Christine: If Jordan Walker fixes his launch angle, you are looking at thirty home runs next season. That is not a hope; that is a mathematical inevitability if the data holds up. We are breaking down exactly how to get there, plus your questions on the bullpen and the catcher room.
Christine: This is the Beatline Podcast Network, America’s number one daily sports podcast. I’m Christine, and I’m joined by Jason. Today is October 4th, 2026, and we are doing a mailbag episode for the St. Louis Cardinals.
Jason: Good morning, Cardinals fans. It’s a heavy day. We finished 77-85, fourth in the NL Central. The Brewers swept us in the final series, and Jacob Misiorowski put up historic numbers against us. But we aren’t just mourning the loss; we’re planning for the future.
Christine: Exactly. And we have three big things coming up. First, we’re answering your questions about the starting rotation and whether the current group can hold up. Second, we’re diving into the infield battles, specifically JJ Wetherholt and Masyn Winn. And third, we’re talking about the catcher depth chart with Leo Bernal and Jimmy Crooks.
Jason: And finally, we’ll look at the ABS challenge system rankings and what they tell us about umpire bias this year. Let’s jump into the mailbag. Sarah from St. Louis asks: "The rotation looks thin. Do we keep Cooper Hjerpe or trade him?"
Christine: Great question, Sarah. Cooper Hjerpe has been a bright spot for a young team. But looking at the roster, we also have Hunter Dobbins, Richard Fitts, Kyle Leahy, Matthew Liberatore, Quinn Mathews, Andre Pallante, Tekoah Roby, and Michael McGreevy. It’s crowded.
Jason: Right. And let’s be clear about the context here. The Cardinals finished 77-85. Fourth place. You don’t trade your best young arm unless you are getting a proven ace back. Hjerpe showed he can eat innings. In a rebuild or retool, you want stability.
Christine: But Jason, remember last week we talked about needing a veteran starter? If Hjerpe is the guy, where does he fit against a lineup like Milwaukee’s?
Jason: He got torched by Turang and Alvarez-type production. But Hjerpe allowed two hits in five and a third shutout innings in the final game of the season. He capped a solid stretch. The issue isn’t Hjerpe’s stuff; it’s the run support. Or lack thereof.
Christine: So, keeping him makes sense. What about Andre Pallante? He’s been inconsistent. Does he stay in the rotation or move to the bullpen?
Jason: Pallante is a swingman. With Justin Bruihl, Ryan Fernandez, Luis Gastelum, Gordon Graceffo, Brycen Mautz, Riley O'Brien, Hancel Rincon, George Soriano, Ryne Stanek, Matt Svanson, and Cade Winquest in the bullpen, you have options. But moving Pallante to the pen doesn’t fix the rotation hole.
Christine: Fair point. So we keep Hjerpe, maybe use Pallante as a long man or spot starter, and then what? @CardinalsFan99 asks: "Who do we target in free agency? A bat or a pitcher?"
Jason: We said it before: a veteran starter or a reliable reliever. The offense was stagnant. Jordan Walker needs help. Ivan Herrera is our DH now, but we need more power from the outfield. Everson Pereira and Jordan Walker in right, Joshua Baez and Jose Fermin in left. It’s young, but it’s not explosive yet.
Christine: Ivan Herrera moving to DH is interesting. He’s a good hitter. But seeing him behind the plate limits our catching depth. We have Leo Bernal and Jimmy Crooks. Are they ready?
Jason: Pedro Pages is still around too. The hierarchy is Pages, then Herrera, then Bernal/Crooks. If Pedro Pages isn’t the everyday catcher, this becomes a logjam. But given the 77-85 record, you don’t panic-buy. You develop.
Christine: Let’s pivot to the infield. Marcus in Chicago asks: "JJ Wetherholt vs. Masyn Winn. Who starts at shortstop in 2027?"
Jason: Masyn Winn is the incumbent. He’s the face of the franchise. But Wetherholt at second base provides incredible depth. Thomas Saggese is also there. This isn’t an either/or. It’s about platoon splits and defensive alignment.
Christine: Winn is a speed threat. Wetherholt is a contact hitter. If the Brewers’ Brice Turang is hitting .300 with 100 RBIs, we need to match that kind of production. Can Winn do it?
Jason: Turang hit a go-ahead two-run homer and a tiebreaking single in that sweep. He had three hits in one game. Winn needs to improve his plate discipline. His OBP was down this year. If he doesn’t, Wetherholt might see more time at second, pushing someone else around.
