse. Pallante is the swingman.
Christine: What about Hunter Dobbins, Richard Fitts, Chase Hampton, Kyle Leahy, Quinn Mathews, Michael McGreevy, Tekoah Roby?
Jason: Most of those guys are competing for the fifth starter spot or bullpen roles. Dobbins has upside. Fitts is steady.
Christine: Hampton and Leahy are young. Do they get a chance?
Jason: In spring training, yes. But regular season? Maybe not yet. Mathews and McGreevy are also options.
Christine: Roby? He’s had injury issues.
Jason: He’s a project. Unless he’s healthy, he’s unlikely to make the opening day roster.
Christine: So the rotation is Hjerpe, Liberatore, Pallante, Dobbins, and Fitts/Roby for the last spot?
Jason: That’s the projected five. With plenty of competition for the final spot.
Christine: Alright, Segment Three: Roster Cuts. Who’s going home?
Christine: Segment Three: Final Cuts. Who’s staying, who’s going?
Jason: First, the players trending up. Pedro Pages, Jordan Walker, Masyn Winn, Cooper Hjerpe, and Gordon Graceffo.
Christine: Pages is definitely trending up. His bat is too good to ignore.
Jason: And Walker. If he hits 30 homers, he’s untouchable. Remember our prediction from last week?
Christine: Yes! We said Walker would hit 30 home runs next season if he improves his launch angle.
Jason: Exactly. His launch angle needs to be higher. More fly balls. More power.
Christine: Winn is also trending up. His speed creates havoc. And Hjerpe is the clear number one starter.
Jason: Graceffo is the dark horse. If he keeps striking batters out, he’ll be in the bullpen.
Christine: Now, the players trending down. Nolan Gorman, Leo Bernal, and maybe Ryne Stanek?
Jason: Gorman is struggling. His OBP is low. He’s not providing enough value.
Christine: Bernal is defensive-only. In today’s game, that’s not enough unless he’s elite.
Jason: Stanek is inconsistent. He might be traded or released if a cheaper option emerges.
Christine: What about the outfielders? Joshua Baez, Jose Fermin, Bryan Torres?
Jason: Baez is safe. He’s young. Fermin and Torres are fighting for the last spot. Torres might lose it.
Christine: And the pitchers? Hunter Dobbins, Richard Fitts, Chase Hampton, Kyle Leahy, Quinn Mathews, Michael McGreevy, Tekoah Roby?
Jason: Dobbins and Fitts are safe for the rotation battle. Hampton, Leahy, Mathews, McGreevy, Roby are competing for the sixth spot or bullpen.
Christine: Who do you think loses that fight?
Jason: Roby. If he’s not healthy, he’s out. Hampton has the best stuff, so he might sneak in.
Christine: So, final roster projection: Catchers: Pages, Crooks. Infield: Winn, Wetherholt, Gorman/Jordan/Prieto (one spot), Baez/Walker/Fermin/Torres (outfield/infield mix). Pitchers: Hjerpe, Liberatore, Pallante, Dobbins, Fitts, Stanek, Graceffo, Fernandez, Winquest, Rincon, plus two spares.
Jason: That’s a reasonable projection. The key is Gorman’s production and Pages’ development.
Christine: And the Cardinals’ record? We predicted 85 wins last time. Where do they stand now?
Jason: They finished 77-85. Fourth place. But with improvements, they could easily win 85 again. Or more.
Christine: I agree. If Walker hits 30 and Hjerpe dominates, they’re playoff contenders.
Jason: Exactly. The foundation is there. Now they just need to polish it.
Christine: Let’s recap. Catcher battle: Pages vs. Crooks. Infield: Gorman’s future. Bullpen: Stanek, Graceffo, Fernandez. Cuts: Bernal, possibly Gorman.
Jason: And predictions: Walker hits 30 HRs. Cardinals win 85 games. Veterans targeted in offseason.
Christine: Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network! If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, rate, and review us on your favorite platform.
Jason: Share this with a fellow Cardinals fan. Let’s keep the conversation going.
Christine: Remember, the Cardinals are rebuilding. Stay positive. Stay informed.
Jason: One thing. One pitch. One play at a time.
Christine: Go Cards!