Giants Roster Battles: Catcher Depth & Infield Logjam

San Francisco Giants · 2026-10-10 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: The season is over, the lights are off at Oracle Park, but for the San Francisco Giants front office, the real work just began. We’re looking at a roster that finished 65-97, fourth in the NL West, and we have to ask: who actually stays? Who goes? And more importantly, where does this team find its identity heading into next year?

Paul: It’s a fascinating time to be a Giants fan because you’re balancing the pain of a 65-win season with the excitement of a massive rebuild. You’ve got Logan Webb anchoring the rotation, but everywhere else, it’s a competition. From the battery behind the plate to the infield logjam, every spot on this roster is up for grabs.

Amanda: That’s right. And before we dive into the positional battles, I want to do a quick shout-out to our listeners. If you enjoy these deep dives, please consider supporting us through the link in the episode description. Your contribution directly funds the daily research, the editing, and keeps this feed running so we can bring you this analysis every single day. Thank you for helping us keep the beatline alive.

Amanda: Today, we’re breaking down three key areas. First, the catcher battle between Drew Cavanaugh, Andrew Knizner, and Zachary Morgan. Second, the infield logjam featuring Willy Adames, Marcelo Mayer, and the rest. And third, we’ll look at the bullpen depth chart and make some roster-cut predictions. Let’s get into it.

Amanda: Let’s start with the most critical position group: catcher. Buster Posey has been vocal about needing stability there. We have Drew Cavanaugh, Andrew Knizner, and Zachary Morgan in the mix. Paul, how do you see this playing out?

Paul: Well, Amanda, it really comes down to what kind of catcher you want to pair with Logan Webb. Cavanaugh brings experience, but he’s coming off a tough season. Knizner is a defensive specialist who can frame pitches well, which is huge for Webb's command. Morgan is the rookie option, raw but high-upside.

Amanda: Right. And remember, Posey mentioned learning from past mistakes regarding leadership and clubhouse culture. Do you think that influences who gets the nod here?

Paul: Absolutely. It’s not just about baseball skills; it’s about being a voice in the dugout. Knizner has that veteran presence. Cavanaugh knows the system inside out. But if they want youth, Morgan is intriguing. I think they’ll likely go with a platoon or a primary/backup dynamic rather than picking one guy to carry the load immediately.

Amanda: So, no clear #1 yet? That feels like a lot of pressure on the pitching coach.

Paul: Exactly. If Webb doesn’t have a consistent partner behind the plate, his ERA could suffer. But given the injuries last year—remember, the Giants led MLB with 2,379 days on the IL—that instability might have already set a precedent. They’re used to dealing with catchers getting hurt.

Amanda: Fair point. The injury toll was historic. But let’s talk offense. Cavanaugh hit better last year than Knizner. Does that swing it?

Paul: Offensively, yes, Cavanaugh is the better bat. But defensively, Knizner protects Webb’s slider better. I think we’ll see them split time until spring training performance dictates otherwise. It’s a classic catch-22.

Amanda: Okay, so the battery remains a question mark. Let’s move to the infield. This is where things get really crowded. Willy Adames is the star, obviously, at shortstop. But then you have Christian Koss also at SS, and Osleivis Basabe, Nate Furman, and Marcelo Mayer at second base.

Paul: It’s a logjam, Amanda. Adames is your everyday starter. He’s proven. Koss is versatile, can play multiple spots, which makes him valuable even if he’s not starting every day. But the real story is the young talent. Marcelo Mayer is a top prospect. If he’s ready, he’s going to push Basabe hard for that second base job.

Amanda: And what about Brett Harris and Shay Whitcomb at third base? Is there room for them too?

Paul: There’s always room if they perform. But realistically, the Giants need to decide if they’re going with youth or veterans at third. Harris has power, Whitcomb has contact. Neither is an automatic starter yet. I think they’ll likely bring in a veteran free agent for stability, as we predicted last week, while letting the kids compete for backup roles.

Amanda: So, Adames locks down SS, Mayer pushes for 2B, and third base is open for competition? That leaves a lot of bodies on the bubble.

Paul: Precisely. And that’s why the roster cuts will be brutal. You can’t keep all those infielders. Someone like Furman or Koss might end up in Triple-A unless they show significant improvement in camp.

Amanda: It’s a tough love approach. But necessary for building a winner. Let’s shift gears to the outfield. We have Jung Hoo Lee, Drew Gilbert, Jonah Cox, Grant McCray, Victor Bericoto, and Bo Davidson. Who stands out?

Paul: Jung Hoo Lee is the centerpiece. He’s a five-tool player with elite speed and defense. If he stays healthy, he’s an All-Star candidate. Gilbert and Cox are solid defenders too. McCray has power but needs to refine his strike zone. Bericoto and Davidson are more fringe options.

Amanda: So Lee is your clear #1. But what about the other two spots? It seems like a battle between Gilbert and Cox.

