Cardinals Power Rankings: Can St. Louis Rebuild From Fourth?

St. Louis Cardinals · 2026-10-01 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Christine: You’re listening to the Beatline Podcast Network, America’s number one daily sports podcast. I’m Christine.

Jason: And I’m Jason. Welcome back to the Cardinals Daily show, where we break down every pitch, every play, and every playoff hope—or lack thereof.

Christine: Today is October 1st, 2026. The season is officially in the rearview mirror for the St. Louis Cardinals. They finished 77-85, fourth in the NL Central. But before you hit skip, here is the hook: Jordan Walker might be the most important player on this roster next year, but only if he fixes his launch angle. We are breaking down exactly why that matters right now.

Jason: Right. And we’re also looking at how Jacob Misiorowski’s historic season against them defines the gap between Milwaukee and St. Louis, plus a realistic look at what the offseason actually needs to fix.

Christine: So, three things today: First, where the Cards sit in the division hierarchy after that brutal finish. Second, the strength of the young infield versus the glaring holes in the rotation. And third, our power rankings projection for 2027. Let’s dive into Segment One.

Christine: Okay, Jason. We have to talk about the NL Central standings. The Brewers won 102 games. The Cardinals finished 77-85. That is a massive chasm. How do you view that gap when you look at the final week?

Jason: It’s not just a gap; it’s a different level of baseball. You look at the final series, St. Louis went 0-3 against Milwaukee. They got swept. Brice Turang had hits in every single game. He hit a go-ahead two-run homer on Saturday, then a tiebreaking two-run single on Friday. On Sunday, Jacob Misiorowski allowed two hits in 5 1/3 shutout innings.

Christine: That’s devastating. Misiorowski became just the fourth pitcher since 1950 to lead the majors in ERA, strikeouts, and opponents' batting average. The Cardinals couldn’t even put a runner on base against him.

Jason: Exactly. And that tells you everything about the division context. The Brewers aren’t just good; they are elite. St. Louis finished fourth because they simply lacked the offensive firepower to keep up with teams like Milwaukee, who secured their first-place finish with that 102nd win.

Christine: But let’s look at the Cardinals’ internal metrics. 77 wins isn’t terrible for a rebuilding team, but it’s disappointing for an organization with this much history. Where did they lose the games?

Jason: They lost them in close games. Look at the scorelines. Saturday, they lost 3-2. Friday, they lost 8-4. Sunday, they lost 6-4. Those 3-2 losses? Those are one-run games. That suggests their bullpen wasn’t closing out leads, or their offense was leaving runners stranded in high-leverage spots.

Christine: We talked about injuries earlier in the week. Masyn Winn and Joey Ortiz were key pieces missing from the lineup. Without your starting shortstop and second baseman, does that explain the 77-win ceiling?

Jason: It explains a lot. When you lose your defensive anchors in the middle infield, your pitchers have to work harder. It affects their confidence. If you’re throwing a fastball and you know there’s a hole behind you, you change your approach. That leads to more hits allowed. Misiorowski capitalized on that vulnerability perfectly.

Christine: So, in terms of power rankings within the division, St. Louis is firmly in fourth. But is there any silver lining? Because ESPN headlines are already talking about 'silver linings for non-playoff teams.'

Jason: There is. The youth movement is real. Alec Burleson at first base, Masyn Winn when healthy, JJ Wetherholt at second. This core is young. They didn’t lose because they lacked talent; they lost because they lacked experience and depth. In a five-year window, this fourth-place finish is a necessary step.

Christine: I agree. But for the fans sitting in the stands right now, watching the Brewers celebrate, it probably feels like a failure. We’ll come back after this break with the biggest strengths and question marks of this roster.

Christine: Stick with us.

Christine: Welcome back. We are in Segment Two: Strengths and Question Marks. Jason, let’s start with the positives. What worked for St. Louis in 2026?

Jason: The outfield defense and the potential of Jordan Walker. Walker has been developing for years, but last season showed flashes of All-Star capability. If he can improve his launch angle, he projects for 30 home runs. That kind of power from right field is rare and valuable.