Christine: So the message to Winn is: get on base. Jason, what about Nolan Gorman at third? He’s been streaky. Blaze Jordan and Cesar Prieto are waiting.
Jason: Gorman is a power hitter. If his launch angle stays low, he’s just making outs. We projected 30 home runs for Walker if he fixes his angle. Gorman needs similar adjustments. Otherwise, he’s a bench player. It’s harsh, but that’s the market.
Christine: Ouch. Alright, let’s take a quick break. We’ll be right back with your questions on the bullpen and a fun hypothetical about the ABS challenge system.
Christine: Welcome back. Before we get to the next round, I need to ask you something directly. If today’s breakdown helped you understand why Jordan Walker’s launch angle matters so much, or if you appreciated the deep dive into the catcher depth chart, please consider supporting the show. Your contribution keeps these daily episodes free for everyone. Just click the link in the episode description.
Jason: It really is about sustainability. We love covering the Cardinals, but we need your help to keep the lights on. Every dollar counts. Thanks for listening.
Christine: Okay, back to the mailbag. Emily from Kansas City asks: "The bullpen was shaky. Who steps up?"
Jason: Ryne Stanek is the closer. He’s the most experienced. But Matt Svanson and Gordon Graceffo have high upside. The problem is consistency. When Turang hit that go-ahead homer, it was because we couldn’t hold the lead.
Christine: Jacob Misiorowski allowed two hits in five and a third shutout innings. He was brilliant. But the offense only scored four runs. Then they lost 8-4 the night before. The inconsistency is killing us.
Jason: That’s the story of 77-85. Good pitching, bad hitting. Or bad pitching, bad hitting. We need offensive consistency. Ivan Herrera at DH helps, but we need more from the middle infield. Masyn Winn and JJ Wetherholt need to produce.
Christine: What about the outfield? Nathan Church and Victor Scott II in center. They’re fast. But do they hit? Everson Pereira in right is the power source. Jordan Walker needs to join him.
Jason: Church and Scott are defensive specialists. If they can’t get on base, they can’t score. The Brewers’ Brice Turang had 100 RBIs. He drives runs. Our guys are striking out too much. Plate discipline is key.
Christine: So, the plan is: keep Hjerpe, trade for a bat, develop Winn, and fix Walker’s angle. Clear. Now, David in Springfield asks: "What’s the deal with the ABS challenge system?"
Jason: The ABS challenge system ranks batters, catchers, teams, and umpires. It tracks strike zone accuracy. If our hitters are getting called out on pitches in the dirt, that hurts our OBP. We need to know if we’re being victimized.
Christine: Interesting. So if the data shows our guys are losing close calls, that explains some of the losses. It’s not just bad luck. It’s systemic.
Jason: Exactly. And if the umpires are biased against left-handed hitters, that affects Joshua Baez and Jose Fermin. We need to adjust. Maybe hit more from the right side. Platoon splits matter.
Christine: Alright, let’s wrap this up with a fun hypothetical. If the Cardinals could trade one piece from the Brewers’ core for a Cardinal prospect, who goes?
Jason: Brice Turang. He’s the engine. He hit the go-ahead single, the two-run homer. He’s clutch. Give me Turang for any of our minor league arms.
Christine: No way! Turang for a kid? I’d take Jacob Misiorowski instead. He led the majors in ERA, strikeouts, and opponents' batting average. He’s a Cy Young contender.
Jason: Misiorowski is elite. But Turang wins games. One run at a time. He’s the difference between 77 wins and 90 wins.
Christine: Okay, lightning round. Last question from @BaseballNerd: "Predictions for 2027."
Jason: Jordan Walker hits 30 home runs. If he improves his launch angle, it’s guaranteed. Also, the Cardinals target a veteran starter in the offseason.
Christine: I agree on Walker. And I think Masyn Winn breaks out as an All-Star. He just needs confidence. Final thought: The Cardinals will finish above .500 next year.
Jason: I’ll go with 85 wins. Same projection as before. It’s realistic. We have the pitching. We just need the bats to wake up.
Christine: There you have it. 85 wins. Jordan Walker with 30 homers. And a new veteran starter. Thank you for joining us on the Beatline Podcast Network. If you enjoyed this mailbag, please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen. Share this episode with a fellow Cardinal fan.
Jason: Keep your launch angles up, folks. See you tomorrow.
Christine: Go Birds!