Paul: I’d lean toward Gilbert. He’s got more experience and can handle center field. Cox is great defensively but his bat hasn’t consistently shown up against major league pitching. So, Lee in Left, Gilbert in Center, and maybe a platoon in Right depending on who performs best in spring training.

Amanda: And Bryce Eldridge at DH? He’s got power, but does he stick?

Paul: Eldridge is a project. He strikes out a lot. He’ll probably start in Triple-A unless he hits well in camp. The Giants need contact hitters, not just power threats, given their overall offensive struggles last year.

Amanda: Okay, so we’ve covered the core positions. Now, let’s talk about the bullpen. This is where the Giants were weakest last year. You’ve got Camilo Doval as the closer, but behind him, it’s a mess. Tristan Beck, JT Brubaker, Duncan Davitt, Jason Foley, Trent Harris, Sam Hentges, Joel Kuhnel, Seth Lonsway, Cesar Perdomo, Braxton Roxby, Reiver Sanmartin, Carson Seymour, Dylan Smith, and Ryan Walker.

Paul: That’s a long list! Doval is your setup man/closer, but the rest are mostly minor leaguers or unproven arms. Ryan Walker has some big league experience. Beck and Brubaker are former starters trying to make the transition. Hentges and Sanmartin are rookies with potential.

Amanda: So, essentially, the Giants need to acquire several relievers in the offseason?

Paul: Absolutely. You can’t build a playoff team with that much uncertainty in the pen. They’ll likely target a few veteran relievers to stabilize the back end. Doval needs help, and a lot of these guys will be non-tendered or traded.

Amanda: That’s a lot of work for the front office. But it’s exciting because it means there’s opportunity for the young guys to step up if they impress.

Paul: Exactly. Spring training will be critical. Watch for Hentges and Sanmartin to stand out. If they dominate, they could force their way onto the roster.

Amanda: Alright, let’s wrap up Segment 1 with a quick prediction. Who wins the closer job?

Paul: Doval. He’s the proven commodity. But don’t be surprised if someone like Walker or Beck takes over later in the season if Doval struggles.

Amanda: Got it. Doval holds the job, but watch for competition. Thanks, Paul. Coming up, we’ll dive deeper into the infield logjam and make some specific roster cut predictions. Don’t go anywhere.

Amanda: We’re back. Last time, we talked about the catcher battle and the outfield hierarchy. Now, let’s zoom in on that infield logjam. Willy Adames is the anchor, but who else makes the team? We have Christian Koss, Osleivis Basabe, Nate Furman, Marcelo Mayer, Brett Harris, and Shay Whitcomb.

Paul: It’s a numbers game, Amanda. You can only carry four infielders plus a utility guy. Adames is locked in at short. That leaves three spots for five players. Koss is the utility man—he plays multiple positions. So now we’re down to two spots for Basabe, Mayer, Harris, and Whitcomb.

Amanda: Marcelo Mayer is the hot name. If he’s ready, he’s a lock, right?

Paul: If he’s ready, yes. He’s a top-tier prospect. But the question is whether he’s ready for MLB pitching in April. If he’s not, Basabe might hold the job longer. Harris and Whitcomb are both third basemen, so they’re competing for one spot. Harris has more power, Whitcomb has more contact.

Amanda: So, it’s basically Adames, Koss, and Mayer as the core, with Harris or Whitcomb rounding it out? What about Furman?

Paul: Furman is the odd man out. He’s a defensive specialist with limited upside. Unless he proves he can hit, he’ll likely be sent to Triple-A. The Giants need to take risks on youth here. Mayer and Harris offer higher ceilings.

Amanda: That makes sense. They can’t afford to carry another defensive-only infielder when they’re trying to improve offensively. But what if Mayer isn’t ready? Then it’s Adames, Koss, Harris, and Whitcomb?

Paul: Then it’s a toss-up between Harris and Whitcomb. I’d give the edge to Harris because of his power. Offense wins games, and the Giants scored very little last year. They need that extra pop.

Amanda: Okay, so Harris gets the nod if Mayer is delayed. But what about the catching situation again? Because if Cavanaugh and Knizner split time, that affects the lineup construction.

Paul: Right. If they go with a platoon, they’ll likely bench one of them against left-handed pitching. That opens up a spot for a pinch-hitter or a DH. Bryce Eldridge could fill that role if he’s struggling in Triple-A.

Amanda: So, Eldridge as a DH/pinch-hit specialist? That’s an interesting use of his skill set.

Paul: It’s better than sitting on the bench. If he can provide occasional power bursts, he’s useful. But he’s not an everyday guy. His strikeout rate is too high for regular duty.

Amanda: Let’s talk about the pitching staff. Logan Webb is the ace. Who’s the #2? Yunior Marte, Miguel Mendez, Anthony Molina, Landen Roupp, Matt Wilkinson.

Paul: Matt Wilkinson has the best stuff, but he’s inconsistent. Roupp has a good fastball-slider combo. Mendez and Marte are more mid-rotation options. I think they’ll go with Wilkinson as the #2 if he’s healthy, otherwise Roupp.

