Cardinals Mailbag: Misiorowski's Historic Season & The Offseason Blueprint

St. Louis Cardinals · 2026-10-03 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Christine: It was a brutal end to the season for St. Louis, but the stories don't stop just because the lights go out in October. We’re talking about Jacob Misiorowski making history, the Brewers sweeping the Cardinals, and exactly what happens next.

Jason: Yeah, it’s a tough pill to swallow going 77-85 and finishing fourth in the NL Central, especially after getting swept by Milwaukee. But there are silver linings here that we need to unpack before we start planning for 2027.

Christine: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we live for the game. I’m Christine, and this is your daily Cardinals mailbag.

Jason: And I’m Jason. Thanks for tuning in, Cardinals fans. Today we’re answering your questions on the rotation, the bullpen, and the future of Jordan Walker.

Christine: Here is what we’ve got coming up: First, we tackle the biggest storyline from the final week—Jacob Misiorowski’s historic achievement. Second, we dive into the catcher battle between Leo Bernal, Jimmy Crooks, and Pedro Pages. And third, we look at the infield depth chart with Nolan Gorman and Masyn Winn. Let’s get right into it.

Christine: Okay, let’s start with a big one from Sarah in St. Louis. She asks: 'With Jacob Misiorowski leading the majors in ERA, strikeouts, AND opponents' batting average, isn't he the clear Cy Young winner? Why is the conversation still open?' This is huge, Jason.

Jason: It is absolutely huge. Misiorowski became just the fourth pitcher since 1950 to lead the majors in all three categories. That is elite stuff. But Cy Young voting isn’t just about stats; it’s about narrative and team success. The Brewers made the playoffs with a 102-59 record. Misiorowski had an incredible season, but his team didn't have the same run as some other contenders.

Christine: Right, and looking at the final games, he allowed two hits in five and a third shutout innings against us on Sunday. That’s dominance. But does the fact that he capped his season against the Cardinals hurt or help his case?

Jason: It helps his case statistically, obviously. You shut down a team in September. But remember, the Brewers were rolling toward 102 wins. Misiorowski was part of that machine. For a Cardinal fan, though, seeing him dismantle our lineup repeatedly is painful. Brice Turang hit a go-ahead homer off our staff later, but Misiorowski was the anchor for Milwaukee all year.

Christine: Let’s pivot to another question, this time from @CardinalCountry99. He wants to know: 'Why did the offense completely collapse against Milwaukee? They scored only four runs in the finale. What was the issue at the plate?'

Jason: Plate discipline was non-existent against Misiorowski. When you face an ace who holds hitters to a low opponents' batting average, you can't chase. We saw it in the sweep. Turang hit a tiebreaking two-run single in the eighth inning on Friday, then a go-ahead two-run homer on Saturday. Our guys were chasing pitches outside the zone.

Christine: It’s frustrating because we know the talent is there. Ivan Herrera is behind the plate, and Jordan Walker has power. But if you can’t put the ball in play against a guy like Misiorowski, you’re not going to win those tight games.

Jason: Exactly. And it wasn't just Misiorowski. On Saturday, Turang’s homer lifted the Brewers over us 3-2. On Friday, he had three hits including that tiebreaking single. The Brewers exploited our weaknesses. It’s a reminder that even when you have young talent like Masyn Winn and JJ Wetherholt, you need veteran composure in high-leverage spots.

Christine: One more from Mike in Kansas City. He asks: 'The headlines mention Yordan Alvarez and Gabriel Moreno winning batting titles. Does that change how the Cardinals should approach their own lineup construction moving forward?'

Jason: It highlights the gap. Alvarez and Moreno are hitting .300-plus territory while we’re struggling for consistency. The Cardinals need hitters who can make contact and drive the ball. Alec Burleson at first base and Nolan Gorman at third need to be more consistent. If the league leaders are hitting like that, we need to raise our floor.