Christine: And what about the pitching staff? We have Cooper Hjerpe, Kyle Leahy, Andre Pallante. Is the rotation a strength?

Jason: It’s a mix. Hjerpe has been excellent. He’s got that elite stuff. But looking at the full roster, you see names like Justin Bruihl, Ryan Fernandez, Ryne Stanek in the bullpen. The bullpen usage was inconsistent. When you look at the ABS challenge system tracker, the Cardinals weren’t among the top teams in catching efficiency or batter resistance. That points to a lack of strategic sharpness.

Christine: Let’s talk about that catcher position. We’ve discussed Leo Bernal, Jimmy Crooks, and Pedro Pages. Who is the future there?

Jason: Pedro Pages showed promise, but Ivan Herrera at DH provides some offensive stability. The issue is that the catchers aren’t providing enough defensive value to mask the pitching inconsistencies. If your catcher can’t frame pitches well, your starters get called for balls in the zone more often.

Christine: Right. And then there’s the big question mark: Third Base. You have Nolan Gorman, Blaze Jordan, Cesar Prieto. It’s crowded, but is it productive?

Jason: Nolan Gorman has power, but his strikeout rate is always a concern. Blaze Jordan is still developing. The problem is platoon splits. If you’re relying on left-handed hitters against left-handed pitching, and your bench doesn’t have the right matchups, you stall out. That’s exactly what happened against the Brewers. They couldn’t solve Misiorowski’s command.

Christine: So, the biggest weakness is clearly offensive consistency against elite pitching. And the biggest strength is the young infield defense and Walker’s power potential. Does that mean the Cardinals need to target a veteran starter in free agency?

Jason: Absolutely. We predicted this last week. With payroll flexibility from missing the playoffs, they should be aggressive. They need a reliable arm who can eat innings so guys like Hjerpe and Leahy don’t burn out. A veteran starter would stabilize the whole rotation.

Christine: Before we move to our outlook, I want to take a quick moment. If you love this show and want to help keep it running daily without ads, please consider supporting us. Your contribution directly funds the research, editing, and production that brings you these deep dives every morning. Just check the link in the episode description. Thank you so much.

Christine: Thanks for the support, everyone. Now, Segment Three: Realistic Outlook and Win Projection. Jason, where do the Cardinals stand in the overall MLB power rankings right now?

Jason: They’re likely in the bottom third of the league. 77 wins puts them around the 25th to 30th spot. Not quite the worst, but definitely not competitive for October baseball this year. The gap to the Brewers—102 wins—is too wide to bridge with minor tweaks.

Christine: So, what’s the projection for 2027? Are we looking at another 77-win team, or can they climb?

Jason: If they sign a veteran starter and Walker hits those 30 homers, I see 85 to 88 wins. That gets them into the Wild Card conversation, but probably not the division title. The Brewers are too strong. The Cardinals need to focus on beating teams like Pittsburgh or Cincinnati more consistently.

Christine: That sounds reasonable. 85 wins is a solid rebound year. It keeps the fanbase engaged and sets up a strong foundation for the young guys. But what about the bullpen? Do they need to add relief help?

Jason: Yes. Ryne Stanek and Matt Svanson are decent, but the setup roles were shaky. If they can find a reliable closer or a high-leverage reliever, that stabilizes the late innings. Remember, those 3-2 losses came down to the wire. Fixing the bullpen fixes the close games.

Christine: So, my prediction: The Cardinals will finish fifth in the division again, but they’ll make a Wild Card run if Walker stays healthy and the new starter performs. What’s your take?

Jason: I’ll go with a Wild Card berth. 88 wins. It’s optimistic, but if the front office executes the offseason correctly, it’s possible. The talent is there; it just needs better management and slightly better health.

Christine: Alright, let’s recap. The Cardinals finished 77-85, fourth in the NL Central, swept by the Brewers in the final series. Jordan Walker is the key to next year’s success, and the team needs a veteran starter and bullpen help. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network.

Jason: If you enjoyed this breakdown, please subscribe, rate, and review us. It helps other fans find the show. Share it with a friend who loves the Cards.

Christine: Until next time, keep your faith alive. Go Cards Go!