Amanda: And the rest of the rotation? Is it wide open?

Paul: Mostly. They’ll need to develop Marte, Mendez, and Molina. But they’ll also likely sign a veteran starter, as we discussed. That veteran would slot into the #3 or #4 spot, giving Webb and Wilkinson the most innings.

Amanda: So, Webb, Wilkinson, and a new veteran form the top three? That sounds like a solid foundation.

Paul: It’s a good start. But they need depth. If any of those guys get injured—and let’s face it, the Giants have a history of that—they’ll be scrambling. They should add at least one more reliable arm.

Amanda: Agreed. Injury prevention and management will be key for Posey and the coaching staff. Okay, let’s pivot to the bullpen again. We mentioned Doval. Who’s next in line?

Paul: Ryan Walker has the best control. He’s a ground-ball pitcher, which is great for Webb. But he’s never been a full-time reliever. Beck and Brubaker are also options, but they’re risky. I think they’ll bring in a veteran setup man to bridge the gap to Doval.

Amanda: So, Doval closes, a veteran sets up, and the rest is a competition among the young arms?

Paul: Exactly. And Hentges and Sanmartin will be watching from Triple-A, waiting for their chance. If they dominate, they’ll get a call-up.

Amanda: Interesting. So, the bullpen is a mix of proven veterans and high-risk/high-reward rookies. It’s a bold strategy.

Paul: It’s a necessity. They don’t have the budget for a blockbuster bullpen overhaul. They have to develop what they have and hope for the best.

Amanda: Well, let’s hope for the best. Coming up, we’ll make our final roster cut predictions and discuss who’s trending up and down. Stay tuned.

Amanda: Welcome back. We’ve analyzed the catchers, the infield logjam, the outfield hierarchy, and the pitching staff. Now, it’s time to make some tough decisions. Who stays, and who goes? Let’s start with the roster cuts.

Paul: Okay, Amanda. Based on what we’ve discussed, here’s my projection. The core stays: Webb, Adames, Lee, Mayer (if ready), Doval, and Wilkinson. Those are your locks.

Amanda: And the cuts?

Paul: I think Nate Furman is gone. He’s too limited offensively. Also, Zachary Morgan might be non-tendered if they don’t see him as a long-term solution. And one of the third basemen, either Harris or Whitcomb, will be sent down.

Amanda: So, Furman, Morgan, and one 3B are out? What about the catchers? Cavanaugh vs. Knizner?

Paul: They’ll keep both. One as the starter, one as the backup. It’s safer given the injury history. But Morgan is on the bubble. If he doesn’t impress in camp, he’s out.

Amanda: Okay, so Morgan is the biggest risk. What about the bullpen? Who’s trending up?

Paul: Hentges and Sanmartin. They’re young, athletic, and have high ceilings. If they show command in spring training, they’ll be tough to send down. Also, Ryan Walker is trending up as a reliable setup option.

Amanda: And who’s trending down?

Paul: Cesar Perdomo and Braxton Roxby. They’ve struggled with consistency. Unless they turn it around quickly, they’ll be the first ones called upon for a trade or released. Also, Drew Gilbert might be trending down if he can’t secure an everyday outfield spot against Lee.

Amanda: So, Perdomo, Roxby, and maybe Gilbert are on the chopping block. What about the veterans? Are they safe?

Paul: Mostly. But if they sign a new veteran starter, the current ones might be displaced. Same for the bullpen—if they add a veteran closer, Doval’s role could change.

Amanda: Right. The front office has a lot of flexibility. They can shape the roster based on performance and needs. But ultimately, they need to win. And winning requires balance.

Paul: Exactly. They can’t rely solely on youth. They need a mix of experience and talent. That’s why I expect them to make a few strategic acquisitions in the offseason.

Amanda: So, we’re expecting trades? Free agency signings?

Paul: Both. They’ll likely target a veteran starter and a relief arm. Maybe a corner outfielder too. They need to fill the gaps we identified today.

Amanda: Okay, let’s summarize. Core: Webb, Adames, Lee, Mayer, Doval, Wilkinson. Cuts: Furman, Morgan, one 3B. Trending Up: Hentges, Sanmartin, Walker. Trending Down: Perdomo, Roxby, Gilbert. Sound right?

Paul: That’s a solid summary. It’s a team in transition, but with a clear path forward. If they execute well, they could be competitive by 2028.

Amanda: 2028. That’s two years away. Patience is key. But the foundation is being laid. And that’s something to be excited about.

Paul: Agreed. It’s not overnight, but it’s steady progress. And that’s how you build a contender.

Amanda: That’s it for today’s episode! We broke down the Giants’ roster battles, from the catcher competition to the infield logjam and bullpen uncertainties. Remember, the core is there, but the details matter. Thanks for listening to the Beatline Podcast Network. Please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you get your podcasts, and share this episode with a fellow Giants fan. Go Giants!