Giants Mailbag: Injury Woes, Catcher Battles & The Posey Standard

San Francisco Giants · 2026-10-09 · Beatline Sports Podcast Network

Amanda: Two thousand three hundred and seventy-nine days on the injured list. That is not a typo. That is the San Francisco Giants’ official stat line for 2026, and it’s enough to make any fan pull their hair out.

Paul: It’s a staggering number, Amanda. They ended the Dodgers' three-year reign as the league leaders in IL days. It’s a testament to durability from Los Angeles, but a massive hurdle for San Francisco’s development pipeline.

Amanda: Welcome to the Beatline Podcast Network! I’m Amanda, and this is your daily Giants mailbag. Paul, you’re back.

Paul: I am. We’ve got a lot to unpack today. We’re looking at the final standings, the roster battles ahead, and what Buster Posey is saying about the culture of this team.

Amanda: Here is what we are covering: First, we answer your questions about that historic injury toll and where it leaves the pitching staff. Second, we dive into the catcher competition between Drew Cavanaugh, Andrew Knizner, and Zachary Morgan. And third, we talk about the Pride Night controversy and how President of Baseball Ops Buster Posey wants to move forward.

Amanda: But before we get to the mailbag, I want to take thirty seconds to ask for your help. This show is free, daily, and made by fans who love baseball. If you’ve enjoyed our breakdowns of the Giants’ offseason outlook, please chip in via the link in the episode description. Your support keeps us independent and allows us to keep digging into these stories every single day. Thank you.

Paul: We appreciate it. Now, let’s get into the questions.

Amanda: Let’s start with Marcus in Denver, who asks: 'The Giants finished 65-97, fourth in the NL West. But the headline isn’t just the losses—it’s the injuries. How does having 2,379 IL days impact the rotation for next year? Do we even have a rotation?'

Paul: It’s the central question of the offseason. When you look at the current roster, you see Logan Webb, Yunior Marte, Miguel Mendez, Anthony Molina, Landen Roupp, and Matt Wilkinson. But the depth chart is thin. The injury count suggests that health is the biggest variable for 2027.

Amanda: Right. And we predicted last week that they would acquire a veteran starter. Given these numbers, is that still the right move?

Paul: Absolutely. You cannot rely on young arms like Roupp and Molina to eat innings if the history shows the team breaks down constantly. A veteran presence stabilizes the clubhouse and provides innings security. It’s about managing workload.

Amanda: Okay, @GiantsFan88 writes in: 'I saw the final game against the Dodgers. Alex Call hit an RBI double in the 10th and Andy Pages went yard. Does that give us hope for the future?'

Paul: It was a tough loss—ending the season with a 5-1 defeat—but those are young players finding their footing. Pages’ power is real. However, one game doesn’t erase the 65-97 reality. We need to see if that offensive spark can translate over a full season.

Amanda: Another question from Sarah in San Jose: 'What about the bullpen? Camilo Doval is there, but who else? Is JT Brubaker reliable?'

Paul: The bullpen is a mix of veterans and relievers-in-waiting. You have Tristan Beck, Duncan Davitt, Jason Foley, Trent Harris, Sam Hentges, Joel Kuhnel, Seth Lonsway, Cesar Perdomo, Braxton Roxby, Reiver Sanmartin, Carson Seymour, Dylan Smith, and Ryan Walker. It’s crowded. The challenge will be figuring out who fits in high-leverage spots.

Amanda: That is a long list. It sounds like camp will be intense for those relief spots.

Paul: Very intense. And remember, the league-wide trend with the ABS system means catchers are having more success challenging calls. Pitchers need to be precise from the start.

Amanda: Stick with us. We’re moving on to the position battles.

Amanda: Let’s talk catching. David in Oakland asks: 'Drew Cavanaugh, Andrew Knizner, Zachary Morgan. Who wins the job? And does Jung Hoo Lee affect this?'

