Cardinals Roster Battles: Catcher Clash & Bullpen Questions

St. Louis Cardinals · 2026-09-30 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Christine: Pedro Pages is the starting catcher, or maybe he isn’t. The St. Louis Cardinals finished 77-85, fourth in the NL Central, and while the standings are set, the real drama is happening right now on the depth chart. We are talking about who stays, who goes, and who earns a spot in 2027.

Jason: It’s a fascinating time to be a Cardinals fan because the playoff hopes are gone, but the future is very much alive. We’ve got three major position groups up for grabs this episode.

Christine: Here is what we are covering today. First, the battle behind the plate between Pedro Pages, Leo Bernal, and Jimmy Crooks. Second, the infield logjam at third base involving Nolan Gorman, Blaze Jordan, and Cesar Prieto. And third, we look at the bullpen arms fighting for the final roster spots. I’m Christine惕, you’re listening to the Beatline Podcast Network.

Jason: And I’m Jason. Thanks for tuning in. It’s September 30th, 2026. The season is over, but the work isn’t done. Let’s dive into Segment One.

Christine: Okay, Jason. Let’s start with the most visible battle. Catcher. You have Pedro Pages as the incumbent, but we also have Leo Bernal and Jimmy Crooks in the mix. How do you see this shaking out?

Jason: Well, Christine, if you look at the roster construction, Pedro Pages has the edge simply because of his offensive upside. He’s young, he’s got power, and he fits the modern catcher profile better than a pure defender. But it’s not a lock.

Christine: Right. And Leo Bernal? He’s been there longer. Is he just a veteran presence now, or does he have a legitimate shot to win the job back?

Jason: Bernal is a defensive specialist. If the team prioritizes pitch framing and game-calling above all else, he could take some starts. But against a guy like Jimmy Crooks, who brings more bat-to-ball skills, Bernal is fighting an uphill battle for everyday playing time.

Christine: So, Crooks is the wild card here? He wasn’t mentioned much during the regular season headlines.

Jason: Exactly. In fact, looking at the ABS challenge system tracker, which ranks catchers throughout the season, Crooks showed promise in limited action. If the Cardinals want to keep Ivan Herrera healthy as a DH option, they need a catcher who can hit. That points to Pages or Crooks.

Christine: I agree. My guess? Pages starts, Crooks gets a long look in spring training, and Bernal might be traded or designated if they bring in another veteran arm. What about the infield? This is where it gets messy.

Jason: The third base situation is tricky. You have Nolan Gorman, who is under contract and has shown flashes of power. Then you have Blaze Jordan and Cesar Prieto coming up through the minors. Gorman’s strikeout rate has always been a concern, but his exit velocity is elite.

Christine: But wait, didn’t we talk about injuries earlier? Masyn Winn and Joey Ortiz were key pieces of that infield defense. Without them, how does that change the equation at third?

Jason: That’s a huge factor. With Winn and Ortiz hurt, the Cardinals had to shuffle things around. Gorman moved around a bit, but it exposed some defensive liabilities. If they want to improve their fielding percentage, they might need to look at Prieto, who is more of a polished defender.

Christine: So, is Gorman’s job actually in jeopardy? Or is he just stuck in the middle?

Jason: He’s stuck. He’s too expensive to cut, but not good enough to be untouchable. I think he’ll start at third, but if Blaze Jordan shows dominance in the Arizona Fall League, Gorman could be moved by trade deadline next year.

Christine: Interesting. So, Gorman is a trade candidate rather than a core piece. That changes how we view the offseason moves. Now, let’s move to Segment Two. The outfield and second base depth.

Jason: Let’s talk about the outfield. You have Jordan Walker in right, Everson Pereira in left, and Nathan Church in center. But then you’ve got Joshua Baez, Jose Fermin, Bryan Torres, and Victor Scott II pushing for minutes.

Christine: Jordan Walker was a big topic last week. Remember, Jason, you predicted he’d hit 30 home runs if he improved his launch angle. Where do you stand on that now that the season is over?

Jason: I still believe in him. His raw power is undeniable. But 30 home runs requires consistency. He needs to stop chasing pitches in the dirt. If he can improve his plate discipline and OBP, he becomes a top-tier corner outfielder.

Christine: What about the other guys? Jose Fermin seems like the utility man. Can he hold down a starting spot in left?

Jason: Fermin is a contact hitter. He won’t hit 20 home runs, but he won’t strike out much either. He’s a great platoon option against left-handed pitching. But as a full-time starter? I doubt it unless Walker or Pereira struggle significantly.

Christine: And what about JJ Wetherholt at second base? He’s young, but Thomas Saggese is also on the roster. Who wins the job?

Jason: Wetherholt has the higher ceiling. He’s a toolsy player. Saggese is more of a safety valve. Unless Wetherholt hits a wall defensively, he’s the everyday second baseman. The Cardinals need that offensive punch from the keystone.

Christine: So, Wetherholt is the guy. Got it. Now, let’s get into the trenches. Segment Three. The bullpen. This is where the Cardinals made some interesting moves, but also where they might need help.

Jason: Right. The bullpen list is deep. You have Ryne Stanek, Matt Svanson, Cade Winquest, Gordon Graceffo, Justin Bruihl, Ryan Fernandez, Luis Gastelum, Brycen Mautz, Hancel Rincon, and George Soriano. That’s ten arms. They can’t all stay.

Christine: Stanek is the clear closer. Svanson has the high-leverage stuff. Who are the odds-on favorites to make the roster?

Jason: Winquest and Graceffo are intriguing. Winquest has velocity, and Graceffo has command. I think one of those two joins Stanek and Svanson in the late-inning roles. The others will likely be sent to Triple-A or released.

Christine: What about the starters? Hunter Dobbins was mentioned last week as a potential roster contender upon return from IL. Where does he fit?

Jason: Dobbins is still a question mark. With Cooper Hjerpe, Kyle Leahy, Andre Pallante, Matthew Liberatore, Quinn Mathews, Richard Fitts, and Tekoah Roby already in the mix, Dobbins might be competing for a fifth starter spot. But if he’s not 100%, he could end up in the bullpen.

Christine: So, Liberatore is safe? We talked about his efficiency last week.

Jason: Liberatore is safe. He’s established himself as a reliable mid-rotation arm. The competition is really among the younger guys. I expect the Cardinals to be aggressive in free agency, as we discussed, to bolster both the rotation and the bullpen.

Christine: Before we wrap up, I want to ask our listeners for a quick favor. This show is completely free, with no ads and no paywall. That’s only possible because of supporters like you. If you enjoy our daily analysis, please chip in via the link in the episode description. Your support keeps us independent and helps us keep bringing you this content every single day.

Jason: Thanks for listening. To recap: Pages wins the catching job, Gorman is a trade candidate, and the bullpen will see significant churn. Subscribe, rate, and review wherever you listen.

Christine: We’ll be back tomorrow with more Cardinals coverage. Go Birds!