Giants Power Rankings: 4th Place, 65 Wins, and the Road to 75

San Francisco Giants · 2026-10-11 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: You are looking at a team that finished with 65 wins. Sixty-five. In the National League West. That is not a playoff team. That is a rebuilding team. And yet, somehow, the story of this season wasn't just about losing—it was about surviving an injury crisis so severe it broke the league record.

Paul: It’s a stark contrast to last year’s hype. We’re talking about a franchise that led MLB in injured list days—2,379 of them. That is a staggering number when you think about the roster churn and the lack of continuity we saw from April to October.

Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network, where we break down the biggest stories in sports every single day. I’m Amanda, and I’m joined by Paul. If you’re new here, or if you’ve been listening since the beginning, grab your coffee and settle in because today we are doing a deep-dive power ranking on the San Francisco Giants.

Paul: Hey everyone. Good to be here. It’s always good to talk Giants, even when the results are tough. We’ve got a lot to unpack today regarding their final standing, their strengths, and where they go from here.

Amanda: Here is what we are covering today. First, we will rank the Giants within the NL West context—they sit fourth, but is that fair? Second, we will look at the real strengths versus the glaring question marks, specifically around that pitching staff. And third, we will give you our realistic win projection for 2027.

Amanda: But before we get into the rankings, I want to take thirty seconds to ask for your help. We do all the daily research, the editing, and keep this feed running every single day. A small contribution through the link in the episode description keeps this show free and allows us to dig deeper for you. Thank you.

Amanda: Let’s jump right into Segment One: Where do the Giants stand? The official record is 65-97. They are fourth in the NL West. On paper, that sounds like a disaster. But let’s look at the context.

Paul: Right. And the headline that defined their divisional struggle wasn’t just losses; it was the health crisis. Leading the majors with 2,379 IL days and 44 placements. The Dodgers finally ended their three-year streak as the worst team in terms of injuries, which means the Giants held that ignominious title all year long.

Amanda: It’s hard to build a winning culture when half your roster is in Omaha. Does finishing fourth feel accurate given that context? Or should they have been worse?

Paul: I think fourth is actually generous in some ways, but also kind in others. Because when guys were healthy, they competed. But you can’t compete consistently when you are turning over your lineup every Tuesday. It destroys chemistry. It destroys timing at the plate.

Amanda: And let’s not forget how the season ended. They lost to the Dodgers in the finale, 5-1. Alex Call had an RBI double in the 10th, Andy Pages hit a three-run homer. It capped off a season where the Giants couldn’t close out games against their division rivals.

Paul: That loss to LA was symbolic. The Dodgers won their 100th game. The Giants finished with 65. That 35-win gap tells you everything about the talent disparity in this division. The Giants are clearly behind Los Angeles, and likely behind San Diego and Arizona too.

Amanda: So, putting a pin in that ranking. Fourth place. Not playoff caliber. But the real story isn’t just the standings—it’s the roster construction. Which brings us to Segment Two: Strengths and Weaknesses.

Paul: Strengths? This is tricky because 'strength' is a strong word for a 65-win team. But if I had to pick one area of hope, it’s the emerging young arms in the rotation. You’ve got Logan Webb still anchoring things, but then you look at Yunior Marte, Miguel Mendez, Anthony Molina, Landen Roupp, Matt Wilkinson.

Amanda: That is a loaded rotation group. Even if some struggled, the depth is there. But what about the bullpen? You listed Tristan Beck, JT Brubaker, Duncan Davitt, Camilo Doval, Jason Foley... that’s a lot of names. Is that a strength or a mess?

Paul: It’s a mess. It’s a logjam. You have Seth Lonsway, Reiver Sanmartin, Carson Seymour, Dylan Smith, Ryan Walker, Cesar Perdomo, Braxton Roxby, Joel Kuhnel. Who is closing? Who is setting up? There is no clarity. Without a clear hierarchy, you lose leverage in late innings.

Amanda: And on the field, we saw struggles. Remember the Pride Night controversy? Buster Posey said the team must learn from handling that situation. It showed a lack of organizational maturity that sometimes bleeds onto the field.

Paul: Right. Off-field issues distract from on-field performance. But back to baseball—let’s talk about the infield. You have Willy Adames at short stop. That is a true strength. Adames is an elite defender and a consistent hitter. He stabilizes the middle infield.

Amanda: Adames is definitely the star. But who is playing second base? Osleivis Basabe, Nate Furman, Marcelo Mayer? It feels like a committee approach rather than a settled starter.

Paul: Exactly. And third base? Brett Harris, Shay Whitcomb. It’s a logjam. Meanwhile, in the outfield, you have Jung Hoo Lee in right field. He provides speed and defensive versatility. Jonah Cox and Drew Gilbert in center. Grant McCray in left. The outfield has more stability than the infield.

Amanda: So, the takeaway: Strong starting pitching depth, elite shortstop in Adames, shaky infield logistics, and a bullpen that needs a complete overhaul. Is that fair?

Paul: Fair. And don’t forget the catchers. Drew Cavanaugh, Andrew Knizner, Zachary Morgan. The catcher competition is wide open heading into next year. That is a huge question mark. Who gets the majority of reps with Webb?

Amanda: We talked about this yesterday! The catcher competition is going to dictate the success of Logan Webb. If he doesn’t have a reliable battery mate, his numbers could slip. Okay, so we know where they stand, and we know the holes. Let’s talk about the future.

Amanda: Segment Three: Realistic Outlook. We projected 75 to 80 wins last week. After seeing the full 65-97 reality, does that projection hold up for 2027?

Paul: I still stand by 75 to 80 wins. Here is why: health. If the Giants stay relatively healthy, that 65 wins becomes 75. You add a veteran starter—which we predicted they would acquire—and you stabilize the bullpen. Those are incremental gains that add up.

Amanda: But wait. What about the offensive production? Bryce Eldridge at DH. Victor Bericoto, Jon Hox, Bo Davidson in the corners. Is that lineup ready to produce 75 wins worth of runs?

Paul: It’s a work in progress. But look at the minor league options. Marcello Mayer is a top prospect. If he makes an impact, or if someone like Christian Koss steps up at short, you get younger, faster defense. Defense wins games in the NL West.

Amanda: So, the strategy is: Get healthy, add a veteran arm, and let the youth develop. No rush to win now, but a solid push for .500 ball.

Paul: Exactly. 75 wins is the floor. If Adames plays like himself, and Webb stays dominant, they could sneak into the 80-win range. But they need to fix that bullpen identity crisis first.

Amanda: So there you have it. The Giants finish fourth, plagued by injuries, but with a foundation of young pitching and elite defense in Adames. We project 75 to 80 wins next season if they stay healthy.

Paul: It’s a rebuild in motion. Focus on the farm system, fix the health, and see where they land. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network.

Amanda: If you enjoyed this breakdown, please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen. It helps more fans find the show. Go Giants!