Cardinals Mailbag: Misiorowski's Masterclass, Roster Battles & What’s Next

St. Louis Cardinals · 2026-09-29 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Christine: You are not going to believe what just happened in Milwaukee. A six-run lead, a dominant pitching performance from the opposition, and a Cardinals offense that simply went silent when it mattered most.

Jason: It was a brutal ending to a tough season for St. Louis. Jacob Misiorowski didn't just beat them; he dismantled their lineup with five and a third shutout innings, allowing only two hits.

Christine: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, America's number one daily sports podcast. I'm Christine, and joining me is Jason. We are live on September 29th, 2026.

Jason: That's right. The Cardinals finish 77-85, fourth in the NL Central. It’s a season of missed opportunities, but today we’re looking at the silver linings, the roster battles, and answering your mailbag questions.

Christine: Here is what we have coming up: First, we break down that final loss to the Brewers and why Masyn Winn’s absence was felt so deeply. Second, we dive into the infield depth chart with JJ Wetherholt and Nolan Gorman. And third, a fun hypothetical about who takes over if injuries strike again.

Jason: We also look at how the front office might use their payroll flexibility now that they aren't competing for a playoff spot. Let’s get into it.

Christine: Let's start with Segment One, where we tackle the biggest storylines from this week's series against Milwaukee. Marcus in Denver writes in asking about that final game. He says, 'The Brewers won 6-4, but Misiorowski was untouchable. Did the Cardinals have any chance once he settled in?'

Jason: Honestly, no. Misiorowski is having a historic year. He’s one of only four pitchers since 1950 to lead the majors in ERA, strikeouts, and opponents' batting average. When you face that kind of stuff, you need perfect execution.

Christine: Right, and St. Louis didn't have that. They were dealing with injuries to Joey Ortiz and Cooper Pratt earlier in the week, which disrupted the defensive alignment. By Sunday, the lineup was already compromised.

Jason: Exactly. You had Masyn Winn out, too. His absence changes everything about how you construct an at-bat. Without his speed on the bases or his contact ability, the pressure falls on guys like Alec Burleson and Jordan Walker to drive the ball.

Christine: Burleson was chasing RBI titles all year, but he couldn't get anything going against Misiorowski. Sarah from Rochester asks, 'Is this offensive struggle a team-wide issue or just bad luck against elite pitching?' She notes they lost three straight to the Brewers.

Jason: It’s both. But fundamentally, it’s a plate discipline issue. Against a pitcher like Misiorowski, you can’t chase strikes outside the zone. The Cardinals looked hesitant. That hesitation leads to weak contact or strikeouts.

Christine: And let's not forget Brice Turang’s go-ahead homer in the Saturday game. That was the dagger. It showed how efficient Milwaukee was offensively while St. Louis struggled to string hits together.

Jason: Turang finished with 100 RBIs, a massive milestone. Meanwhile, the Cardinals' bullpen—Ryne Stanek, Justin Bruihl, Gordon Graceffo—had to work hard in those close games, but they often lacked run support.

Christine: @CardinalsFan88 asks a great question: 'With the season over, should the focus be on developing young arms like Chase Hampton and Kyle Leahy for next year, or keeping the veterans steady?'

Jason: This is where it gets interesting. With a 77-85 record, there’s no penalty for playing kids. Hampton and Leahy are starters. Giving them innings now helps their development. Quinn Mathews and Michael McGreevy are also in the mix.

Christine: I agree. The rotation needs fresh legs. Andre Pallante had some ups and downs, but seeing how these younger guys handle big-league pressure in September is invaluable data for the offseason.

Jason: Plus, it gives the coaches a chance to evaluate who belongs in the long-term plan versus who might be traded. It’s a strategic move for a rebuilding phase.

Christine: So, the priority is clearly evaluation over winning meaningless games. Stick with us, because next we’re diving deep into the infield battles.

Christine: Segment Two: Roster Battles. David in Chicago writes in, 'JJ Wetherholt and Nolan Gorman are both third basemen. Who starts next year if Joey Ortiz doesn't return fully?'

Jason: That’s a tough one. Gorman has power, but Wetherholt offers better contact and defense at second base. If Ortiz is injured, you might see Wetherholt slide over to shortstop, pushing Cesar Prieto around.

Christine: Prieto has been solid, but Wetherholt feels like the future at second. His swing plane is so clean. Do you think Gorman stays at third, or do they move him?

Jason: Gorman is a natural third baseman. His bat is too good to bench. The real question is whether they keep Prieto as a utility guy or shop him. The roster has room for versatility.

Christine: Linda from St. Louis asks about the catchers. 'Pedro Pages vs. Ivan Herrera. Who gets the nod? Pages has been trending up, but Herrera has experience.'

Jason: Pages is the future. His defensive metrics are elite, and his pitch framing is improving rapidly. Herrera is a great backup, but Pages needs to play every day to develop.

Christine: Leo Bernal is also there, but he seems further down the line. It’s clear the Cardinals want Pages to take over the starting role. Does that impact DH usage?

Jason: Probably. If Pages is catching regularly, Herrera might move to DH occasionally to give him rest. Or they could use Ivan Herrera more as a platoon option against left-handed pitching.

Christine: And what about the outfield? Nathan Church and Victor Scott II are both in center field. Bryan Torres in left. Is there a clear winner there?

Jason: Church has the speed, but Scott II has the contact. Torres is a solid defender in left. I think they’ll go with a mix based on matchups. Platoon splits will matter a lot here.

Christine: Jose Fermin is another option in left. The competition is fierce. It’s going to be a fascinating spring training battle.

Jason: Absolutely. Every position player knows they need to impress in October if they want a secure spot next year. There’s no complacency allowed.

Christine: Before we get to our final segment, we need to talk about something important. This show is free, with no ads and no paywall. Listener support is what protects that. Please chip in via the link in the episode description to help keep us running.

Christine: Segment Three: Fun Hypothetical and Lightning Round. Mike in Kansas City asks, 'If Hunter Dobbins returns from the IL tomorrow, does he make the roster?'

Jason: He definitely competes. His athleticism fits the mold of what St. Louis wants. If he’s healthy, he pushes guys like Prieto or even Torres for a utility spot.

Christine: Lightning round! First question: Who wins the NL Central next year? Jason, you pick.

Jason: Milwaukee. They’re 102-59. That’s dominance. The Cardinals have work to do.

Christine: Fair point. Second question: Which Cardinal will hit 30 home runs next season? Alec Burleson or Jordan Walker?

Jason: Walker. His raw power is underrated. If he improves his launch angle, he’s a 30-homer threat.

Christine: Third question: Best rookie call-up for 2027? Chase Hampton or JJ Wetherholt?

Jason: Wetherholt. He’s ready now. Hampton needs more time in the minors.

Christine: Final question: Will the Cardinals be aggressive in free agency given their payroll flexibility?

Jason: They should be. Missing the playoffs means they have space. Expect them to target a veteran starter or a reliable reliever.

Christine: Great answers. Thanks to all our listeners for the questions. We appreciate you tuning in every day.

Christine: To recap: The Cardinals finish 77-85, fourth in the NL Central, after a tough loss to Milwaukee. Misiorowski was unstoppable, and the offense struggled without key players.

Jason: But there are bright spots. Young arms like Hampton and Leahy are gaining experience. The infield battles between Wetherholt, Gorman, and Prieto will be exciting to watch.

Christine: If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, rate, and review us on your favorite platform. Share it with a friend who loves the Cardinals.

Jason: We’ll be back tomorrow with more analysis. Keep supporting the team.

Christine: Go Cards!