Christine: So, no more slumps. Consistency is key. Alright, let’s move to Segment Two. We’re talking roster battles. David in Springfield sends in a question: 'The catchers are a mess. Leo Bernal, Jimmy Crooks, Pedro Pages—who actually wins the job next year?'

Jason: This is the most critical decision of the offseason. We talked about this recently. Leo Bernal has the defensive upside, but can he handle the pitching staff? Jimmy Crooks is a contact hitter with good speed. Pedro Pages brings raw power but struggles with strikeout rates.

Christine: I think Crooks gives us the best chance to win immediately. His contact skills are reliable. But Bernal has that arm and the potential for growth. If the front office is patient, Bernal might be the long-term answer.

Jason: But patience costs wins. If we need to contend in 2027, Crooks might be the safer bet. Or do they bring in a veteran? Remember, we predicted last week that the Cardinals will target a veteran starter or reliable reliever. Maybe they extend that logic to catching and bring in a seasoned backup to mentor one of these kids.

Christine: That’s a smart move. Bring in a veteran presence. Now, let’s talk infield. Jessica in Florissant asks: 'Masyn Winn and JJ Wetherholt are both young shortstops. Who starts? And where does Nolan Gorman fit if he doesn't improve?'

Jason: Winn is the everyday shortstop. His defense and baserunning are superior. Wetherholt is more of a utility infielder, maybe second base. As for Gorman, if he doesn’t improve his launch angle, he’s stuck in a platoon role. We said earlier that if Walker improves his launch angle, he hits 30 homers. Same logic applies to Gorman. If he can’t drive the ball consistently, he’s not a full-time third baseman.

Christine: Blaze Jordan and Cesar Prieto are also in the mix at third. It’s crowded. The competition will be fierce in spring training. But for now, Winn is the man at short. Gorman needs to step up or move.

Jason: And don’t forget the outfield. Joshua Baez, Nathan Church, Everson Pereira, Jordan Walker. It’s stacked. Walker is the primary right fielder, but Pereira has shown flashes. If Walker can’t find that extra pop in 2027, Pereira could push him for time.

Christine: Alright, let’s head to Segment Three. We’ve got a fun hypothetical and a lightning round. Tom in Cape Girardeau asks: 'If you could trade one current Cardinal for any player in baseball right now, who do you take?'

Jason: Oof. Tough one. If I’m trading someone, I’m probably looking at a rental or a player with declining value. Maybe Andre Pallante? No, he’s valuable. How about... I’d trade for a proven ace. A veteran starter. We need that stability.

Christine: I’d keep everyone. This is a young team. You don’t tear it down yet. But if I had to, I’d swap a lower-tier reliever for a middle-of-the-order bat. Someone like Alvarez or Moreno. We need that offensive punch.

Jason: Agreed. We need to balance the rotation with better offense. Speaking of which, quick fire round. Cooper Hjerpe or Kyle Leahy as the number two starter?

Christine: Hjerpe. His stuff is higher ceiling.

Jason: Ryne Stanek or Justin Bruihl for closer?

Christine: Stanek. Experience matters.

Jason: Leo Bernal or Jimmy Crooks for starting catching duties?

Christine: Crooks. Contact wins games.

Jason: Last one. Did the Cardinals miss the playoffs because of bad luck or bad management?

Christine: Bad luck. The Brew Crew was just too good. Turang’s homer, Misiorowski’s shutouts. They played perfect baseball.

Jason: Fair point. But we control our own destiny next year. And that brings me to something important for you, the listeners.

Christine: If today’s breakdown helped you understand the roster better, or if you enjoyed hearing Jason break down those playoff losses, please consider supporting the show. Your contributions keep this network free and daily. Just click the link in the episode description to chip in.

Jason: We appreciate every bit of support. It allows us to keep digging deep into the stats and bringing you the truth about the Cardinals.

Christine: To recap: Misiorowski was historic, the Brewers dominated the sweep, and the Cardinals need to address catching and offense in the offseason. Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen.

Jason: Keep your launch angles high, folks. See you tomorrow.

Christine: Go Birds!