Paul: Jung Hoo Lee is primarily an outfielder, so he doesn’t directly compete for catching duties. But his presence changes how you use your bench. For catching, it’s a competition between experience and upside. Knizner has MLB time. Cavanaugh has been in the system. Morgan is a prospect.

Amanda: Buster Posey mentioned the importance of leadership. Does that favor one guy?

Paul: Posey values defense and game-calling. If Cavanaugh has shown growth in framing and handling a pitching staff, he could edge it out. But Knizner’s versatility is valuable. It likely won’t be decided until spring training.

Amanda: Now, Mike in Sacramento asks about the infield. 'Willy Adames is the star. But who is playing second base? Osleivis Basabe? Nate Furman? Marcelo Mayer?'

Paul: This is a logjam. Willy Adames anchors the shortstop spot. Christian Koss is also there. For second base, Basabe offers speed. Furman is solid defensively. Mayer is a top-tier prospect but might need more seasoning. Expect some platoon splits here.

Amanda: And the outfield? We have Jonah Cox, Drew Gilbert, Grant McCray, Turner Hill, Bo Davidson, and Bryce Eldridge at DH.

Paul: Eldridge provides power from the DH slot. In the outfield, Gilbert and Cox are speed/defense guys. McCray has pop. Hill is left-handed. It’s a deep group. The manager will have to decide who gets the most at-bats based on matchups.

Amanda: One more from @BayAreaBall: 'Victor Bericoto is listed as LF. Is he ready for everyday play?'

Paul: Bericoto is young. He’ll likely split time or serve as a defensive replacement early on. The Giants aren’t rushing him. They’re focused on stability first.

Amanda: Alright, let’s shift gears. Brett in Palo Alto asks about the Pride Night controversy. 'Buster Posey said we need to learn from it. What happened, and what does it mean?'

Paul: Several players added Bible verses to their caps during Pride Night. Posey acknowledged the misstep. He emphasized that the organization needs to be more thoughtful about inclusivity. It’s a cultural lesson. The front office is taking ownership.

Amanda: It’s a reminder that being a pro team means representing all fans. Posey is clear: no more surprises. Communication is key.

Paul: Exactly. And it ties into the broader theme of accountability. Just like on the field, off-field decisions matter.

Amanda: Stay tuned. We’ve got a fun hypothetical coming up next.

Amanda: Let’s do a quick hypothetical. Lisa in San Francisco asks: 'If the Giants had stayed healthy all season, what would their record look like?'

Paul: Hard to say exactly, but 2,379 IL days is huge. That’s dozens of games missed by starters. If they’d played their best lineup consistently, they might have been .500. Maybe 81-81. But the core talent was there.

Amanda: So the potential is real. Now, lightning round. Question from Tom in SF: 'Who is the surprise breakout candidate for 2027?'

Paul: I’ll go with Marcello Mayer. If he gets consistent at-bats, his bat-to-ball skills could shine.

Amanda: Good pick. Next: 'Which pitcher has the highest ceiling?'

Paul: Miguel Mendez. His stuff is electric. If he refines his command, he could be a starter.

Amanda: Final one: 'Will the Giants make the playoffs in 2027?'

Paul: We projected 75-80 wins. That’s competitive, but probably not enough for October yet. It’s a building year.

Amanda: Fair assessment. One last thing from @SFBaseball: 'Sam McDowell died recently. He was a Giant legend. Any thoughts?'

Paul: Sam McDowell was a Hall of Fame caliber strikeout artist. Four AL strikeout titles. His later work as a counselor for athletes battling addiction was equally important. A true giant of the game, both on and off the field.

Amanda: Thank you for remembering him. His legacy endures.

Amanda: That’s our mailbag. We covered the injury woes, the catcher battle, the Pride Night lesson, and looked ahead to 2027.

Paul: Big offseason ahead. Acquiring that veteran starter is crucial. And keeping everyone healthy is the #1 priority.

Amanda: If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen. Share it with a fellow Giant fan.

Paul: We’ll be back tomorrow with more Giants coverage. Keep cheering loud.

Amanda: Go Giants!